Diaper rash is one of the most common skin conditions that affects babies and infants. The tender skin around the diaper area is prone to chafing, irritation, and bacterial infections that can lead to redness, inflammation, and pain.
Using a thick barrier cream or ointment can help prevent and treat diaper rash by protecting the skin, keeping it dry, and promoting healing.
Two of the most popular and effective diaper rash creams on the market are Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste. But which one is better for your baby’s delicate bottom?
Here is an in-depth comparison of the key features, pros and cons of Triple Paste versus Boudreaux’s Butt Paste to help you decide which is the best diaper rash ointment.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Features | Triple Paste | Boudreaux’s Butt Paste |
| Key Ingredients | Zinc oxide, petroleum, castor oil | Zinc oxide, petroleum, balsam peru |
| Texture | Thick, paste-like | Thick, paste-like |
| Fragrance | Low fragrance | Medicinal, herbal scent |
| Cost | $$ | $ |
| Availability | Online, pharmacies, stores | Online, pharmacies, stores |
| Waterproof | Yes | Yes |
| Healing | Excellent | Very good |
| Prevention | Excellent | Very good |
| Absorption | Very good | Good |
| Ease of Use | Very good | Good |
Overview of Triple Paste
Triple Paste is a premium diaper rash ointment that contains three powerful ingredients to treat and prevent diaper rash – zinc oxide, petroleum jelly, and castor oil.
Key Features and Benefits:
- Thick zinc oxide formula creates a long-lasting protective barrier on baby’s skin
- Petroleum jelly seals in moisture and prevents wetness from irritating skin
- Castor oil has anti-inflammatory properties to soothe irritation and promote healing
- Fragrance-free and hypoallergenic for sensitive skin
- Waterproof to keep moisture out and skin dry
- Excellent for both prevention and healing severe diaper rash
- Easy to apply thick paste glides smoothly onto skin
Overview of Boudreaux’s Butt Paste
Boudreaux’s Butt Paste is another top diaper rash cream containing zinc oxide and petroleum jelly as key ingredients.
Key Features and Benefits:
- Zinc oxide provides protective barrier against wetness
- Petroleum jelly seals out moisture and prevents chafing
- Balsam Peru added for antiseptic and soothing properties
- Distinctive medicinal scent from balsam peru and other natural oils
- Budget-friendly price point compared to Triple Paste
- Very thick paste stays put on baby’s bottom
- Good for both protecting against and treating diaper rash
- Widely available in major stores and online
Also Read: Is Water Wipes Better Than Kirkland Wipes?
Key Differences Between Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste
Now, let’s take a detailed look at how Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste stack up against each other in key categories:
Ingredients
The main ingredients in both Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste are zinc oxide and petroleum jelly, which work together to form a protective barrier on the skin while sealing in moisture.
Triple Paste sets itself apart with the addition of castor oil. Castor oil has natural anti-inflammatory properties from ricinoleic acid that can help reduce irritation and swelling. The castor oil in Triple Paste may make it more soothing and healing for angry, inflamed diaper rashes.
Boudreaux’s contains balsam peru, an antiseptic that gives it its distinct herbal, medicinal smell. The balsam peru offers antiseptic and mild numbing benefits to ease discomfort. However, some parents may want to avoid the strong fragrance.
Both ointments use high levels of zinc oxide, around 40%, to maximally protect delicate skin. Triple Paste has a light, low fragrance formula, while Boudreaux’s scented formula may irritate some babies.
Texture
Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste have a very similar thick, paste-like texture. They are both opaque white creams that go on smoothly and stick well to the skin without being messy.
The thick zinc oxide formulas do not drip or run, allowing both creams to stay in place inside diapers to keep skin protected. The thick texture also creates more of a barrier compared to thinner creams.
Some parents find Triple Paste applies a bit more easily from the tube without being quite as thick. However, both products have the ultra thick texture needed to effectively coat skin and prevent diaper rash.
Effectiveness
Based on customer reviews and expert analysis, both Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s are highly effective for treating and preventing diaper rash. The zinc oxide creates a physical shield against wetness and friction while the petroleum jelly seals out moisture.
Several studies have found zinc oxide ointments reduce diaper rash severity better than other options. Both creams score well in real world testing for quickly relieving diaper rash symptoms like redness and chafing while promoting faster healing.
Triple Paste may have a slight edge for more severe diaper rash cases because of the added anti-inflammatory properties from the castor oil. The petroleum jelly also absorbs a bit more thoroughly than the waxier base of Boudreaux’s. But both offer excellent protection and relief.
Cost
One area where the two diaper creams differ is cost per ounce. Boudreaux’s Butt Paste is the more budget friendly option, typically running about $1 per ounce. Triple Paste costs around $2 per ounce.
The increased cost of Triple Paste may be worthwhile for parents looking for a formula with that extra castor oil anti-inflammatory boost. But Boudreaux’s provides good value for families looking to save on a quality diaper rash cream.
Larger tubes of 4 or more ounces will provide more value for money with both brands. Still, the price per ounce remains lower overall for Boudreaux’s Butt Paste.
Fragrance
Triple Paste has almost no fragrance, which is ideal for sensitive skin. Boudreaux’s Butt Paste has a distinctive strong medicinal, herbal scent from the natural balsam peru and oils.
For babies who become easily irritated by fragrances, Triple Paste would be the better choice. The low fragrance formula is less likely to further inflame already upset skin.
Some parents don’t mind the natural scent of Boudreaux’s Butt Paste. And some even find the menthol-like medicinal smell to be soothing. But babies with allergies or sensitive skin may do better with the no-fragrance Triple Paste.
Absorption
With both ointments having thick, occlusive formulas designed to keep moisture out, absorption is moderate. The thick zinc oxide formulations sit on top of skin rather than absorbing deeply.
However, Triple Paste’s base of petroleum jelly allows for slightly more skin absorption than Boudreaux’s wax-heavy base. The petroleum jelly sinks in a bit better while still sealing moisture out.
While neither absorb fully for a dry feel, Triple Paste leaves a bit less greasy residue. Boudreaux’s Butt Paste’s thicker formula stays more waxy on the skin’s surface. So Triple Paste may be preferred for parents looking for less residue.
Also Watch This Review Video:
Ease of Use
Both Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste come in squeezable tubes that make it easy to apply the thick creams. However, some parents report Triple Paste requiring a bit less force to squeeze out while application goes on more smoothly.
The castor oil in Triple Paste gives it a more emollient, glide-on texture over the skin compared to the thicker, waxier Boudreaux’s Butt Paste. Triple Paste takes a bit less effort to spread around the diaper area.
With Boudreaux’s, the thicker texture needs a bit more warming and spreading to apply evenly. But both creams are still formulated for easy, mess-free application.
Availability
One advantage of Boudreaux’s Butt Paste is its wide availability in major retailers like Walmart, Target, and CVS. Triple Paste may require a trip to the pharmacy or ordering online.
However, Triple Paste can also be found in many pharmacy chains, grocery stores, and big box stores. And it is readily available online through major retailers like Amazon. So while Boudreaux’s may have a slight edge in accessibility, Triple Paste still remains easy to find.
In summary, while Triple Paste holds up better in some areas like ingredients, absorption, and fragrance for sensitive skin, you really can’t go wrong with either diaper cream. Both provide excellent protection and relief for baby’s delicate bottom.
Also Read: Comparison Between Pampers Sensitive Wipes And Aqua Pure.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Triple Paste is regarded by many parents and pediatricians as the best diaper rash cream. The zinc oxide and petroleum jelly provide optimal protection and healing. And the addition of castor oil makes it both soothing and antimicrobial. Overall, Triple Paste delivers excellent diaper rash relief.
Desitin, A&D ointment, and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste share similar zinc oxide formulations and thickness to Triple Paste. But none offer the added castor oil benefits. Parents report Triple Paste works better than other common diaper rash creams.
Both Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste rank as top diaper rash ointments. Triple Paste may have an edge with the anti-inflammatory castor oil. But Boudreaux’s provides excellent protection at a lower price point. For severe rashes, Triple Paste is regarded as the best diaper rash ointment overall.
Yes, Triple Paste diaper cream is very safe when used as directed. The active ingredients zinc oxide and petroleum jelly have long been used safely and effectively for diaper rash. Always consult your pediatrician if rash worsens or does not improve within 5-7 days of treatment.
Also Read: Differences Between Abiie Beyond And Stokke Tripp Trapp High Chairs.
Final Thoughts
When it comes to keeping baby’s skin healthy in the diaper area, both Triple Paste and Boudreaux’s Butt Paste are excellent options that protect, soothe, and help heal irritated bottoms.
While Triple Paste has compelling benefits from the castor oil and lighter feel, Boudreaux’s provides comparable protection at a more affordable price point.
Whichever you choose, applying a thick diaper cream with each change can make a real difference in preventing and resolving diaper rash.
Pay close attention to any reactions or worsening rash, and be ready to switch creams or consult your pediatrician to find the best solution for your little one’s delicate skin.