Vinyl records have seen a major resurgence in popularity over the last decade. With so many great turntables to choose from, it can be tough deciding which one is right for your needs and budget.
Two of the most popular options are the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO and Audio-Technica’s lineup of turntables. But which one should you buy?
Here is a comprehensive comparison of the key features and performance of the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO and Audio-Technica turntables to help you choose the best fit.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO | Audio-Technica |
| Type | Belt drive | Both belt drive and direct drive models |
| Price | $499 | $99 – $1,199 |
| Motor | DC motor | High torque motors |
| Platter | 8.6” aluminum platter | Die-cast aluminum platters |
| Cartridge | Carbon tonearm, Ortofon 2M Red | AT-VM95E on cheaper models, AT-VM540ML on high end model |
| Adjustable Counterweight | Yes | Varies by model |
| Anti-Skate Control | Yes | Varies by model |
| Built-in Phono Preamp | No | Select models have USB output |
| Auto Stop | No | Some models |
| Speeds | 33/45 RPM | 33/45 RPM |
| Design | Minimalist | Vintage inspired |
Overview of the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO
The Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO is an elegant, easy to use turntable that delivers excellent sound quality. Here are some key details about the Debut Carbon EVO:
- Belt driven turntable with 8.6” aluminum platter
- Ortofon 2M Red moving magnet cartridge pre-installed
- 8.6” carbon fiber tonearm is lightweight and stiff for accurate tracking
- Precision belt drive with DC motor for smooth rotation and speed consistency
- Adjustable counterweight and anti-skating control for proper cartridge alignment
- Minimalist aesthetics with piano black or walnut finish options
- Manufacturer recommended price of $499
Pros of the Debut Carbon EVO:
- Outstanding audio quality that rivals turntables costing much more
- Easy set up out of the box and simple plug-and-play operation
- Carbon tonearm provides detailed and dynamic sound
- Quality Ortofon 2M Red cartridge included
- Speed consistency from precision belt drive system
- Great build quality with optimally tuned chassis
Cons:
- Manual speed change between 33 and 45rpm
- No auto stop function
- No on-board phono preamp
- Basic design may not appeal to those wanting a more vintage turntable aesthetic
Overview of Audio-Technica Turntables
Audio-Technica offers a wide range of turntables spanning budget models to high-end audiophile players. They are known for quality cartridges and durable turntables. Here are some key factors about Audio-Technica turntables:
- Models range from basic $99 turntables to $1,199 high-end turntables
- Most models are belt drive but some direct drive models are available
- Die-cast aluminum platters provide inertness and damping
- High torque motors optimize speed consistency
- Most models have adjustable counterweights and anti-skating
- Cartridges vary from basic AT-VM95E to high-end AT-VM540ML
- Select models have USB output to digitize vinyl
- Vintage aesthetics on most models
- Automatic stop on some models
Pros:
- Wide selection of turntables spanning a broad price range
- Excellent value on entry-level models
- High quality cartridges made by Audio-Technica
- Sturdy construction for smooth, quiet operation
- Direct drive on some models for DJ/mixing use
- Modern convenience features like USB output on certain models
- Appealing vintage styling
Cons:
- Sound quality and features vary greatly by price
- Entry models may lack adjustable counterweight or anti-skating
- Changing speeds requires moving the belt manually
- Basic models prone to vibration without isolation feet
- No built-in phono preamps on most models
Key Differences Between the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO and Audio-Technica
· Sound Quality
The Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO delivers audiophile-level sound quality that outperforms turntables costing much more. Its Ortofon 2M Red cartridge and stiff, lightweight carbon fiber tonearm produce detailed highs, warm midrange, and accurate bass reproduction.
The precision belt drive system ensures unwavering speed consistency for superior sound across the entire frequency range.
Audio-Technica turntables sound quality varies widely based on the model and price point. Budget models under $200 have decent sound but lack the refinement of the Pro-Ject. Mid-range AT turntables offer clearer audio with improved tonearms and cartridges.
The high-end AT-LP7 has superb audio quality on par with the Pro-Ject thanks to its microline stylus and damped chassis. Overall the Debut Carbon EVO provides better, more accurate sound than similarly priced Audio-Technica models.
· Build Quality and Design
The Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO is built from high quality materials including the MDF chassis, aluminum platter, and carbon fiber tonearm. It has an optimized low-resonance design for quiet vinyl playback. The minimalist aesthetic and piano lacquer finish give it an elegant, contemporary look.
Audio-Technica turntables generally have a vintage, retro inspired design. Die-cast aluminum platters and metal tonearms provide durability on most models. Budget models have more plastic parts that can affect acoustics and overall fit and finish.
The higher-end AT turntables have excellent build quality with damped metal platters and vibration damping. Those wanting a more classic turntable aesthetic may prefer the look of the Audio-Technicas.
· Features and Controls
The Debut Carbon EVO has a simple plug-and-play design but includes key adjustments for proper setup like the counterweight and anti-skating dial.
It lacks convenience features like auto-stop or built-in phono preamp, but this preserves sound purity. The outboard power supply isolates noise and vibration. Setup is quick with included instructions.
Audio-Technica turntables vary widely in features based on price. Budget models under $200 have basic operation with preset tracking force and no adjustable anti-skate. Mid-range models add adjustable counterweights, anti-skating, and sometimes auto stop.
High-end AT turntables match the Pro-Ject in adjustability for balance and alignment. Some models have USB output and selectable phono pre-amps for more flexibility. Button controls and detachable power cords add convenience.
· Ease of Use
The Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO is very easy to setup straight out of the box. After removing the transportation screws and plugging in the power and RCA cables, it’s ready play records with no adjustments needed to get excellent sound.
The simple design means there are no complicated controls to learn. Upgrading or replacing the cartridge is straightforward when needed.
Audio-Technica turntables range from basic plug-and-play operation on inexpensive models to more involved setup on higher-end turntables. Having to balance the tonearm and dial in tracking force and anti-skate on certain models makes initial setup more difficult.
Changing speeds by moving the belt manually can also be tricky. Those new to vinyl may prefer the easier operation of the Debut Carbon EVO.
· Cost and Value
With an MSRP of $499, the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO provides exceptional performance and build quality for the price. It outperforms turntables costing twice as much.
The included Ortofon 2M Red cartridge is a $100+ value itself. This makes the Debut Carbon EVO a fantastic value compared to competitors.
Audio-Technica turntables range greatly in price from $99 to over $1000. Budget models under $200 are a good value for casual listening. However, mid-range models around $300+ offer better fidelity and features.
The high-end AT-LP7 at $1199 compares well to the Pro-Ject in quality. Overall the Debut Carbon EVO provides better bang for your buck, but AT has more flexibility across price points.
Also Watch This Review Video:
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Yes, the impressive sound quality, clever engineering, and high-end components of the Debut Carbon EVO make it worth the $499 asking price. It outperforms most turntables under $1000.
Pro-Ject and Rega both make excellent turntables. Pro-Ject gives you more value for the money. Rega turntables have slightly warmer sound but cost much more. For the price, Pro-Ject provides better performance and features.
Audio-Technica makes quality turntables, especially their mid-range and high-end models. Their decades of experience result in good sound and reliability. Entry level AT turntables have more compromises but are good starter tables.
No, the Debut Carbon Evo does not have a built-in phono preamp. You need to use a separate phono preamp or a receiver with phono input. This avoids sound degradation from cheap preamps and allows using higher quality outboard preamps.
Final Thoughts
For listening to vinyl at home, I believe the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO is the better choice between these two great turntable options. It provides audiophile-level performance at a reasonable price that no Audio-Technica turntable under $1000 can quite match.
Superior acoustics, thoughtful engineering, and elegant minimalist design make the Debut Carbon EVO a product that outperforms its price tag.
While Audio-Technica makes quality turntables across many price points, none have the magic combination of sound and value of the Pro-Ject. For discerning music lovers getting into vinyl, the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO is a perfect place to start the journey.
