When it comes to outfitting your home with quality furniture, Stanton and Ashley are two of the most well-known brands on the market today. But which one offers the best value, style, and durability for your money?
Here, we’ll compare these two popular furniture retailers across some key categories to help you decide which is better for your needs.
A Brief Comparison Table Of Stanton And Ashley Furniture
| Features | Stanton | Ashley |
| Manufacturing Location | USA | Mostly overseas |
| Average Pricing | $1,000-$3,000 | $500-$2,000 |
| Construction Quality | Excellent, premium materials | Fair to good, some durability issues |
| Style Focus | Modern, contemporary | Traditional, classic Americana |
| Customization Options | Modular sectionals, storage pieces | Wide range of sectionals, bedrooms, dining sets |
| Sustainability | Good – domestic production, responsible materials | Not a focus – larger transport footprint |
| In-Store Experience | Smaller showrooms, personalized | Massive selection under one roof |
| Warranties | Lifetime frame, 5 years cushions | Tiered plans from 1-15 years |
Overview Of Stanton Furniture
Stanton is an American furniture manufacturer founded in 1971 and based in California. They specialize in contemporary, modern designs across living room, dining room, and bedroom collections.
Some key things to know:
- Stanton furniture is designed and crafted in the USA. They pride themselves on finely built pieces made from quality North American hardwoods and upholstered in stain-resistant fabrics.
- The brand is sold through authorized retailers as well as their own Stanton Home Furniture stores across the country. This allows you to try out their furniture in person.
- Stanton offers customizable options for many pieces like sectionals, cabinets, and storage ottomans so you can tailor pieces to your space.
- Price-wise, Stanton sits solidly in the mid-to-upper bracket – more expensive than mass market brands but not as costly as high-end designer furniture. Expect to spend $1,000-$3,000 for sofas and sectionals.
Overview Of Ashley Furniture
Ashley Furniture Industries is one of the largest furniture manufacturers in the world, headquartered in Wisconsin. They offer a wide range of styles from traditional to contemporary across living room, dining room, and bedroom furniture.
Some quick facts:
- The majority of Ashley furniture is manufactured abroad to keep costs low, and they have factories and operations in countries like China and Indonesia.
- Ashley sells through their own HomeStore locations as well as major retailers like Rooms to Go and Amazon. This makes them widely accessible.
- As a mass market brand, their furniture is on the affordable side, with living room pieces ranging from $500-$2000.
- They offer extensive customization options for sectionals, office chairs, beds, and entertainment centers.
Features Comparison Between Stanton And Ashley Furniture
Quality And Craftsmanship
When it comes to quality and durability, Stanton furniture tends to edge out Ashley.
Stanton uses thick, kiln-dried North American hardwoods and eight-way hand-tied coil spring systems in their upholstered pieces. This results in good sturdiness and longevity. Their items also undergo rigorous testing to meet performance standards.
By contrast, some of Ashley’s overseas-manufactured furniture has received complaints over the years for flimsy materials, weak joining, and durability issues. That said, they have worked to improve quality control in recent years. Their North American-made pieces tend to be of better construction.
Winner: Stanton for better materials and construction quality that will last years longer than some Ashley lines.
Also Read: Comparison Between Bob’s And Ashley Furniture.
Style Aesthetic
Both Stanton and Ashley offer a range of style options from modern to farmhouse classic. However, Stanton excels at contemporary, modern designs while Ashley has more traditional Americana styles.
Stanton’s sleek sectionals, modular sofas, and angular accent chairs have a chic, urban aesthetic perfect for modern spaces. Their minimalist, neutral color schemes help them fit in with any décor.
Ashley has all the classics covered for traditional homes, from ornate dining chairs to floral upholstered sofas to rustic farm tables. Their looks lean towards cushiony, curved silhouettes and detailed finishes.
So if you like a pared-down, modern look, Stanton will have more options to suit your taste. For traditional cozy charm, Ashley has the selection.
Winner: Tie – comes down to personal style preference!
Customization Options
Both brands offer ample ways to tailor their furniture to your needs and style through customizable options.
Stanton sectionals can be configured with multiple chaise, arm, and corner pieces. Their storage ottomans and media consoles come in multiple colors and layouts.
Ashley is known for their highly customizable sectionals featuring a wide range of layouts, fabrics, and features like power reclining or USB ports. Their bedroom and dining collections also have options to pick finishes and upholstery.
No matter which brand you choose, you’re sure to find the exact shape, size, and features you want for a personalized fit.
Winner: Tie – both allow for significant customization of their core furniture lines.
Watch the video to learn more!
Price And Value
For price, Ashley Furniture has the advantage as the more budget-friendly brand. Stanton’s higher-end materials and American production lead to higher price tags.
Ashley sofas and sectionals can be found for $500 to $1,500, making them an attractive option for shoppers on a tighter budget. You pay less for their imported manufacturing.
Stanton’s comparable pieces run from $1,500 up to $3,500. But the adage “you get what you pay for” applies – you’re getting higher-end features and construction. Their quality materials and craftsmanship make pieces that will last.
For sheer value, Ashley has an edge. But Stanton delivers good long-term value too if it fits within your budget.
Winner: Ashley offers better budget value, while Stanton provides excellent quality/price ratio at the higher end.
Environmental Sustainability
Eco-conscious shoppers will appreciate that Stanton has an edge when it comes to environmental practices and sustainability.
Their locally-made furniture means shorter shipping distances and a smaller carbon footprint. Stanton uses responsibly-sourced woods and some eco-friendly materials like soy-based foam cushioning. They avoid certain harmful chemicals and emissions in production.
Ashley, as a volume manufacturer abroad, is not as transparent about sustainability initiatives or supply chain impacts. Most of their furniture travels long distances by ship which has a higher environmental impact.
So while environmentally-friendly manufacturing is not Ashley’s strong suit, Stanton makes noticeable efforts to be greener. Those concerned with eco-friendliness may find Stanton the better choice.
Winner: Stanton for their comparatively smaller carbon footprint and green production.
In-Store Experience
Both brands give you the option to try out their furniture in person before you buy. Stanton has a network of authorized retailers carrying their lines across the country. Ashley has nearly 1000 HomeStore locations to visit.
Trying pieces firsthand allows you to assess their comfort, construction, and sizing. Being able to see and feel options in person is a big perk.
Stanton’s in-store experience tends to be more personalized given their smaller exclusive retailer footprint. Ashley’s massive stores can feel overwhelming, though associate assistance is available. Their size allows massive furniture displays however.
For in-person shopping, Stanton likely provides a more tailored, intimate experience. But Ashley gives you ample selection under one roof. Either way, you can test options in real life.
Winner: Tie again – both allow you to try products out in dedicated retail spaces. Comes down to personal preference.
Read More: Comparison Between Allmodern And West Elm
Warranties And Policies
Strong customer service policies like warranties give peace of mind with big furniture purchases. Here’s how Ashley and Stanton compare:
- Stanton provides a limited lifetime warranty on frames and joints, 5 years on cushions, and 1 year on other upholstery parts.
- Ashley offers extensive tiered warranties up to 15 years depending on the item. Other policies range from 1-5 years for different components.
Both brands provide reasonable protections should defects arise. Stanton likely edges out for their lifetime frame/joint coverage. But Ashley isn’t far behind.
For returns and exchanges, both offer 30 days to return unused items. Delivery and shipping costs aren’t refunded.
When it comes to damage coverage, Ashley provides some advantage. Their policies refund or replace items damaged during delivery, while Stanton’s retailers may not cover transport damage.
All in all, both brands back up their products reasonably well. Ashley may cater slightly better to consumer concerns. But Stanton offers solid assurances too.
Winner: Ashley for broader damage coverage and thorough warranty tiers.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Yes, Stanton is considered a very good furniture brand, known for high-quality materials, detailed craftsmanship, and durable construction in their American-made pieces. They use premium hardwoods and upholstery that stand up well over years of use.
Stanton sectionals are built to last using kiln-dried hardwood frames and eight-way hand-tied spring supports. Their premium leathers and fabrics resist stains, wear, and tearing. So yes, their sectionals are of excellent quality and durability.
Some of the most durable living room furniture includes:
Solid wood or engineered hardwood frames instead of particle board or plastic. Maple, oak, and ash have strength,
Eight-way hand-tied springs in cushions for longevity and comfort,
Leather or high-performance, stain-resistant fabrics like polyester blends,
Durable finishes like powder coating or catalyzed varnish,
Reinforced joining with double doweling and corner blocks,
Following these tips when choosing sofas, recliners and sectionals helps maximize their lifespan.
Stanton sofas and furniture are owned by Stanton Home Furnishings, an American company founded in 1971 and headquartered in Los Angeles, California. They design their own pieces domestically which are handcrafted locally in California.
Read More: Comparison Between Rove Concepts And West Elm
Final Verdict: It Depends On Your Needs
When comparing Stanton and Ashley Furniture, there’s no universally “better” brand. The right choice depends on your budget, style, and priorities:
- For modern styles and locally-made quality, Stanton is ideal (if over budget). Their sleek silhouettes and carefully constructed furniture make long-lasting investment pieces.
- For classic American styles on a wallet-friendly budget, Ashley is the best bet. Their huge selection ensures traditional looks for the whole home.
- If environmental impact is important, Stanton’s greener domestic production gets the edge.
- For broad customization and warranty coverage, Ashley is preferable.
Weigh what’s most important for your home furniture. Getting to test options in person helps make the final call. Overall, Stanton offers superior materials and craftsmanship with a modern aesthetic.
Ashley provides great variety and customization at budget prices, though may fall short in longevity. Carefully considering your needs helps decide which brand is the better fit.
With their varied strengths, you’re sure to find durable, quality living room furniture with either of these popular American brands.
Weigh them against your own priorities to pick what truly suits your lifestyle and space. Happy furniture hunting!
