Clothing rental services like haverdash and nuuly are changing the way people shop for clothes. Instead of buying new outfits, you can rent clothes and accessories for a monthly fee.
This allows you to constantly refresh your wardrobe with new styles without breaking the bank or contributing to fast fashion waste.
But how do you decide between haverdash and nuuly? Here is an in-depth comparison of the pros, cons, features, and FAQs to help you determine which clothing rental service may be best for your needs and budget.
Key Differences Between Haverdash And Nuuly:
| Feature | Haverdash | Nuuly |
| Starting Price | $59/month for 3 items | $88/month for 6 items |
| Brands | 100+ brands including Reformation, Levi’s, Vince, Anthropologie | 1,000+ brands including Madewell, Levi’s, Anthropologie |
| Women’s Sizes | 0-16 | 00-26 including petite, maternity, plus |
| Men’s/Kids | No | Yes |
| Max Rental Period | No limit | 30 days |
| Shipping Time | 3-4 days | 1 business day |
| Mobile Apps | iOS only | iOS and Android |
| Purchase Rentals | No | Yes, at reduced cost |
Overview Of Haverdash And Nuuly
Haverdash and Nuuly are two popular monthly clothing and accessory rental subscription services. With both services, you select clothing and accessory styles from their online catalogs and they ship items to you.
You can wear the items as much as you want during your rental period, then return them for a new box of goods.
Haverdash
Some key things to know about Haverdash:
- Founded in 2016 and based in Los Angeles
- Rental plans start at $59 per month for 3 item rentals
- Brands include Reformation, Levi’s, Free People, Anthropologie, etc.
- Focused on women’s apparel and accessories
- Add-on options for maternity and kids clothing
Nuuly
Some key things to know about Nuuly:
- Founded in 2019 and based in New York
- Rental plans start at $88 per month for 6 item rentals
- Brands include Madewell, Levi’s, Anthropologie, Free People, Vince, etc.
- Focused on women’s apparel, accessories, maternity, petite, and plus sizes
- Add-on options for kids clothing
Detailed Comparison Of Haverdash And Nuuly:
Haverdash vs Nuuly: Rental Plans and Pricing
The rental plans and pricing are a major difference between haverdash and nuuly.
Haverdash offers two main plans:
- The Studio: $59 per month for 3 rentals
- The Collection: $89 per month for 5 rentals
You can add up to 2 kids items to The Collection plan for an additional $20 per month.
Nuuly has one main subscription plan:
- Nuuly Subscription: $88 per month for 6 rentals
You can add kids styles to the Nuuly plan for an additional $10 per month per item.
So at base pricing with no add-ons, Nuuly is $29/month more expensive than Haverdash’s lowest plan. However, you get twice as many styles (6 vs 3 per month) for that higher fee.
If maximizing the number of rentals is most important, Nuuly provides better value. But if you only want a few staple rentals each month, Haverdash gives more budget flexibility.
Nuuly also offers short-term plans:
- 1-Month Plan: $88 for 1 month of 6 rentals
- 3-Month Plan: $228 for 3 months of 6 rentals per month ($76/month)
Haverdash only has standard month-to-month plans.
Read More: Comparison Between Haverdash And Rent The Runway
Selection and Sizes
Both Haverdash and Nuuly offer trendy, coveted brands at affordable rental prices. However, there are some key differences in selections and sizes:
Haverdash focuses exclusively on womenswear in standard and petite sizes 0-16. They have over 100 brands including Reformation, Levi’s, Vince, Free People, Anthropologie, etc. You’ll find lots of stylish dresses, tops, bottoms, jackets, and accessories.
Nuuly has a wider selection of styles, sizes, and categories. They offer womenswear sizes 00-26 including standard, petite, plus, and maternity styles. There are also options for menswear and kids.
Popular brands include Madewell, Levi’s, Anthropologie, Vince, Free People, Mother Denim, and more. Over 1,000 brands and 100,000+ items are available in their online “closet.”
So while Haverdash nails the core offering of chic womenswear essentials, Nuuly exceeds them in selection variety. Nuuly is ideal for an extended size range, maternity clothes, or adding family members to your plan.
But the targeted Haverdash closet feels more curated if you just need stellar women’s apparel.
Ordering and Delivery
Ordering and shipping is quick and convenient with both services. Here’s an overview:
Haverdash
- Browse online closet or provide style preferences
- Select up to plan maximum items
- Receive box within 3-4 days
- Free delivery and returns
Nuuly
- Take style quiz to customize selections
- Fill box with 6+ items from online closet
- Box ships within 1 business day
- Free delivery and returns
The services match in their ease of ordering and speedy shipping. Haverdash gets boxes out a bit faster while Nuuly allows fuller customization. But the overall convenience is excellent with both.
Wearing, Cleaning, and Returns
Once you get your rental box, the wearing, cleaning, and return processes are very similar:
- Keep each item for as long as your subscription period (30 days for Nuuly, no set period for Haverdash)
- No limits on wears, washes, etc. Treat items as your own!
- Use provided prepaid return label when ready to exchange items
- Free dry cleaning available through both services
You can renew rentals of favorite items on both platforms if you aren’t quite ready to send them back yet.
The only difference is that Nuuly enforces a 30 day maximum rental period per box. Haverdash lets you keep items indefinitely as long as your subscription stays active.
User Experience and App
Haverdash and Nuuly both provide an enjoyable user experience. Their apps and websites make browsing, ordering, and managing rentals effortless.
Key features:
Haverdash
- Smooth site and iOS app
- Curated selections in online closet
- Style quizzes for personalized picks
- View rental history and return/exchange items
- Seamless checkout and returns
Nuuly
- Sleek site and app for iOS and Android
- Share closet with friends and family
- Purchase rented items at reduced cost
- Track return dates and print shipping labels
- Arrange automatic monthly exchanges
The platforms are on par regarding user-friendly design and useful features. Nuuly has a slight edge with its expanded app availability and purchase options. But both make clothing rental totally hassle-free.
Sustainability
Sustainability is a huge focus for both Haverdash and Nuuly. Renting clothing reduces waste versus fast fashion while allowing more people access to premium styles.
Here is how the brands promote eco-conscious practices:
Haverdash
- Partners with eco-friendly dry cleaners
- Reuses garment bags and hangers
- Ethically sources and produces apparel
- Carbon neutral shipping
Nuuly
- Utilizes green dry-cleaning methods
- Rewears and recycles packaging
- Optimizes supply chain for minimal environmental impact
- Partners with eco-conscious brands
By keeping clothing in use longer through renting, Haverdash and Nuuly align with sustainability values. Both make impressive efforts to further reduce their environmental footprints.
Watch the video to learn more!
Haverdash Vs. Nuuly: Quick Pros And Cons
Haverdash
Pros
- Lower base pricing
- Faster shipping times
- Curated, trendy women’s styles
Cons
- Less size, category, and brand variety
- No Android app
- Pricier for max item allowances
Nuuly
Pros
- Wider size range and product selection
- Allows menswear, maternity, kids, etc.
- Purchase rentals at reduced cost
Cons
- Higher base pricing
- Enforced 30 day maximum rental period
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Haverdash plans start at $59 per month for 3 rental items. Their highest plan is $89 per month for 5 items.
Yes, Nuuly allows you to renew rentals of favorite items by month. Simply log in and indicate which items you want to extend before the 30 day rental period expires.
Nuuly is headquartered in New York, NY. Their rental inventory ships out from warehouses across the US.
Popular clothing rental apps include Nuuly, Haverdash, Le Tote, Rent the Runway, Caastle, Style Lend, and more. These allow you to rent clothing and accessories rather than purchasing.
Read More: Comparison Between Born Primitive And Lululemon
The Verdict: Which Service Should You Choose?
Haverdash and Nuuly both provide amazing options for affordable, sustainable clothing rental. Which is best comes down to your specific needs:
- If you want to maximize items for the cost, Nuuly is likely the better deal.
- If you like a handpicked, curated rental selection, Haverdash nails it.
- Nuuly excels for extended sizes, maternity, menswear, kids, etc.
- Haverdash is ideal for trendy, basic womenswear essentials.
Overall, you can’t go wrong with either service. Take advantage of free trials to experience Haverdash and Nuuly for yourself.
Ditch clothing waste and refresh your wardrobe affordably with clothing rental. Your wallet and the planet will thank you!