Clean, filtered water is essential for healthy living. For homeowners seeking to purify their entire water supply, Leaf and Culligan both offer whole house water filtration systems. But with different technologies, pricing, and services, how do you choose?
This guide compares Leaf Home Water Solutions and Culligan head-to-head. Read on to learn the pros, cons, and key differences to pick the ideal whole house system for your needs.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Category | Leaf Home Water | Culligan |
| Founded | 2021 | 1936 |
| Filtration Technology | Multi-stage: sediment, carbon, UV, remineralization | Customized: RO, softeners, carbon, specialty |
| Contaminant Removal | Broad spectrum of common contaminants | Handles hundreds of specific contaminants |
| Installation | DIY or professional | By Culligan technicians |
| Monitoring | Leaf app tracks usage | Add-on smart monitoring available |
| Water Waste | Low water waste | High waste from reverse osmosis |
| Pricing | Purchase $699+ with subscription filters | Lease $30+/month or purchase $500+ |
| Maintenance | Self-service | Handled by Culligan |
| Service Network | Online direct + authorized dealers | Culligan technicians |
Overview of Leaf Home Water Solutions
Founded in 2021, Leaf is a relative newcomer providing modern whole house water filters focused on removing contaminants without using harsh chemicals.
Their systems use a 5-stage filtration process combining carbon filtration, UV light disinfection, and mineralization to reduce microplastics, chlorine, pharmaceuticals, and other emerging water pollutants. Leaf filters out the bad while retaining healthy minerals.
Monitoring your home’s water usage and filter status is easy with Leaf’s integrated mobile app. Their subscription model sends new filters when needed. Installation is DIY or can be professionally handled.
Here are some quick facts on Leaf Home Water:
- Headquarters: Los Angeles, CA
- Founded: 2021
- Filtration method: 5-stage carbon, UV, mineralization
- Pricing: $699-$1,549 upfront + subscription
- Installation: DIY or professional
- App integrations: Leaf smart app
Leaf aims to make whole home filtration easy, modern and sustainable for today’s water quality threats.
Overview of Culligan Water
Culligan is an established water treatment pioneer dating back to 1936. Their solutions run from water softeners and drinking water filters to customizable whole house systems.
Culligan systems use a variety of filtration methods including reverse osmosis, activated carbon, and ion exchange to remove sediment, chlorine, heavy metals, and scale. Specialty filters are available for problems like iron, sulfur, and hard water.
You can lease or purchase Culligan hardware and sign up for ongoing replacement filter deliveries. Installation and maintenance are handled by Culligan technicians. Overall, Culligan offers more robust customization for whole house needs.
Some Culligan Water quick facts:
- Headquarters: Rosemont, IL
- Founded: 1936
- Filtration methods: Reverse osmosis, activated carbon, ion exchange, more
- Pricing: Lease from $30+/month, purchase $500+
- Installation: By Culligan technicians
- App integrations: Optional smart home monitoring
With decades of expertise, Culligan is the established leader in water solutions.
Also Read: Comparison Between Primo Water And Culligan Water
Leaf vs Culligan: Key Differences
Now let’s compare Leaf and Culligan’s whole house systems head-to-head:
- Filtration Technology
Leaf uses a streamlined filtration system combining carbon block and sediment filters, UV sanitization, and remineralization. It’s optimized for simplicity.
Culligan draws from a large menu of filtration options like reverse osmosis, Water Softener, and specialty filters to target specific contaminants. More customizable.
- Contaminant Removal
Leaf effectively reduces chlorine, particulates, microplastics, pharmaceuticals, and more. Limited filtering of heavy metals.
Culligan can tailor solutions for iron, lead, bacteria, nitrates, hardness, and hundreds of impurities. Broader contaminant removal.
- Installation & Maintenance
Leaf is designed for convenient DIY install or setup through Leaf’s network of local professionals. Their app guides maintenance.
Culligan requires installation by a technician. They handle all replacement filters and repairs through scheduled service. More hands-off.
- Convenience & Monitoring
Leaf’s system self-monitors use and filter status. The mobile app sends alerts for replacement or service needs. Very convenient.
Most Culligan systems lack smart capabilities without an upgrade. Monitoring is through traditional servicing. Less automated.
- Water Waste
Leaf’s method doesn’t waste water like some filtration processes. Culligan’s reverse osmosis systems can use 3-4 gallons of water for every purified gallon.
- Taste Impact
Leaf claims their remineralization restores healthy minerals for pure taste. Culligan’s RO removes minerals, so an additive may be needed to improve taste.
Also Read: Comparison Between Brio and Primo
- Pricing
A Leaf whole house system starts at $699 to purchase with subscription filters from $59 per month.
Culligan owns their hardware, with whole house solutions leased for $30+ monthly or purchased starting around $500. Filter replacements included.
Culligan offers unlimited customization but with higher pricing. Leaf is cost-effective for basic whole home filtration.
Also Watch This Review Video:
Pros and Cons of Leaf vs Culligan
| Leaf | Culligan | |
| Pros | – Simple modern filtration- Effective at removing common contaminants- DIY installation & maintenance- App monitoring integration- Lower monthly costs | – Broadest contaminant filtration- Custom solutions for any issue – Professional installation & service- Established brand with 70+ years of expertise |
| Cons | – Limited to basic filtration- Minimal smart home integrations- Short company track record- Limited dealer network | – Hardware purchases required- Higher monthly costs- Water waste from RO systems- Unpredictable servicing fees |
Also Read: Comparison Between ReadyRefresh And Sparkletts
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
There are a few reasons why Culligan water filtration systems are considered better than competitors:
Culligan has decades of expertise optimizing water filtration technologies for homes and businesses with unique needs. Their solutions can handle hundreds of specific water contaminants. Culligan offers completely customized whole house systems combining water softeners, reverse osmosis, activated carbon, and specialty filters to match each home’s water issues. Professional installation and ongoing service by Culligan technicians make it hassle-free. They monitor and replace filters on schedule.
Culligan is a reputable American brand trusted by consumers for over 85 years. Their products are tried and tested.
The ‘best’ whole home water purification system depends on your water quality issues and needs. Top options include: Reverse osmosis – Best for contaminant removal, Activated carbon filtration – Great for chlorine and chemicals, Water softeners – Ideal for hard water and scale, Multi-stage systems – Combine technologies for comprehensive filtration, Culligan offers fully customized solutions using the right filtration technologies for a household’s unique water situation. Leaf and Pelican provide more standardized systems at lower costs.
With Culligan systems, water quality is excellent. Their filtration methods like reverse osmosis, activated carbon, and specialty filters remove up to 99% of trace impurities, while water softeners reduce scale buildup. Culligan reduces lead, chlorine, pesticides, sulfur, iron, unpleasant odors and tastes, cloudiness, and bacteria. Their customized systems let homes match filtration to their local water quality issues. The result is clean, clear, healthy water.
The Leaf whole house water system uses a multiple filtration stages: Sediment filter traps particulate matter like dirt, rust, sand. Activated carbon block filter adsorbs chemicals like chlorine and pesticides.
UV light disinfects pathogens like bacteria. Remineralization adds healthy minerals back like calcium and magnesium. Final carbon polishing ensures clean, mineralized water. The easy-to-replace filter cartridge connects to the main water supply line. Leaf’s app monitors usage and alerts you when a new filter is needed based on gallons filtered. It’s an intuitive ‘set it and forget it’ whole home system.
Also Read: Choose Between Apec RO-Hi And RO-90.
Final Thought
Here are a few key considerations when deciding between Leaf and Culligan whole house systems:
- Leaf is ideal if you want modern filtration of common pollutants at an affordable price. Culligan offers extreme customization better suited to unique water problems.
- DIY installation makes Leaf more convenient. Culligan’s professional install and servicing provides white-glove treatment.
- Leaf suits health-conscious households looking to remove chlorine, microplastics, and pharmaceuticals. Culligan can address specialized issues like iron, sulfur, bacteria, and scale.
- Leaf’s lower monthly pricing and app monitoring make maintenance easy. Culligan’s higher service costs provide routine visits by experts.
For most households seeking safe, clean water with some DIY, Leaf Home Water is a budget-friendly option. Culligan excels at robust solutions for difficult residential water problems.