Merrell is a highly reputable name when it comes to comfortable, casual shoes designed for everyday wear. Two of their most popular models, the Encore Breeze 3 and 4, are nearly identical shoes with a few key differences to consider before deciding which is right for you.
In this comprehensive comparison guide, we will break down the pros and cons of each model, evaluate their performance and construction, and provide a recommendation on which Encore Breeze will meet your needs and comfort preferences for all-day wear.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Merrell Encore Breeze 3 | Merrell Encore Breeze 4 |
| Upper | Lightweight mesh | Softer mesh |
| Arch Support | Minimal | Improved |
| Cushioning | EVA foam, Ortholite footbed | EVA foam, Ortholite footbed, more heel cushioning |
| Breathability | Very breathable | Less breathable than 3 |
| Odor Control | M Select Fresh | M Select Fresh, Organic Odor Control |
| Price | $80-$100 | $95-$120 |
| Overall Best For | Breathability, flexibility | Cushioning, support |
Merrell Encore Breeze 3 Overview
The Encore Breeze 3 was released in 2018 as an update to the original Encore Breeze. This casual slip-on shoe had big shoes to fill, as the Encore line had already developed a reputation for exceptional comfort and support.
The Encore Breeze 3 delivers on these expectations with its lightweight, breathable mesh upper construction. The integrated mesh sockliner provides cushioning underfoot. An Ortholite footbed offers long-term comfort and moisture management.
At the midsole, you’ll find an EVA removable footframe for stability and shock absorption. The Encore Breeze 3 is finished with a grippy rubber outsole designed to handle a variety of surfaces.
M select fresh helps minimize odor, allowing you to go sockless comfortably. For a secure yet relaxed fit, Merrell integrated its Hyperlock technology, which mimics the foot shape. A pull tab at the heel lets you slip in and out of the shoe effortlessly.
Merrell Encore Breeze 3 Pros:
- Breathable mesh upper keeps feet cool
- Lightweight feel
- Removable EVA footbed provides stability
- Ortholite footbed for cushioning and moisture wicking
- M select fresh reduces odor
- Hyperlock construction hugs the foot’s shape
- Flexible, grippy outsole
Merrell Encore Breeze 3 Cons:
- Runs narrow, not ideal for wide feet
- Less arch support than some Merrell models
- Mesh upper not waterproof
- Outsole wears down quicker than expected
Merrell Encore Breeze 4 Overview
In 2021, Merrell released the Encore Breeze 4, the latest upgrade to this popular casual shoe line. The 4th generation Encore Breeze is highly similar to the 3 with a mesh upper, Ortholite footbed, and EVA midsole.
However, the Encore Breeze 4 makes some key adjustments to the materials and construction. The mesh upper is softer and more supple while remaining breathable. An integrated tongue helps reduce irritation. Arch and heel support receive a boost with more substantial stabilization features.
The midsole uses M select FRESH antibacterial agents and an Organic Odor Control compound to minimize odors. Merrell refreshed the color combinations for a more modern, fashion-forward look.
Despite these design changes, the Encore Breeze 4 retains the same weight, feel, and relaxed styling of its predecessors.
Merrell Encore Breeze 4 Pros:
- Softer mesh upper improves comfort
- Integrated tongue prevents irritation
- Better arch support than previous models
- More shock absorption at the heel
- Fresh odor-control technologies
- Contemporary color options
- Same Encore Breeze feel and weight
Merrell Encore Breeze 4 Cons:
- Higher price point than Breeze 3
- Mesh upper still not waterproof
- Reduced breathability compared to Breeze 3
- Outsole has durability concerns
Now that we’ve provided an overview of each model’s key features and changes, let’s compare them across some important performance criteria.
Comfort And Feel Comparison
When evaluating comfort shoes, factors like underfoot cushioning, support, and overall feel are vital considerations. Here is how the Merrell Encore Breeze 3 and 4 compare:
Underfoot Cushioning: Both models utilize a removable EVA foam footbed and Ortholite footbed to absorb shock and provide cushioning with every step. The 4 receives upgraded heel cushioning for slightly better comfort.
Arch Support: The Encore Breeze 4 augmented the arch support making it better for those needing more stability, while the 3 has minimal arch support.
Toe Box: With their narrow styling and integrated tongue, neither model is ideal for wide feet. The 4’s softened upper has a bit more give for toe splay.
Weight: No noticeable difference; both feel lightweight and flexible during wear.
Overall Feel: The hyperlock technology and slip-on silhouette provide a relaxed, molded fit; the 4 has a smoother, sock-like interior lining.
For superior comfort and support, the Encore Breeze 4 is the winner. However, the 3 excels at breathability and flexibility.
Construction Quality Comparison
From materials to workmanship, construction quality greatly impacts performance and durability. Here’s how these two models’ build stacks up:
Uppers: The mesh fabric on the 4 is softer and thicker while the 3’s is lightweight and more breathable. Both are prone to tears.
Outsoles: Identical rubber outsoles are grippy at first but lose traction over time. Neither outsole is particularly durable.
Stitching and Structure: Sturdy stitching throughout; structured heel counters and snug slip-on design ensures secure fit.
Comfort Features: 4 includes more sophisticated comfort tech like integrated tongue and odor control.
Sizing: Runs a half size small; narrow toe box limits wide feet. Purchase a half size up.
The Encore Breeze 4 edges out the 3 for using improved, more durable materials. However, there are consistencies across both for sizing and structural components.
Also Read: Comparison Between Wally Funk And Wally Sox Casual Shoe.
Suitable Environments Comparison
Considering where and when you’ll be wearing your Encore Breeze helps determine the right choice. Let’s evaluate both models’ performance in different settings.
Casual Wear: With their slip-on silhouette and mesh fabric, both are stylish yet understated for casual everyday wear.
Work and Business: The simple, sleek profile suits professional workplace environments. The all-black option is perfect for business casual offices.
Hot Weather: Highly breathable mesh uppers promote air flow, making them ideal for hot climates and summer months.
Cold Weather: Lack of insulation and waterproofing render both models unsuitable for cold, wet conditions.
Outdoor Walks: Cushioning provides comfort on short walks but lacks traction and support for extended hikes.
Standing All Day: Cushioned insole and shock absorption capacity make them suitable for all-day standing comfort.
The breathable mesh build suits hot climates and months as well as indoor standing or walking. Their casual styling adapts well for most occasions except cold outdoor use.
Cleaning And Care Comparison
To extend your Merrell shoes’ lifespan, proper cleaning and care are essential. Here’s how to maintain each model:
Encore Breeze 3 Care:
- Remove laces and removable footbed and wash with warm water and mild soap. Air dry.
- Spot clean stains on mesh upper with damp cloth.
- Replace insoles every 6 months for optimal cushioning.
Encore Breeze 4 Care:
- Hand wash upper in cold water with gentle detergent. Rinse and air dry away from direct heat.
- Spot clean mesh upper only with damp cloth.
- Replace footbed every 6-12 months.
While mostly similar, avoid machine washing the 4’s upper or using hot water which may damage the materials. Check the inner tag for any updated care recommendations.
Sizing And Fit Comparison
Finding your ideal sizing is crucial for all-day comfort. Here’s how sizing and fit compares:
Size Options: Medium and wide widths available up to size 15 in Men’s sizing; regular and wide widths up to 12 in Women’s.
Length: Runs a half size short; order a half size up from your regular size.
Width: Narrow toe box and snug midfoot fit; not optimal for wide feet.
Arch: Model 3 has minimal arch support while 4 provides improved arch stabilization.
Heel: Integrated heel counter secures the back of the foot in place.
Both run small lengthwise but are tailored for narrow to average width feet. The 4 accommodates wider feet slightly better due to its more flexible upper material.
Also Read: Is Florsheim Medfield Better Than Midtown?
Price Comparison
You’ll find the Encore Breeze 3 and 4 at similar budget-friendly price points typically under $100. Here’s how pricing shakes out:
Encore Breeze 3: $80-$100 range depending on retailer
Encore Breeze 4: $95-$120 range based on seller
On average, expect to pay $10-$20 more for the newest Encore Breeze 4 model. Frequent sales and availability of past season’s styles can reduce costs on both.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Remove footbeds and laces then wash upper in cold water with a small amount of gentle detergent. Rinse thoroughly then air dry.
Spot clean stains on mesh upper using a damp cloth and mild soap.
Replace footbeds every 6-12 months for optimal comfort and support.
With proper care, Merrell shoes typically last around 1-2 years with regular wear before showing signs of wear like reduced tread and midsole compression. The Encore Breeze line lasts closer to the 1 year mark.
Many Merrell shoes provide excellent arch support and cushioning making them a good choice for plantar fasciitis sufferers. Look for contoured, compression molded footbeds combined with midsole shock absorption technologies.
Also Read: Comparison Between the New Balance 623 and 624
Conclusion and Recommendation
For shoppers seeking a comfortable, washable casual shoe, both the Merrell Encore Breeze 3 and 4 are fantastic options. The 4 stands out for delivering noticeable improvements to comfort and support.
However, with a higher price tag than its predecessor, the Breeze 3 remains appealing for its supreme breathability and flexibility. Ultimately, choosing between the two comes down to weighting your priorities.
For superior cushioning and improved fit, we recommend going with the Merrell Encore Breeze 4. But if you want a super airy, lightweight feel, stick with the 3. Both styles effortlessly pair with jeans, shorts, dresses, and other laidback looks, keeping you stylish and comfortable all day.