Finding the perfect tuxedo for your next special event can be a daunting task. Should you rent or buy? What style looks best? And where do you even begin searching for tuxedo options? Luckily, online tuxedo rental companies like Menguin and The Black Tux have made the process much easier.
With just a few clicks, you can browse styles, customize your tux, and have it delivered right to your door. But how do you decide between the two popular rental services?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll break down the key differences between Menguin and The Black Tux to help you determine the best tuxedo rental option for your needs. We’ll compare the styling and fit, pricing and fees, customer service and convenience, and overall ordering experience between the two competitors.
Whether you’re looking for a modern slim fit tux or a more traditional style, need to outfit a whole wedding party or just yourself, this Menguin versus The Black Tux comparison will help you make the best tuxedo rental choice as you shop for your next black-tie affair.
A Brief Comparison Table:
| Feature | Menguin | The Black Tux |
| Tuxedo Styles | Slim fit, classic fit | Slim, contemporary, traditional |
| Tuxedo Customization | Limited | Extensive options |
| Starting Rental Price | $95 | $115 |
| Included in Rental | Jacket, pants, shirt, tie, shoes | Jacket, pants, shirt |
| Extra Fees | $15 insurance per rental | None |
| Try At Home | No | Yes |
| Customer Service | Email, phone, virtual | Email, phone, chat, in-store |
| Delivery Timeframe | 1 week before event | Up to 2 months before |
Overview Of Menguin
Founded in 2014 in New York City, Menguin aims to “take the pain out of renting a tuxedo” by making the process simple, affordable, and enjoyable. They offer a selection of high-quality tuxedo styles, including modern slim fit and classic cut designs, for rental or purchase.
The easy-to-navigate website and user-friendly fitting process allows you to customize your tuxedo, with options like lapel style, jacket vent, and pants pleats. Once you place your order, Menguin will ship your rental tuxedo up to two weeks before your event using expedited shipping.
Overview Of The Black Tux
Launched in 2013 and headquartered in Los Angeles, The Black Tux seeks to disrupt the traditional tuxedo rental industry with an easy, online ordering experience. Their tuxedo selection includes slim, contemporary, and traditional fits to accommodate different body types and styles.
You can choose jacket linings, lapels, and other tuxedo components to customize your look. The Black Tux offers free home try-on for fit, expedited shipping, and quality dry cleaning for rentals.
Now that you have a basic introduction to both companies, let’s compare the key features side-by-side:
Menguin Vs. The Black Tux: Tuxedo Style And Fit Comparison
One of the most important factors when choosing a tuxedo rental is the style and fit. You want to look and feel your best, after all! Here is how Menguin and The Black Tux compare when it comes to tux designs and tailoring:
Menguin
- Offers slim fit and classic/traditional tuxedo styles
- Slim fit tux is trim through chest, waist and legs for a modern look
- Classic tux has more room through body and legs for comfort
- Both styles available in black and navy colors
- Some customization of lapels, vents, etc
The Black Tux
- Provides slim, contemporary, and traditional fit options
- Slim fit has narrow shoulders, trim waist, and skinny legs
- Contemporary is between slim and traditional fits
- Traditional cut allows more room in the chest and legs
- Black and navy tuxedos available across all fits
- Extensive tux customization choices
For the most modern, tailored look, both Menguin and The Black Tux’s slim fit tuxedos are great choices. Guys who prefer comfort and mobility over a snug fit may want to consider the classic (Menguin) or traditional (The Black Tux) styles. With more customization options, The Black Tux offers greater flexibility to get the exact tuxedo style and fit you desire.
Menguin Vs. The Black Tux: Pricing And Fees Comparison
Tuxedo rental pricing is another essential factor that can vary between providers. Here’s how Menguin and The Black Tux compare on rental costs:
Menguin
- Tuxedo rental packages from $95
- All rentals include jacket, pants, shirt, tie/bow tie, and shoes
- Extra fees for vests, accessories
- Rental prices increase closer to event date
- $15 insurance fee per rental
The Black Tux
- Rental packages starting at $115
- Tuxedo bundles include jacket, pants, shirt
- Vests, ties, and shoes available for added fee
- Rental prices go up as event nears
- No insurance fees on rentals
- Occasional discount promos available
Pricing is very similar between the two brands for standard tuxedo rental bundles. The Black Tux has a higher starting price, but offers frequent discounts and special offers that can make up the difference. Menguin’s mandatory insurance fee tacks on an additional $15 per rental. For large groups, those fees can add up. The Black Tux wins when it comes to the best overall value for standard tuxedo rentals. Of course, pricing varies based on tux style, customization options, and other factors. But both brands are competitively priced with one another.
Also watch the review video of Menguin!
Menguin Vs. The Black Tux: Customer Service And Convenience Comparison
Renting a tux online makes the process more convenient than going to a local brick-and-mortar shop. But customer service and support are still important in case any issues come up. Here’s how Menguin and The Black Tux compare when it comes to the convenience, accessibility, and service they provide:
Menguin
- Free shipping on orders
- Virtual appointments for style/fit help
- Email and phone customer service
- Minimal retail locations for in-person service
- Return tuxes by mail after event
The Black Tux
- Free at-home try-on and free returns
- Virtual and in-person appointments available
- 24/7 customer service via phone, email, chat
- Numerous retail stores across the US for fittings
- Prepaid return shipping label included
For customer service and convenience, The Black Tux is the winner. Their expansive retail network and around-the-clock customer support surpass the service options of Menguin. Home try-on for fit and complimentary return shipping also make The Black Tux the more convenient, accessible choice overall.
Menguin Vs. The Black Tux: Ordering And Delivery Experience
Placing your tuxedo order online and getting the gear delivered on time can make or break the rental experience. Here is how Menguin and The Black Tux compare when it comes to ordering and delivery:
Menguin
- Easy online ordering via website
- Virtual fit sessions to confirm size
- Expedited shipping as event nears
- Delivery as late as 1 week pre-event
The Black Tux
- User-friendly order process online
- Home try-on kits to test fit and sizing
- Rush delivery available last minute
- Ships up to 2 months prior to event
- Optional pickup at local retail store
Again, The Black Tux comes out ahead with more flexibility for fittings through their home try-on kits. The ability to confirm fit as early as 2 months before your event provides peace of mind. While Menguin also facilitates online orders and fast shipping, The Black Tux ultimately delivers better experience through their first-hand fit testing and expanded delivery timeline guarantees.
Also Read: Comparison Between Menguin And Generation Tux.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Menguin and Generation Tux are both online tuxedo rental companies with a similar business model. The main differences are that Generation Tux offers a fuller range of suit styles and colors beyond just tuxedos, while Menguin focuses specifically on tuxedo rentals.
Menguin provides two fit options (slim and classic) compared to Generation Tux’s three fits. Overall customer service, convenience and prices are comparable between the two brands.
The Black Tux’s main competitors in online tuxedo rentals include Menguin, Generation Tux, The Mr. Collection, and Tuxedo Rental USA. Brick-and-mortar tux shops like Men’s Wearhouse and David’s Bridal are also competitors. The Black Tux stands out for its selection of modern slim fit tuxedos, convenience of home try-on, and strong customer service.
As a broader men’s online formalwear rental company, Generation Tux competes with The Black Tux, Menguin, The Mr. Collection and Combatant Gentlemen. Their wide selection of suit styles and colors makes them stand out from tux-only focused companies.
Yes, The Black Tux offers several slim fit tuxedo styles to choose from. Their slim fit tuxes have narrow shoulders, a trim waist and skinny legs for a modern, tailored silhouette. The Black Tux slim fit styles include their Signature Suit, Premier Suit, and Bespoke Signature blue tuxedo.
Conclusion: The Better Tuxedo Rental Choice
After comparing the styling, pricing, service, and overall experience between Menguin Vs. The Black Tux, The Black Tux emerges as the winner for best online tuxedo rental provider. Their expansive fitting options, broad style selection that includes quality slim fit tuxedos, stellar customer service, and overall value make them our top pick.
Also Read: Comparison Between Generation Tux And Men’s Wearhouse.
However, savvy shoppers may be able to find Menguin rental deals and discounts that make the pricing more competitive. You can’t go wrong renting from either brand, but The Black Tux’s exceptional service and convenience give them the advantage.
Whichever online tuxedo rental company you choose, you’ll look dapper and elegant for your next formal affair. Both Menguin and The Black Tux offer an easy tux rental experience that beats the hassle of an in-person trip to a traditional tux shop. Just order your tuxedo online, test the fit when it arrives, and return it cleanly after your big event.
With an online tuxedo rental, you can focus on looking dashing and enjoying the occasion rather than stressing over your formalwear.