Coterie Vs. Water Wipes: Which Baby Wipes Are Better?

New parents have a lot of decisions to make when preparing for baby’s arrival. One of those is which baby wipes to use for diaper changes, faces, and hands. Two popular options are Coterie baby wipes and WaterWipes. 

But which one is better? Here’s an in-depth look at the key differences between Coterie and WaterWipes to help you decide.

A Brief Comparison Table

Ingredients99% purified water, chamomile extract99.9% purified water, grapefruit seed extract
TextureThick, texturedSoft, smooth
Cost per wipe$0.05$0.07
ScentUnscentedFaint grapefruit scent
PackagingSoft packsFlip-top dispenser packs
ProsHypoallergenic, pH balanced, affordable, durableUltra gentle, convenient dispenser, antimicrobial
ConsNo dispenser, limited scent optionsMore expensive, less ideal pH

Overview Of Coterie Baby Wipes

Coterie baby wipes were specially designed for baby’s sensitive skin. The wipes contain 99% water and 1% chamomile extract. They are pH balanced, hypoallergenic, dermatologist tested, and free from alcohol, parabens, sulfates, phthalates, and fragrances.

Some of the key features of Coterie wipes include:

  • 99% purified water: The high water content helps cleanse and moisturize skin during changes.
  • Chamomile extract: Chamomile is soothing on delicate skin and has anti-inflammatory properties.
  • pH balanced: Coterie wipes have a 5.5 pH, close to baby’s natural skin pH around 5. This helps maintain skin’s protective barrier.
  • Hypoallergenic: Less likely to cause any skin reactions or irritation.
  • Dermatologist tested: Approved as safe for baby’s skin.
  • Thick and durable: Each wipe is thick and textured to efficiently clean messes.

Coterie wipes come in convenient soft packs that can be tossed in your diaper bag. They are gentle enough for newborns but durable enough for bigger messes as baby gets older.

Overview Of Waterwipes

WaterWipes are also designed for delicate newborn skin. As the name suggests, these wipes contain 99.9% purified water and just a drop of fruit extract. The key highlights include:

  • 99.9% water: Ultra purified water is the main cleansing ingredient.
  • Fruit extract: WaterWipes contain a drop of grapefruit seed extract which acts as a mild cleanser.
  • pH neutral: pH of 7, same as water, to avoid disrupting skin’s acid mantle.
  • Hypoallergenic: Does not contain common allergens like fragrance, soap, or alcohol.
  • MBT free: No methylisothiazolinone or methylchloroisothiazolinone.
  • Naturally biodegradable: Breaks down easily and sustainably.

WaterWipes are soft, gentle, and suitable for premature babies, eczema-prone skin, and newborns. The wipes come in a resealable flip-top pack.

Also Read: Is Water Wipes Better Than Kirkland Wipes?

Comparison Between Coterie And Waterwipes

Now let’s compare some of the key factors between Coterie and WaterWipes wipes:


  • Coterie: 99% water, chamomile extract
  • WaterWipes: 99.9% water, grapefruit seed extract
Water Wipes

Both wipes use purified water as the main ingredient. Coterie adds soothing chamomile while WaterWipes has antimicrobial grapefruit extract.

pH Level

  • Coterie: pH 5.5
  • WaterWipes: pH 7

Coterie wipes have an acid-mantle friendly pH closer to baby’s natural skin pH. WaterWipes are pH neutral like water.


  • Coterie: Thick and textured
  • WaterWipes: Soft and smooth

Coterie wipes have a thicker, textured feel while WaterWipes are known for their silky soft texture.


  • Coterie: Approximately $0.05 per wipe
  • WaterWipes: Approximately $0.07 per wipe

Coterie wipes are more affordable, especially when purchased in bulk bundles. WaterWipes have a slightly higher per wipe cost.


  • Coterie: Unscented
  • WaterWipes: Faint grapefruit scent

Both wipes are free of artificial fragrances. Coterie has no scent while WaterWipes have a light citrus scent.

Dispenser Packs

  • Coterie: Soft packs only
  • WaterWipes: Flip-top dispenser packs

Coterie wipes come in soft packs while WaterWipes offers a convenient flip-top dispenser pack.

Also Read: Is Depend Protection Plus Better Than FIT Flex?

Coterie Wipes Pros And Cons

Pros of Coterie wipes:

  • Hypoallergenic and dermatologist tested
  • pH balanced for skin protection
  • Chamomile extract is soothing
  • Thick and durable
  • More affordable per wipe cost
  • 99% purified water base

Potential cons of Coterie wipes:

  • Only available in soft packs, no flip-top dispenser
  • Limited scent options
  • Less water content than WaterWipes

Waterwipes Pros And Cons

Pros of WaterWipes:

  • 99.9% purified water is ultra gentle
  • Dispenser pack is convenient
  • Soft, smooth texture
  • Grapefruit extract has cleansing properties
  • pH neutral like water

Potential cons of WaterWipes:

  • Slightly more expensive per wipe
  • Less ideal pH for baby’s skin
  • Not as thick as Coterie wipes
  • Faint scent not ideal for sensitive skin

Also watch this video!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is coterie wipes worth it?

Coterie wipes are a great option for baby’s delicate skin. The hypoallergenic formula, pH balance, and chamomile extract make them very gentle and effective. For the price, Coterie wipes are worth considering.

Are water-based wipes better?

Wipes with a high water content like Coterie and WaterWipes are ideal. The purified water base cleanses without drying out baby’s skin. Both Coterie and WaterWipes have over 99% water.

What is the best substitute for WaterWipes?

Coterie wipes are a great alternative to WaterWipes. Other water-based wipes like Babyganics or Amazon Elements baby wipes also make good substitutes.

What’s the difference between WaterWipes and regular baby wipes?

WaterWipes have a 99.9% purified water base while regular wipes often contain cleansing agents, fragrances, and preservatives. The ultra-purified water makes WaterWipes gentler.

Also Read: Differnces Between Huggies Simply Clean And Natural Care.

The Verdict

For ultimate gentleness, WaterWipes with their 99.9% water content are hard to beat. But Coterie wipes offer a similar 99% water formula at a more affordable price point. Both wipes are non-irritating, hypoallergenic, and PH balanced for baby’s skin.

The choice may come down to your priorities and budget. WaterWipes are extremely soft and come in a handy dispenser pack. But the thicker Coterie wipes clean messes efficiently at a lower cost per wipe. 

For mild cleansing power, chamomile extract in Coterie wipes is soothing while grapefruit extract in WaterWipes offers antimicrobial protection.

Whichever wipe you choose, you can feel confident Coterie and WaterWipes are both healthy, safe options for your baby’s delicate skin. With plenty of water and mild ingredients, both brands offer that magic wipe that effortlessly cleans your little one’s bottom and leaves their skin fresh, moisturized, and protected.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.