Tommy John Vs. MeUndies: Well-Known Underwear Brands Compared

Finding that perfect pair of underwear is no easy task. Tommy John and MeUndies are two popular underwear brands promising next-level comfort. But how do these labels really stack up?

In this in-depth comparison, we’ll contrast Tommy John Vs. MeUndies on key factors like fabric, fit, style, price and more. Read on to see if one clearly beats the other, or if it’s too close to call.

A Brief Comparison Table

Aspects	Tommy John	MeUndies
Fabric	Proprietary cool cotton, modal blends	MicroModal, modal blends
Style	Classic men’s silhouettes, solid colors	Fun prints, cheeky styles, matching sets
Fit	Contoured pouches, activewear focused	Inclusive sizing, tailored fits
Price	$24-$42 per pair	$16-$24 per pair
Sustainability	Efforts in progress	Core business model practices
Best For	Athletic wear and performance	Everyday comfort and style

Overview of Tommy John

Founded in 2008, Tommy John sought to “revolutionize men’s essentials” starting with underwear. Their underwear uses proprietary fabrics like Cool Cotton and Second Skin for lightweight breathability and stretch.

Some key features of Tommy John include:

• Unique fabrics designed in-house
• Horizontal QuickDrawTM fly
• Stay-put waistband
• Range of silhouettes from briefs to boxer briefs
• Matching undershirts, loungewear and socks
• Bold colors and seamless designs

Tommy John has grown into a leading men’s basics brand focused on fabric innovation and quality construction.

Overview of MeUndies

MeUndies launched in 2011 with the goal of transforming the underwear experience through ultra-soft fabrics and bold prints. They’re best known for their proprietary MicroModal fabric that is 3 times softer than cotton.

Key features of MeUndies:

• Ultra-plush MicroModal material
• Fun and adventurous prints/patterns
• Classic and cheeky silhouettes for men and women
• Subscription options for regular delivery
• Matching loungewear like bralettes, tops and bottoms
• Sustainability initiatives and ethical production

This LA-based brand shook up the underwear industry with its irreverent personality and focus on comfort.

Also Read: Comparison Between Separatec And SAXX Underwear

Key Differences Between Tommy John And MeUndies

• Comparing the Fabrics

One of the biggest differentiators is the proprietary fabrics created by each brand.

Tommy John:

1. Cool Cotton – breathable cotton that keeps you cool
2. Second Skin – modal/spandex blend that stretches and retains shape
3. Air – lightweight mesh fabric
4. Sport – moisture-wicking fabric with stretch

MeUndies:

1. MicroModal – lightweight modal made from beechwood; ultra-soft handfeel
2. Lenzing Modal – sustainably sourced modal fibers
3. Dreamsicle – modal blend with more stretch and recovery

Both Tommy John and MeUndies leverage modal for its softness and ability to contour to the body. MeUndies’ proprietary MicroModal stands out for its exceptional softness that customers rave about. Tommy John offers fabrics more tailored for athletic performance.

For pure comfort, MeUndies has the advantage. But Tommy John excels at technical fabrics ideal for workouts and activity.

• Style and Design Choices

In terms of silhouette and design options, here is how Tommy John and MeUndies compare:

Tommy John

1. Boxer briefs
2. Briefs
3. Trunks
4. Boxers
5. Thongs
6. Camo and solid colors
7. Minimal bold logos and branding

MeUndies

1. Briefs
2. Trunks
3. Boxer briefs
4. Thongs
5. Boyshorts
6. Onesies
7. Matching sets
8. Adventurous prints
9. Food, holiday, and pop culture designs

While both carry the classic men’s underwear silhouettes, MeUndies offers far more daring and innovative styles. Their expansive print selection gives customers way more options for self-expression.

Tommy John leans traditional with a smaller selection of colors and patterns. MeUndies has more variety for every personality and style preference imaginable.

Also Read: Comparison Between TomboyX And MeUndies.

• Sizing, Fit, and Support

Dialed-in fit and sizing makes all the difference in comfort.

Tommy John:

1. Men’s sizes from XS-3XL
2. Contoured pouches and seamless leg openings
3. Stay-put waistbands prevent slipping
4. Most styles have horizontal fly

MeUndies:

1. Men’s sizes from XS-4XL
2. Women’s sizes from XS-3XL
3. Soft waistbands and tagless labeling
4. Cheeky fits for bold women’s styles
5. Specific fits like trunks with extra thigh room

Both Tommy John and MeUndies cater to a wide range of body types with expanded sizing. MeUndies goes up to 4XL, while Tommy John stops at 3XL.

Tommy John seems engineered for athletic builds, while MeUndies accounts for curvier bodies in their fits. MeUndies also better accommodates women with a larger size range.

For most average-sized men, either will provide a comfortable tailored fit. MeUndies has an edge for inclusive sizing and fitting more body types.

• Pricing and Value Comparison

As premium underwear brands, Tommy John and MeUndies come at a higher price point than discount multipacks. Here’s how their pricing shakes out:

Tommy John:

1. $24-$42 per pair
2. Multipacks and bundles available
3. Frequent discounts and sales

MeUndies:

1. $16-$24 per pair
2. Smaller multipacks available
3. Subscribe-and-save pricing
4. Sales for first time customers

MeUndies generally has more affordable everyday pricing, though Tommy John runs frequent promotions to offset their higher prices.

For the materials and construction quality, both seem fairly priced. MeUndies costs less for their most basic options, while Tommy John charges more for their technical fabrics.

Watch this review video:

• Subscription Options

Both Tommy John and MeUndies give customers the option to subscribe and save for regular underwear deliveries.

MeUndies subscription plans cost $14-$16 per pair when you sign up monthly. You can pause, delay, or cancel anytime.

Tommy John’s subscription ranges from $20-$38 per month depending on style preferences. There is flexibility to push back orders and shipping as needed.

MeUndies has the leg up for subscription savings value. Tommy John’s monthly plans don’t offer much discount over buying individually.

• Sustainability and Ethical Sourcing

For eco-conscious shoppers, both brands are making efforts to improve sustainability:

Tommy John:

1. Using more sustainable Supima cotton
2. Exploring eco fabrics like bamboo
3. Partnership with Fair Trade USA for ethical production
4. Claim 120,000 pounds fabric saved from landfills

MeUndies:

1. Lenzing’s TENCEL modal fabric from sustainable wood sources
2. Removing all single-use plastics in packaging/production by 2025
3. Ethical working conditions ensured through supply chain auditing
4. Donates returned underwear to those in need

MeUndies has made sustainability intrinsic to their business model through eco fabrics and responsible manufacturing. Tommy John is taking steps in the right direction but still has room to improve.

Also Read: Comparison Between Sheath And Separatec Underwear

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Final Thought

Based on the detailed comparison above, here is my personal take on Tommy John Vs. MeUndies:

For everyday comfort and self-expression, MeUndies wins out with their unbeatable soft MicroModal fabric and huge variety of bold, adventurous designs. They accommodate more body types and lead in sustainability efforts.

However, Tommy John is the way to go for athletic men looking for moisture-wicking performance. Their technical fabrics and modern silhouettes make Tommy John the perfect undershirt for workouts and activity.

Both brands make quality underwear that feels great and lasts. Choose MeUndies for that ultra-soft lifestyle feel, or Tommy John for high-tech functionality. For most guys’ day-to-day needs, I give the edge to MeUndies. But Tommy John fills its niche for active men nicely.