Electric scooters have exploded in popularity in recent years as an eco-friendly and convenient way to get around urban areas. Two of the most popular models on the market are the Hiboy S2 Max and the Ninebot Max.
But how do these two electric scooters compare, and which one is better for your needs?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll break down the key features, performance, price, and pros and cons of each model to help you decide.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Hiboy S2 Max | Ninebot Max |
| Max Speed | 18.6 mph | 18.6 mph |
| Range | 17 miles | 40 miles |
| Motor | 350W rear motor | 350W front wheel motor |
| Battery | 432Wh | 551Wh |
| Tires | 8.5″ solid tires | 10″ pneumatic tires |
| Brakes | Front and rear disc brakes | Front and rear drum brakes |
| Weight | 28 lbs | 42 lbs |
| Water resistance | IPX4 | IPX5 |
| Customizability | Accessories available | No accessories offered |
| Portability | Excellent – one step folding | Moderate – heavier to carry |
| Price | $709 average retail | $960 average retail |
Overview And Specs
The Hiboy S2 Max and the Ninebot Max are both electric kick scooters designed for commuting and riding around town. They have similar max speeds and ranges, but differ in their motors, tires, brakes, and several other specs.
Hiboy S2 Max
- Max speed: 18.6 mph
- Range: 17 miles
- Motor: 350W brushless rear motor
- Battery: 432Wh lithium-ion
- Tires: 8.5 inch solid tires
- Brakes: Front and rear disc brakes
- Weight: 28 lbs
Ninebot Max
- Max speed: 18.6 mph
- Range: 40 miles
- Motor: 350W front wheel hub motor
- Battery: 551Wh lithium-ion
- Tires: 10 inch pneumatic tires
- Brakes: Front and rear drum brakes
- Weight: 42 lbs
As you can see, the Ninebot Max has a longer maximum range but is also quite a bit heavier than the Hiboy S2 Max. The Hiboy is lighter and more portable, while the Ninebot offers a smoother ride with its air-filled tires.
Let’s look at each model in more detail.
Design And Build Quality
In terms of design, the Hiboy S2 Max features a minimalist aesthetic with a tall steering column and deck. The overall construction uses aluminum alloy which is durable while keeping the weight down. The scooter deck provides about 7 inches of room to stand on.
The Ninebot Max has a stouter, more solid build made from high-strength plastic. It provides more stability than the Hiboy S2 Max, with a wider 4.5 inch deck. However, the heavier frame and components add considerable weight.
Both scooters have good levels of water resistance and can handle splashes and light rain. However, the Ninebot Max edges out with an IPX5 rating allowing it to withstand more intense water exposure compared to the Hiboy’s IPX4 rating.
For lighting, the Hiboy S2 Max has a bright LED headlight and rear brake light powered by the main battery. The Ninebot Max also has a front LED headlight but it is generally considered less bright than the Hiboy’s.
Performance And Handling
When it comes to real world speed and acceleration, the Hiboy S2 Max and Ninebot Max are evenly matched. Both can reach a top speed of around 18.5 mph in optimal conditions. The acceleration and hill climbing ability are similar between the two as well.
However, the Ninebot Max offers a more comfortable ride thanks to its air-filled tires that help absorb bumps and vibration. The solid tires of the Hiboy S2 Max transmit more shock through to the rider on uneven roads. The Ninebot Max is able to tackle curbs and bumps more smoothly.
In terms of braking, the Hiboy S2 Max uses front and rear mechanical disc brakes that deliver strong stopping power. The Ninebot Max has drum brakes front and rear which some users report can feel slightly mushy compared to disc brakes. However, both scooters provide adequate braking capability for safety.
For handling, the Ninebot Max provides more stability with its wider platform and lower center of gravity. At higher speeds, the Hiboy S2 Max can feel more wobbly in comparison. The Ninebot Max generally gives riders more confidence with its planted feel and pneumatic tires.
Also Read: Choose Between Aventon And Pedego Ebikes.
Features And Customizability
Both the Hiboy S2 Max and Ninebot Max come with a range of convenience features, but the Hiboy has a slight edge when it comes to customization options.
The Hiboy S2 Max includes integrated cruise control and support for an add-on seat attachment. The scooter’s LED display shows speed, battery level, riding mode, and other helpful info. For customization, Hiboy offers a selection of accessories like phone mounts, baskets, carrying straps, and colored silicone handle grips allowing you to tailor the scooter to your preferences.
The Ninebot Max includes the ability to lock the rear wheel remotely using the smartphone app. The LED dashboard cleanly shows speed and battery level. However, customization options are lacking compared to the Hiboy S2 Max. Currently, Ninebot does not offer official accessories to customize the Max model.
Both scooters connect to apps on your iOS or Android device via Bluetooth. The apps allow monitoring the scooter status, activating security features, customizing performance settings, and more.
Portability
A major advantage of the Hiboy S2 Max is its lighter weight of only 28 pounds. It’s among the most portable full-featured electric scooters out there. The one-step folding mechanism quickly collapses the handlebar and makes the scooter very easy to carry or stow away.
Meanwhile, the heavier Ninebot Max tips the scales at 42 pounds. The bulkier frame and components add to the overall weight, making it more difficult to haul up stairs or onto public transportation. The Ninebot does still fold down, but is ultimately less portable compared to the lighter Hiboy alternative.
Price And Value
When it comes to price, the Hiboy S2 Max retails for $709 on average. The Ninebot Max has a higher $960 retail price tag.
However, the extra cost of the Ninebot Max may be justified if you need the extended 40 mile range and high stability it provides. The overall premium build quality also makes it worth the price for many riders.
The Hiboy S2 Max offers excellent value at its lower price point. For shorter urban commutes under 20 miles, the Hiboy can meet the majority of riders’ needs while costing several hundred dollars less than the Ninebot Max.
Also read: Comparison Between Hiboy S2 Pro and Max3
Reliability And Warranty
The reliability and warranty coverage can give insight into the overall durability you can expect from each electric scooter model.
The Hiboy S2 Max is backed by a 1 year limited warranty. User reports indicate the scooter generally offers good reliability, although occasional issues with the motor or battery can arise after a year or two of steady use. Hiboy Service provides responsive customer support to troubleshoot problems.
Ninebot Max buyers are covered by a generous 1 year or 180 day warranty if used commercially. The Max lives up to its name with impressive reliability and durability. The water resistance provides added peace of mind. Ninebot service is also responsive in case any issues occur down the road.
Also watch the video!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
The Hiboy S2 Max is an upgraded version of the standard Hiboy S2. The Max model has a larger battery for increased range (17 miles Vs. 12 miles), more powerful 350W motor (Vs. 250W), front and rear disc brakes, and a digital LED display. The Max also includes cruise control and has a higher weight capacity of 260 lbs.
Some top alternatives to consider instead of the Ninebot Max are the Hiboy S2 Max, Gotrax G4, Apollo Explore, and Evolv Tour 2. The Hiboy S2 Max offers many premium features at a more affordable price point.
The G4, Explore, and Tour 2 also provide excellent performance for hundreds less than the Ninebot Max.
For riders needing to cover longer distances or demanding maximum stability, the Ninebot Max is likely worth the higher price. The 40 mile range, smooth ride, and robust build quality make it a worthwhile investment for frequent daily commuting.
More casual riders may be better served by a lighter and cheaper alternative like the Hiboy S2 Max.
The Hiboy S2 Max has a top speed of 18.6 mph in optimal conditions on flat terrain. It can reach speeds over 15 mph quite quickly, while acceleration gradually slows down approaching the max.
Hills and heavier riders will impact overall speed. The 350W motor provides peppy performance for most urban commutes under 20 miles.
Also Read: Comparison Between Varla Eagle One And Apollo Phantom.
The Verdict
Overall, the Ninebot Max is the superior choice if you demand maximum range, stability, and premium construction. However, the Hiboy S2 Max offers an impressive balance of performance, features, and value at a more affordable price point.
For shorter urban commutes under 20 miles, the Hiboy S2 Max will satisfy many riders’ needs while costing hundreds less. But for longer distances or daily heavy use, the Ninebot Max justifies its higher price with extra range, smoother ride, and robust durability.
Ultimately, the ideal electric scooter comes down to your budget and performance requirements. Both the Hiboy S2 Max and Ninebot Max are high quality options among the best electric scooters on the market. By understanding their key differences, you can decide which model is the best match for your personal transportation needs.