As a parent, keeping your baby clean and comfortable is a top priority. And a key tool for doing that is baby wipes. Two popular baby wipe options are Huggies Simply Clean and Huggies Natural Care.
But with different features and ingredients, which is the better choice for your little one? This in-depth guide compares Huggies Simply Clean and Natural Care on key factors to help you decide.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Huggies Simply Clean | Huggies Natural Care |
| Ingredients | Shorter list, fewer synthetics | More botanicals like cucumber extract |
| Texture | Thicker, textured | Smoother, triple layer |
| Durability | Less prone to shredding | More complaints of shredding when wet |
| Scents | Unscented | Unscented |
| Cost | $0.04 per wipe | $0.05 per wipe |
| Ratings | 4.8 stars on Amazon | 4.7 stars on Amazon |
| Skin safety | Hypoallergenic, National Eczema Association seal | Hypoallergenic, National Eczema Association seal |
| Eco-friendly | Biodegradable plant-based formula, recyclable packaging | Biodegradable plant-based formula, recyclable packaging |
Overview Of Huggies Simply Clean Baby Wipes
Huggies Simply Clean baby wipes were introduced in 2013 as a plant-based, hypoallergenic option. Here are some of the key features:
- Plant-based formula contains aloe, chamomile, and vitamin E
- 99% water for a clean, refreshing feel
- Unscented and hypoallergenic for sensitive skin
- Thicker, textured wipes for effective cleaning
- Dermatologist tested for skin safety -Certified by the National Eczema Association
- Paraben-free, MIT-free, alcohol-free formula
The Simply Clean wipes are marketed as a gentle, effective cleansing option for newborns and babies with sensitivities. The main selling points are the plant-based formula and hypoallergenic credentials.
Overview Of Huggies Natural Care Baby Wipes
Huggies Natural Care wipes were released in 2010 as a “natural” option with several botanical ingredients. Here are some key features:
- Plant-based formula includes aloe, vitamin E, and cucumber extract
- Triple clean layers provide deep cleaning
- Unscented and hypoallergenic
- 99% water-activated base
- Paraben-free, MIT-free, soap-free, alcohol-free
- Dermatologist tested for safety
- Certified by the National Eczema Association
Like the Simply Clean wipes, Natural Care is positioned as a sensitive skin-friendly choice. The “triple clean layers” are designed to lift dirt and germs more effectively.
Also Read: Comparison Between Hatch and Nanit Sound Machines
Ingredient Comparison
One of the biggest differences between Simply Clean and Natural Care wipes is the ingredient list. Let’s compare:
Huggies Simply Clean
- Water
- Polyethylene oxide
- Polysorbate 20
- Aloe barbadensis leaf juice
- Tocopheryl acetate
- Chamomilla recutita (matricaria) flower extract
- Disodium cocoamphodiacetate
- Citric acid
- Sodium benzoate
Huggies Natural Care
- Water
- Propylene glycol
- Caprylyl/capryl glucoside
- Polyglyceryl-5 oleate
- Decyl glucoside
- Aloe barbadensis leaf juice
- Glycerin
- Tocopheryl acetate
- Cucumis sativus (cucumber) fruit extract
- Citric acid
- Potassium sorbate
- Sodium benzoate
As you can see, Natural Care contains more botanical ingredients like cucumber extract. However, Simply Clean has fewer synthetic ingredients overall. Both are free of parabens, alcohol, and harsh cleansers.
Texture And Performance
In terms of texture, Simply Clean wipes tend to be thicker and sturdier. They have a textured, quilted surface designed to scrub messes. Natural Care wipes are smoother with more defined cleaning layers.
For performance, parents give both wipes high marks for removing dirt, food, and sticky messes without irritation. However, some reviews suggest the Natural Care wipes are more prone to shredding, especially when wet. The Simply Clean wipes hold up better during vigorous cleaning.
Cost Comparison
Huggies Simply Clean and Natural Care wipes have very similar price points. Here are some average costs:
- Simply Clean baby wipes – $0.04 per wipe
- Natural Care baby wipes – $0.05 per wipe
A pack of 288 Simply Clean wipes costs around $11, while Natural Care is $14 for 264 wipes. When purchased in bulk or on sale, the prices are almost identical. Natural Care wipes are occasionally a bit pricier.
Reviews And Ratings
Here is an overview of customer reviews for both products:
Huggies Simply Clean
- Amazon rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars (12,000+ reviews)
- Walmart rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars (300+ reviews)
- Parents praise gentleness, cleaning power, thickness
- Some reviewers wish they were unscented
Huggies Natural Care
- Amazon rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars (14,000+ reviews)
- Walmart rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars (600+ reviews)
- Parents like plant-based formula and softness
- Complaints of shredding, especially when wet
Overall, both wipes score very well with parents who have used them. The Simply Clean wipes rate slightly higher for durability, while Natural Care gets nudged up for its natural ingredients.
Also watch the video!
Sensitive Skin Suitability
A key consideration for many parents is how suitable the wipes are for sensitive skin. Here is how the two compare:
- Both are certified by the National Eczema Association as acceptable for eczema-prone skin.
- The hypoallergenic and fragrance-free formulas minimize allergy risk.
- Simply Clean wipes contain fewer ingredients overall.
- The plant-based formulas provide soothing natural extracts.
- Parents of babies with sensitivities give both products high marks.
While minor ingredients differ, Natural Care and Simply Clean wipes are comparable choices for avoiding skin irritation. Simple Clean gets a slight edge for its shorter ingredients list.
Environmental Impact
Today’s parents also consider the environmental footprint of baby care products. Here is how these two wipe varieties stack up:
- Both are biodegradable and contain plant-based ingredients.
- The wipes are plastic-free and use recyclable packaging.
- Water is the main ingredient in both wipe solutions.
- Huggies has a recycling program for used wipes through TerraCycle.
- No major differences between the two for environmental friendliness.
Overall, Huggies Simply Clean and Natural Care wipes are eco-friendly options compared to wipes with harsh cleaners and plastics. Their biodegradable plant-based formulas set them apart.
Also Read: Comparison Between Enflora LGG And Probiotic LGG.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Yes, Huggies Natural Care wipes are a very good option especially for babies with sensitivities. The hypoallergenic, plant-based formula is free of concerning chemicals. Parents give them high ratings for being gentle, effective, and soft.
Huggies Natural Care wipes can be used for a wide variety of baby cleaning needs. They are ideal for wiping faces, hands, bottoms, and messy skin during diaper changes. The wipes clean effectively while also moisturizing skin.
Huggies Natural Care wipes are formulated to be good for babies, including newborns. The National Eczema Association seal means they are suitable for babies prone to skin irritation. Parents of babies with sensitivities are pleased with their performance. The plant-based formula provides extra gentleness.
Also Read: Comparison Between Coterie And Water Wipes.
Conclusion
To recap the major differences:
Huggies Simply Clean
- Thicker, textured wipes for scrubbing messes
- Shorter ingredients list with fewer synthetics
- More durable and less prone to shredding
- Unscented formula
- Very highly rated for sensitive skin suitability
Huggies Natural Care
- Smoother wipes with triple layer cleaning
- More botanical extracts like cucumber and aloe
- Natural branding appeals to some parents
- Slightly more prone to shredding when wet
- Comparable to Simply Clean for skin sensitivities
For many babies, either wipe will provide a great cleansing option free of harsh chemicals. Simply Clean wins out slightly for its durability and simpler formula. But Natural Care also scores well for its natural profile and softness.
While minor differences exist, both Huggies options are excellent choices for parents wanting a sensitive, eco-friendly wipe.