Rothy’s Vs. Toms: Choosing Between Washable Flats and Casual Slip-Ons

When it comes to comfortable, versatile shoes for everyday wear, two brands stand out – Rothy’s and Toms. Both offer stylish flats and slip-ons perfect for lots of steps. But with different materials, silhouettes, and brand missions, should you go for Rothy’s or Toms?

In this in-depth comparison, we’ll look at the key differences between these popular brands. Discover how to choose the right lightweight, walkable shoe for your needs and style.

A Brief Comparison Table

ConstructionKnit fabric from recycled bottlesCanvas, suede, or fabric uppers
SilhouetteOnly ballet flatsMostly slip-ons
FitSnug, contouredRoomy, relaxed
ComfortLightly padded, flexibleMinimal cushioning
CareMachine washableSpot clean and hand wash
Price$125-$165 full price$40-$60 full price
SizingRuns narrowRuns large

Overview of Rothy’s and Toms

Rothy's Shoes
Rothy’s Shoes

First, let’s introduce the two brands.

Rothy’s makes women’s flats and loafers from recycled materials – primarily repurposed plastic water bottles. Their iconic ballet flats have a sleek silhouette with rounded toe and come in both solid colors and prints. Rothy’s are machine washable, reducing waste.

Toms pioneered the One for One giving model, donating a pair of shoes for every pair sold. They are known for slip-on styles for men and women, made of canvas or lightweight suede. Toms started with their classic espadrille design. Their selection has grown to include flats, wedges, boots, and sandals.

Both Rothy’s and Toms emphasize comfort, sustainability, and giving back through community programs.

Also Read: Comparison Between Nisolo And Thursday Boots.

Key Differences Between Tothy’s Ans Toms

Till now we discussed the basics information. Now let’s compare their shoes in detail.

  • Shoe Construction and Materials

The most noticeable difference between Rothy’s and Toms is the materials used to construct their comfortable footwear.

Rothy’s uppers are knit from 100% post-consumer recycled plastic bottles. This proprietary knitting process creates a stretchy, breathable feel. Insoles are made from recycled foam and cork. The outsoles are formed from repurposed rubber.

Toms uses fabrics like cotton, linen, and suede leather for classic espadrille and slip-on styles. Newer Toms flats and sandals may incorporate synthetic fabrics. Outsoles are made from rubber or jute depending on the silhouette.

For those prioritizing eco-friendly materials, Rothy’s recycled knit construction stands out. Toms does not emphasize sustainability in the same way, although some of their shoes use recycled content.

In terms of durability, both brands make shoes suited for casual everyday wear, not intense activity. Rothy’s flats tend to hold their structure and last longer due to the sturdy knit fabric. Toms canvas can get dirty more easily and flatten over time with wear.

  • Style and Fit

Style preference often comes down to flats versus slip-ons when comparing Rothy’s and Toms. Let’s explore the key differences in silhouette and fit.

Rothy’s are exclusively ballet flats with round or pointed toe shapes. They come in solids and patterns ranging from neutrals to brights. Their slim profile and stretchy knit fabric create a snug contoured fit. Rothy’s shoes fit like socks and mold to your feet.

Toms are known for their slip-on only styles. Classics have a low vamp and exposed toe. Newer silhouettes like Driver and Mallow add rounded or pointed toe options. Toms casual vibe translates across patterns like batik as well as solids. Their slip-on fits tend to run big and feel roomy, especially with canvas uppers.

For a secure hug-your-foot feel, Rothy’s wins for fit. Those who don’t like a tight shoe may prefer the less constricting Toms slip-on styles. It comes down to personal preference for flats versus slip-ons.

Rothy’s have a more feminine aesthetic while Toms run unisex. Rothy’s variety of prints, patterns, and colors makes them feel more versatile to dress up or down. Toms earthy looks work for casual moments but may not elevate every outfit like a classic ballet flat.

  • Comfort and Support

Since you’ll likely be on your feet all day in these shoes, comfort is key. How do Rothy’s and Toms stack up?

Toms shoes

Rothy’s knit fabric upper molds softly to your feet without irritation. The round toe shape gives toes room to relax. Cushy insoles provide arch support. However, some find the minimalist flat silhouette lacks ample cushioning or shock absorption long-term. Rothy’s flats won’t replace athletic shoes for serious walks.

Toms slip-on styles feel instantly broken-in and flexible. The open toe and roomy fit allow feet to spread out unconfined. Their lightweight sole works well for short strolls but offers minimal arch support. Constraining the heel can help avoid flip-flop feel. Those with high arches may require added insoles for substantive cushion.

For plush softness that hugs feet, Rothy’s win for comfort. But Toms relaxed fit prevents any pinching or squeeze. Try both brands to see which foot feel you prefer for all-day wear.

  • Washability and Care

Here’s a surprise benefit – you can toss Rothy’s in the washing machine, while Toms require more typical fabric care.

Thanks to their knit construction, Rothy’s shoes are completely washable on gentle cycle. Just remove insoles first. The material doesn’t absorb odor, so you can freshen shoes frequently to keep them like new. Stains and dirt wash away easily.

Toms need to be spot cleaned by hand to avoid damaging the materials. You’ll have to scrub stains as they occur to prevent setting in. To freshen, spray with antibacterial products or use specialized shoe cleaning kits. Toms insoles can be removed and washed separately as well.

For low maintenance and fresher shoes, Rothy’s are the clear winner for easy care and washability. Toms require more time and elbow grease to clean.

  • Cost Comparison

With different materials and brand reputations, how do Rothy’s and Toms compare price-wise?

Rothy’s flats cost $125-$165 full-price for their classic styles. Limited editions run $195-$245. Considering their sustainable construction and durable design, the price reflects the quality that enables years of wear.

Toms classics and slip-ons cost $40-$60 full retail. More fashion-forward and embellished styles run up to $100. Toms remain one of the most affordable casual footwear options. Sales bring prices well under $50.

For budget shoppers, Toms better pricing makes them an easy choice. Rothy’s price point feels justified for a long-term investment in comfort and sustainability. Sign up for both brands’ emails to snag sale deals!

Also Read: Differences Between See Kai Run And Robeez Baby Shoes.

  • Sizing and Fit Insights

Finding your ideal size in both Rothy’s and Toms takes some trial and error. Check out these top sizing tips:

Rothy’s sizing advice:

  1. Start with your regular size for an exact fit or size up for a roomier feel.
  2. Wide width sizes are available. Rothy’s run narrow, especially pointed toes.
  3. They will feel snug at first but stretch to contour your feet.
  4. Try before you buy if possible. Free returns make it easy to exchange sizes.

Toms sizing tips:

  1. Size down for a secure fit, especially in canvas slip-on styles.
  2. Newer pointed and rounded flats tend to run truer to size.
  3. Leather or suede styles that show toes may fit larger.
  4. Take out the removable insoles and stand on them to check your fit.
  5. Wearing socks can help tighten up a loose fit.

Watch this review video:

Rothy’s and Toms Pros and Cons

To recap the key differences between the two brands:

Rothy’s Pros:

  • Sustainable construction from recycled plastic
  • Machine washable for easy care
  • Stylish pointed and rounded flats
  • Snug contoured fit that molds to feet
  • Durable knit fabric holds structure well

Rothy’s Cons:

  • Only offer feminine ballet flat styles
  • Runs narrow, pointed toe especially
  • Expensive $125+ price point
  • Lacks cushioning for extended wear

Toms Pros:

  • Iconic slip-on styles feel laidback and casual
  • Roomy fit allows feet to spread naturally
  • Inexpensive around $50 full price
  • Easy to find on sale under $40
  • Unisex styling works for him or her

Toms Cons:

  • Canvas and suede scuff and show wear
  • Minimal arch support or cushion
  • Sizing can run quite large
  • Hand wash care only to preserve materials

Also Read: Comparison Between Oofos And Cloud Slides.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Do Rothy’s have enough support?

Rothy’s slim flats prioritize lightweight flexibility and comfort over substantial arch or heel support. If you need more cushioning, add removable footbeds or opt for a slip-on silhouette from the brand.

How do I make my Rothy’s more comfortable?

Try these tips to break in stiff Rothy’s:
Wear with socks initially for a less snug feel, Apply moisturizer inside to reduce friction, Stretch them gently over your knee, Wear for short periods to gradually widen.

What is so special about TOMS?

TOMS is known for feel-good giving back through their One for One program that donates shoes, sight services, and safe water with every purchase. Their slip-on styles launched a casual chic trend.

Do TOMS stretch after wearing?

Yes, Toms canvas and suede styles will stretch and form to your feet over time. New slip-ons should feel snug but not pinching. Wear thick socks at first if too tight. Leather Toms mold less than fabric varieties.

Final Thought

Now that you know the nitty gritty on these two popular comfort brands, you can decide whether easygoing Toms or sophisticated Rothy’s better match your personal style and needs.

For an eco-friendly ballet flat that outfits dress up or down, Rothy’s reusable knits bring versatile comfort. Those after laidback slip-ons with a relaxed vibe will love Toms range of prints and patterns.

With details on sizing, styling, and care for both brands, you can confidently pick the right shoe for all-day wear. Don’t forget to take advantage of sales so you can alternate Rothy’s and Toms for a comfortable footprint!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.