Scrubs come in a wide variety of colors, but two of the most popular options are charcoal and pewter. Both are neutral, versatile shades that pair well with other colors.
But what are the key differences between charcoal and pewter scrubs? And which one is better for medical uniforms? Below is a brief comparison of some of the main factors to consider when choosing between charcoal and pewter scrubs:
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Charcoal Scrubs | Pewter Scrubs |
| Color | Very dark gray, almost black | Medium-light gray with brown undertones |
| Staining | More likely to show stains | Hides stains better than charcoal |
| Fading | Less prone to fading | Can fade to an almost white color over time |
| Versatility | Pairs well with most colors | Also versatile, but best paired with blues and greens |
| Gender Suitability | Unisex, but considered more masculine | Unisex, but sometimes viewed as more feminine |
| Formality | Slightly more formal | Slightly more casual |
| Durability | Durable, retains color well | Less colorfast, so may look worn over time |
| Wrinkling | Tends to show wrinkles | Wrinkles less noticeable |
| Fabric Options | Available in most fabric types | Limited fabric choices; works best in twill or sateen |
| Price | Usually very affordable | Often costs slightly more than charcoal |
Overview of Charcoal Scrubs
Charcoal scrubs are characterized by their deep, dark gray color that borders on black. Here are some of the key benefits and features of charcoal medical uniforms:
- Neutral color goes with any other shade of scrubs.
- Dark color hides stains better than lighter scrubs.
- Retains rich color even after repeated washing.
- Looks formal and polished for a medical setting.
- Works well in crisp fabrics like cotton twill.
- Unisex and suitable for any gender.
- Affordable price point even for high quality fabrics.
- Available in many styles from tunics to cargo pants.
- Provides an easy matching uniform when worn by multiple staff members.
- Conveys professionalism and authority when worn by healthcare workers.
- Easy to find and stock at uniform retailers and medical scrubs stores.
Overview of Pewter Scrubs
Pewter scrubs have a medium gray shade with subtle brown undertones. Here are some notable features of pewter medical uniforms:
- Softer neutral complements a variety of skin tones.
- Hides stains better than lighter grays due to brown hints.
- Works well in softer fabrics like sateen.
- Appears more casual and approachable than charcoal.
- Fades gradually to a pale grayish color over time.
- Pairs best with cooler accent colors like blue and green.
- Suitable for any gender but sometimes viewed as more feminine.
- Usually costs more than comparable charcoal scrubs.
- Limited style selection; mostly available in tunics and pants.
- Provides a cohesive yet relaxed look when multiple staff wear them.
- Conveys professionalism with a touch of softness.
- May be harder to find than charcoal scrubs at some retailers.
Also Read: Comparison Between Fit Scrubs And FIGS Medical Scrubs.
Key Differences Between Charcoal and Pewter Scrubs
When deciding between charcoal versus pewter colored scrubs, there are a few key contrasts to consider:
- Color
Charcoal scrubs are defined by their distinct, dark shade that often leans towards a blackish-gray. When you look at charcoal scrubs, the deep hue instantly stands out, setting a tone of no-nonsense and elegance.
This depth in color ensures that the scrubs remain a true neutral, fitting effortlessly into any professional environment.
Pewter, on the other hand, is a subtler shade. This color boasts of a medium tan-tinged gray that possesses a certain warmth.
If you hold both shades side by side, the pewter would almost feel like a diluted version of charcoal with a tinge of brown. This gives pewter a soft and welcoming aura.
- Staining
Stains are an inevitable part of a medical professional’s life. While both colors offer some resistance to noticeable staining, their mechanisms are different.
Pewter has an advantage here due to its lighter color, which helps camouflage certain spills or discolorations. This can be especially useful if you’re in a rush and don’t have time for an immediate change.
Charcoal, however, relies on its sheer depth. Darker colors, in general, are good at making stains less visible, especially if the stains themselves are of a darker hue.
- Fading
The effect of multiple washes on the color intensity varies between these two shades.
Charcoal scrubs tend to be champions when it comes to retaining color. The dark shade ensures that even with repeated washing, the color remains vibrant, rich, and dark.
Pewter, however, has a softer shade that fades progressively with each wash. Over time, pewter scrubs can become noticeably paler, which might require replacement if you want to maintain a consistent look.
- Pairing With Other Colors
Both these colors are versatile, but they have their unique pairings that enhance their look.
Charcoal, with its neutral tone, is a universal player. Whether you’re pairing it with bright reds, serene blues, or even vibrant yellows, charcoal complements them all, offering a balanced contrast.
Pewter is a bit more specific. Its warm undertones mean it tends to mesh better with cooler accent colors. Think of ocean blues, forest greens, or even muted purples.
- Gender Suitability
While scrubs are typically designed to be gender-neutral, colors often evoke different vibes.
Charcoal, with its dark and neutral appeal, is often perceived as slightly more masculine. But this doesn’t mean it’s exclusive to men. Many women wear charcoal scrubs and look equally professional and stylish.
Pewter has a softer appeal, often leaning a bit more feminine due to its warm undertones. However, again, it’s suitable for anyone and everyone.
- Formality
When assessing the formality, there’s a subtle difference between the two.
Charcoal scrubs often come off as more formal and polished. If there were a business meeting in the world of medical professionals, charcoal would be the go-to.
Pewter scrubs, while still professional, have a more relaxed vibe. They give off an approachable aura, making the wearer seem more accessible.
- Durability
Color durability refers to how long the color remains vibrant and fresh.
Charcoal is exceptional in this category. Its rich, dark hue remains consistent even with regular wear, ensuring that your scrubs look new for a longer time.
Pewter scrubs, as previously mentioned, can begin to look worn and faded more quickly.
Also Watch This Review Video:
- Wrinkling
Wrinkles are a common concern, especially for those who want to appear neat and organized.
Charcoal, due to its dark nature, tends to show wrinkles more clearly. Any crease or crinkle becomes more visible, demanding regular ironing or steaming.
Pewter, with its lighter shade and warm undertones, is more forgiving when it comes to wrinkles. The creases blend in better, ensuring a more put-together look even if you’ve just pulled them out of the dryer.
- Fabric Options
Different colors sometimes work best with certain fabric types.
Charcoal scrubs are versatile in this sense. Whether you’re opting for cotton, polyester, spandex blends, or any other fabric, charcoal adapts well.
Pewter is a bit more particular. The color shines especially well in twill or sateen weaves, bringing out the warm undertones beautifully.
- Price
Lastly, the cost can sometimes sway a decision.
Pewter scrubs, particularly from high-end brands, tend to be priced slightly higher. This could be due to the unique dyeing process or the specific fabrics used.
Charcoal scrubs, being more common and versatile, often come with more budget-friendly options. However, prices can vary based on the brand and quality.
Also Read: Comparison Between Medelita And FIGS
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
No, pewter and charcoal are noticeably different shades. Charcoal is almost black while pewter is more of a brownish light-medium gray.
Pewter charcoal would be a darker, grayer version of standard pewter with more charcoal mixed in. It may appear similar to a dark heather gray color.
In scrubs, pewter is typically a tan-tinged medium gray. It’s lighter than charcoal with subtle brown undertones.
No, pewter is much lighter than what is usually referred to as charcoal grey. Charcoal grey is very dark, almost black. Pewter is better described as a brownish medium gray.
Also Read: Is Indigo Better Than Navy Scrubs?
Final Thoughts
When choosing between charcoal versus pewter medical scrubs, consider your facility’s formality, your desired versatility, any gender preferences, and budget.
Charcoal offers classic versatility at an affordable price point. Pewter provides a softer look for a bit more money but doesn’t retain its color as well long-term.
Both are professional neutral options, so your unique needs will determine whether charcoal or pewter is the better choice for your uniform.