Flea collars are a popular option for pet owners looking to protect their dogs and cats from pesky fleas and ticks. Two of the most well-known brands are Seresto and Hartz.
But how do these flea collars really compare? Here is an in-depth look at the pros, cons, features, and effectiveness of Seresto and Hartz flea collars to help you decide which is best for your furry friend.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Seresto | Hartz |
| Active Ingredients | Imidacloprid, Flumethrin | Tetrachlorvinphos, Methoprene |
| Water Resistant | Yes | No |
| Odor | Low | Scented |
| Adjustability | No | Yes |
| Collar Type | One size fits all | Adjustable |
| Duration | 8 months | 3-6 months |
| Price | $$ | $ |
| Efficacy | Very effective | Less effective |
| Safety | Very safe | Potential risks |
| Repels and Kills | Both | Mainly repels |
Overview of Seresto Flea Collar
The Seresto flea collar provides long-lasting, effective flea and tick protection by continuously releasing low concentrations of two active ingredients onto your pet’s fur:
- Imidacloprid – Kills adult fleas and larvae
- Flumethrin – Repels and kills ticks
Key Features:
- Provides 8 months of continuous protection
- Veterinarian-recommended
- Odorless and non-greasy
- Water-resistant
- Safe for dogs and cats (7 weeks and older)
- Kills and repels fleas and ticks
- Easy to apply adjustable collar
- Can cut to size to fit smaller pets
The Seresto flea collar has many advantages that make it a top choice among vets and pet owners:
- Very effective – Kills and repels fleas, ticks, lice, and larvae
- Long-lasting – 8 months of continuous protection
- Water-resistant – Remains effective after swimming or bathing
- Low odor – Unlike some flea collars, Seresto has almost no odor
- Safe – Very low risk of skin irritation or other side effects
- Easy to use – Just place around pet’s neck and cut off excess
The Seresto flea collar provides some of the most complete and enduring flea and tick defense you can get in a collar. It is more expensive than many basic flea collars, but users say the cost is well worth it for the extended protection and effectiveness it delivers.
Overview of Hartz Flea Collar
The Hartz flea collar offers a more affordable option for flea and tick control. It uses different active ingredients than the Seresto collar:
- Tetrachlorvinphos – Kills flea larvae and eggs
- Methoprene – Kills flea eggs and larvae
Key Features:
- Provides 3-6 months of protection
- Low cost
- Scented
- Adjustable sizing
- Water-resistant coating (some versions)
- Kills flea eggs and larvae
- Repels adult fleas and ticks
- Easy to apply and adjust collar
Hartz flea collars can be a good temporary solution for pet owners on a tight budget. Benefits include:
- Low price – More affordable than premium brands
- Adjustable – Can adjust tightness as needed
- Simple application – Just place around pet’s neck
- Scented – Leaves a pleasant scent on fur
- Available in multi-packs – Convenient for multi-pet households
However, there are some downsides to be aware of with Hartz flea collars compared to premium options:
- Shorter duration – Only lasts 3-6 months
- Not water-resistant – Effectiveness decreases after swimming or baths
- Primarily repels pests – May not kill fleas and ticks as effectively
- More potential for irritation – Cheaper materials can cause skin reactions
- Contains toxic pesticides – Risk of endocrine disruption in pets
While Hartz flea collars can provide short-term flea and tick prevention on a budget, they likely won’t deliver the same level of enduring, worry-free protection as a premium collar like Seresto.
Also Read: Comparison Between CapAction And Capstar
Detailed Comparison Between Seresto and Hartz
Now let’s take a deeper dive into how Seresto and Hartz flea collars stack up across some key factors pet owners should consider when choosing a flea and tick collar:
Ingredients and Effectiveness
The active ingredients in Seresto (Imidacloprid and Flumethrin) are more advanced and effective than those typically used in basic flea collars like Hartz (Tetrachlorvinphos and Methoprene).
Seresto utilizes two ingredients that work in tandem to repel and kill fleas, ticks, and lice. Imidacloprid attacks the nervous system of pests, while Flumethrin repels and kills ticks. Together, they provide comprehensive protection.
In contrast, Hartz collars contain Tetrachlorvinphos to kill flea eggs and larvae, and Methoprene to prevent flea larvae from maturing. However, these ingredients mainly just repel adult fleas and ticks rather than killing them. This can allow the pest population to rebound more quickly.
In testing, Seresto was found to be highly effective at killing and repelling fleas and ticks, while lower cost collars with ingredients like Hartz tend to perform worse in repelling ticks and killing existing pest populations.
Water Resistance
Seresto’s active ingredients are stored in the collar polymer and are released over time onto the pet’s coat, so swimming or bathing doesn’t affect the performance.
Hartz flea collars use a water-resistant coating to help maintain effectiveness when wet. However, this barrier can wear off over time, decreasing duration and performance after repeated exposure to water.
For pets that swim or get baths regularly, Seresto is the better choice to ensure uninterrupted flea and tick defense.
Odor and Skin Irritation
Since Seresto was designed by Bayer, a pharmaceutical company, the materials and ingredients used are held to high standards for health and safety. The collar itself has almost no odor as well.
The cheaper ingredients and materials used in basic flea collars like Hartz can sometimes cause skin irritation, allergic reactions, or unpleasant smells. The scent added to overcome this smell may bother some pet owners.
Pets with sensitive skin may do better with a premium option like Seresto that is less likely to cause any skin discomfort or allergic response.
Duration of Protection
Seresto collars provide 8 months of continuous flea and tick protection with a single application. This can prevent pests year-round with just one collar.
In contrast, Hartz flea collars need to be replaced every 3-6 months. So you’ll need to frequently reapply new collars, which can be easy to forget. The shorter protection period also leaves gaps where fleas and ticks can reemerge.
For pet owners who want to “set it and forget it”, Seresto delivers long-lasting protection without the need for constant collar changes.
Also Watch This Review Video:
Cost and Value
At first glance, Hartz flea collars are the cheaper option. However, given that they need to be replaced at least twice as often as Seresto collars for continuous coverage, the costs even out over time.
When you factor in the higher effectiveness, longer duration, and safer ingredients of Seresto collars, most users find them well worth the additional investment for peace of mind knowing their pet is protected.
While Hartz collars can save money upfront, you tend get what you pay for. Many pet owners report switching to premium flea collars like Seresto after being disappointed with the performance and value of cheaper alternatives.
Adjustability
Hartz flea collars can be manually adjusted to tighten or loosen the fit as needed. This can be helpful for maintaining a good fit as pets grow.
Seresto flea collars come in different sizes but have a fixed circumference. You can cut the collar if needed for smaller pets, but it can’t be manually tightened or expanded like an adjustable collar.
For growing puppies or kittens, or pet owners with multiple dogs or cats of different neck sizes, the adjustability of Hartz flea collars can be more convenient. But for most average-sized adult pets, Seresto’s streamlined one-size design works fine.
Also Read: Comparison Between Dogtopia And Camp Bow Wow.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
The main differences are that Seresto flea collars use more advanced insecticide ingredients to deliver longer-lasting, more effective protection, while Hartz uses cheaper pesticides and materials that provide shorter-term prevention. Seresto is also water-resistant and odorless while Hartz has only temporary water resistance and added scents.
Very few flea collars match the duration and effectiveness of Seresto. However, some oral and topical treatments like Bravecto and Frontline may provide even better protection. But they require monthly reapplication, unlike Seresto’s 8 months of coverage.
Hartz flea collars can help temporarily repel fleas and ticks on a budget. But they likely won’t fully eliminate an existing infestation and need frequent replacing. They also pose higher risks of skin irritation or chemical exposure compared to premium options.
For most pet owners, Seresto is widely considered the best flea and tick collar option available. It provides long-lasting, waterproof protection that actually kills and repels pests rather than just repelling. The premium ingredients result in high efficacy with low risk of side effects.
Also Read: Is Science Diet Kitten Better Than Indoor Kitten?
Final Thoughts
While Hartz flea collars are affordable, their shorter duration, weaker pest-fighting ingredients, lack of waterproofing, and potentially irritating effects make premium collars like Seresto a better long-term investment.
Paying a little more upfront for the Seresto flea collar can provide peace of mind through seasons of highly effective, worry-free protection for your furry friend.
For pet owners seeking a simple, pesticide-free flea and tick prevention solution that doesn’t require constant reapplication, the Seresto collar is one of your best options.
Before making a final choice, talk with your veterinarian about the flea and tick control methods they recommend for your pet. But for set-it-and-forget-it flea and tick defense, Seresto remains a top performing option to keep your dog or cat covered.
