When selecting a foundation, finding the perfect match for your skin tone is crucial. Neutrogena offers two similar shades – Classic Ivory and Natural Ivory – that work well for fair skin. But which one should you choose? Here’s an in-depth look at Neutrogena Classic Ivory vs Natural Ivory.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Neutrogena Classic Ivory | Neutrogena Natural Ivory |
| Undertone | Cool, pink undertones | Warm, yellow undertones |
| Skin Tone Match | Very fair, porcelain skin | Fair skin with warm peach undertones |
| Finish | Natural matte finish | Radiant satin finish |
| Coverage | Medium buildable coverage | Light-medium coverage |
| Longevity | Long-wearing | Average longevity |
| Ingredients | Oil-free, non-comedogenic | Contains meadowfoam seed oil |
| SPF | No SPF | SPF 20 sunscreen |
| Price | $$ | $ |
Overview of Neutrogena Classic Ivory
Neutrogena’s Classic Ivory shade has a matte, oil-free finish that works well for very fair skin tones. Key features include:
- Cool undertone with pink hues that match porcelain skin.
- Masks imperfections with medium buildable coverage.
- Controls shine for a natural matte look that lasts all day.
- Oil-free and non-comedogenic formula won’t clog pores.
- Fragrance-free and gentle for sensitive skin.
- Affordable price point around $10-15.
The Classic Ivory shade provides a brightening effect for fair complexions with neutral to pink undertones. It hides redness and imperfections without looking cakey. The long-wearing formula controls oils and stays put all day. Overall, it’s a great shade for very fair cool-toned skin.
Overview of Neutrogena Natural Ivory
Neutrogena’s Natural Ivory has a luminous, radiant finish suitable for fair skin with warm undertones. Key features:
- Warm peachy undertone flatters fair skin with golden hues.
- Light-medium buildable coverage evens tone without heavy feel.
- Skin-nourishing formula contains meadowfoam seed oil.
- SPF 20 protects skin from sun damage.
- Fragrance-free and non-comedogenic.
- Affordable price under $10.
The Natural Ivory shade creates a healthy luminous finish for fair skin with warm undertones. It provides lightweight coverage to even skin tone while letting your natural glow peek through.
The meadowfoam seed oil hydrates skin without clogging pores. It’s a great shade match if you have fair skin with peach or golden undertones.
Also Read: Comparison Between Intellishade And TruPhysical
Key Differences Between Classic Ivory and Natural Ivory
Neutrogena’s Classic Ivory and Natural Ivory seem similar at first glance, but there are some notable differences to consider when choosing between the two fair shades:
Undertones: More Than Meets the Eye
Ah, undertones! They’re the silent game-changers in the foundation world. At first glance, the shades may look similar, but their undertones can be wildly different. This is where Classic Ivory and Natural Ivory diverge significantly.
Classic Ivory: It’s not just about being a shade for fair skin; it’s a shade with cool pink undertones. So, what does that mean? Think about those with porcelain skin, often seen with rosy cheeks or a pinkish hue to their complexion. This shade complements that natural flush.
Natural Ivory: Leaning towards warm golden peach undertones, this shade is a dream for those with fair skin that has a subtle golden or peachy tint. Imagine the soft warmth of the early morning sun; that’s Natural Ivory for you.
A little tip: Look at the veins on your wrist. If they appear more blue or purple, you’re likely cool-toned. If they seem greener, you’re warm-toned!
Finish: Shine or Glow?
Finish matters. It’s not just about the color; it’s about how that color sits on your skin.
Classic Ivory: With its oil-free, natural matte finish, this is the go-to for those who prefer a shine-free look. It’s especially useful for those hot and humid days or if you have an oily skin type. Want to combat that mid-day shine? Classic Ivory has got your back.
Natural Ivory: Ah, the glow seekers will love this. Natural Ivory boasts a radiant finish, giving you that subtle, luminous glow. Think about the soft shimmer of dew on leaves in the morning light.
Remember, there’s no right or wrong here. It’s all about personal preference. Matte or glow, what’s your mojo?
Coverage: Barely There or Almost Full?
Classic Ivory: When you’re aiming for a bit more coverage, perhaps for a special event or a long day ahead, this provides a medium coverage. It’s like a trusty friend, ensuring those little imperfections stay hidden.
Natural Ivory: For the fans of the ‘no makeup’ makeup look, this is a winner. With light-medium coverage, it lets more of your natural beauty shine through. Embrace those freckles!
Longevity: From Dawn Till Dusk
Who wants to keep retouching makeup? Longevity is a biggie.
Classic Ivory: Its oil-free formula means it’s designed to stick around. From that early morning meeting to the evening wind-down, it’s less likely to fade or transfer.
Natural Ivory: While it’s a star in many aspects, it might not have the same marathon-longevity as Classic Ivory. But hey, sometimes, it’s about the journey, not the endurance, right?
Also Read: Comparison Between Brush On Block and Colorescience
Ingredients: Beyond the Shades
Here’s where we peek behind the curtain. What’s in these foundations?
Classic Ivory: Being oil-free and non-comedogenic, it’s a top pick for those with acne-prone skin. It means less worry about clogged pores.
Natural Ivory: Enter meadowfoam seed oil. A hero for dry skin, offering that boost of hydration. But, as with all things, a note of caution: it could potentially be a nemesis for super oily skin types, leading to clogged pores.
Also Watch This Review Video:
SPF: Sun’s Friend or Foe?
Sun protection is a big deal. Let’s see how these contenders fare.
Natural Ivory: SPF 20? Check. While foundation shouldn’t replace your regular sunscreen, it’s a nice added layer. Remember, every bit of sun protection counts!
Classic Ivory: It doesn’t sport the SPF badge, so always pair it with a good sunscreen if you’re stepping out.
Price: Pennies and Preferences
Price tags can be decisive. So, how do these two compare?
Classic Ivory: Priced a smidgen higher, but sometimes, it’s about the value it brings rather than the cost.
Natural Ivory: A little friendlier on the wallet, but as with all products, it’s about finding what resonates with your skin needs and budget.
In a nutshell, both Neutrogena’s Classic Ivory and Natural Ivory have their merits. Your choice will hinge on your skin’s undertone, the finish you seek, the coverage you desire, and your ingredient preferences. Remember, makeup is a journey, and it’s all about finding what makes you feel fabulous!
Also Read: Comparison Between Primally Pure And Beautycounter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Classic Ivory has cool pink undertones while Natural Ivory has warm golden peach undertones. Classic Ivory provides a matte finish and medium buildable coverage. Natural Ivory has a luminous radiant finish with light-medium coverage.
Neutrogena Classic Ivory has cool undertones with pink hues. It is ideal for very fair skin with neutral to pink tones.
The Classic Ivory shade works best for porcelain or very fair skin with cool pink undertones. It brightens the complexion for neutral to pink fair skin.
Neutrogena Natural Ivory in shade 112 suits fair skin with warm golden or peach undertones. It matches well with fair complexions that have a hint of golden color.
Also Read: Is CoverGirl Creamy Natural Better Than Classic Ivory?
Final Thoughts
When choosing between Neutrogena’s fair shade options, assess your skin’s undertones, coverage needs, and finish preferences. Classic Ivory better suits very fair cool-toned skin desiring a matte full coverage look.
Natural Ivory works well for fair warm-toned skin wanting a luminous light-medium coverage finish. Either way, you can’t go wrong with these quality drugstore foundations from Neutrogena tailored for fair skin. Find your perfect shade match and enjoy flawless coverage.