Ellaola Vs. Tubby Todd

As a mom navigating the overwhelming world of baby skincare, I’ve spent countless hours searching for products that are safe, effective, and gentle for my little one’s sensitive skin. In this article, I’m comparing two popular brands—EllaOla and Tubby Todd—to help you decide which is best for your baby. I’ll break down their key features, weigh the pros and cons, and share my real-world insights to make your choice easier. Whether you’re battling eczema or just want a reliable moisturizer, I’ve got you covered with a detailed, engaging analysis.

Comparison Table

My Journey With Baby Skincare

When my son developed a stubborn rash on his cheeks, I panicked. His delicate skin looked angry, and I felt helpless. Like many parents, I turned to the internet, where I found EllaOla and Tubby Todd popping up in mom forums and product reviews. Both brands promised gentle, natural solutions, but I needed to know which one would truly deliver. So, I rolled up my sleeves, ordered their best-selling creams, and put them to the test. Here’s what I discovered about these two brands, their philosophies, and how their products stack up in real life.

Ellaola: The Science-Backed Newcomer

EllaOla burst onto the scene in 2019, founded by Holly Pan, a mom driven to create safe, effective skincare for her baby’s sensitive skin. The brand’s mission is clear: combine cutting-edge science with natural ingredients to nurture delicate skin. Their products are crafted with pediatric dermatologists, rigorously tested, and backed by certifications like the Environmental Working Group (EWG), National Eczema Association, and USDA. This gave me confidence that EllaOla wasn’t just another trendy brand but one with serious credentials.

Key Features of EllaOla

• Ceramides and Vitamin B5: These ingredients strengthen the skin barrier, locking in moisture and keeping irritants out. My son’s cheeks felt softer within days.
• 96-Hour Hydration: EllaOla’s face cream passed a 96-hour hydration test, which I found impressive. Even after a day without reapplying, his skin stayed smooth.
• Fragrance-Free: No essential oils or scents, making it ideal for babies with eczema or allergies.
• Shea Butter and Oatmeal: These soothe and hydrate, perfect for dry, irritated skin.
• EWG Verification: Ranks high for ingredient safety, giving me peace of mind.

Pros of EllaOla

• Unmatched Safety Standards: The EWG verification and National Eczema Association seal are gold standards. I felt safe using it on my newborn.
• Long-Lasting Moisture: The 96-hour hydration claim held up, reducing how often I needed to reapply.
• Gentle for Eczema: My son’s flare-ups calmed significantly after a week of use.
• Simple Application: The cream absorbs quickly, leaving no greasy residue.
• Affordable Luxury: At around $28 for an 8-ounce jar, it’s a steal for the quality.

Cons of EllaOla

• Limited Product Range: EllaOla focuses solely on baby skincare, so no options for older kids or parents.
• Stronger Herbal Scent in Oils: While the creams are fragrance-free, their massage oil has a noticeable herbal aroma that might not suit everyone.
• Availability: Primarily sold online, so you can’t grab it at Target during a diaper run.
• Newer Brand: With only six years in the market, it lacks the long-term reputation of older competitors.

Read More: My Thoughts on Cubo Vs. Nanit.

Tubby Todd: The Family-Favorite Veteran

Tubby Todd, founded in 2014 by Andrea Faulkner Williams and Brian Williams, is a household name in baby skincare. Born from the couple’s quest for gentle products for their own kids, the brand has grown into a full line for babies, kids, and even moms. Known for its plant-based ingredients and cute packaging, Tubby Todd has a loyal following. I was drawn to their All Over Ointment (AOO), which promised to tackle everything from eczema to diaper rash.

Key Features of Tubby Todd

• Plant-Based Ingredients: Lavender, chamomile, and calendula soothe skin, while shea butter hydrates.
• Versatile Products: From ointments to sunscreens, they cover a wide range of needs.
• Fragrance Options: Choose between natural essential oil scents (like lavender) or fragrance-free.
• Colloidal Oatmeal: Found in their AOO, it’s gluten-free and helps relieve itching.
• Mama Collection: Includes belly oil and nipple balm, which I appreciated during postpartum.

Pros of Tubby Todd

• Broad Product Line: Whether you need a chest rub or sunscreen, Tubby Todd has it all.
• Effective for Dry Skin: The AOO worked wonders on my son’s dry patches, especially during winter.
• Family-Run Vibe: The brand’s personal story and responsive customer service make it feel trustworthy.
• Thick Texture: The ointment creates a protective barrier, great for diaper rash or windburn.
• Widely Available: Found online and in select stores, it’s easier to restock.

Cons of Tubby Todd

• No EWG Verification: Unlike EllaOla, Tubby Todd lacks third-party safety certifications, which made me question some ingredients.
• Higher Price Point: At $36 for an 8-ounce Dream Cream, it’s pricier than EllaOla.
• Essential Oil Concerns: The scented versions may irritate super-sensitive skin or eyes.
• Thick Consistency: The AOO can feel heavy and take longer to absorb.
• Shorter Hydration: I needed to reapply daily, unlike EllaOla’s longer-lasting moisture.

Head-To-Head Comparison

To get a clearer picture, I tested EllaOla’s Baby Face Cream and Tubby Todd’s All Over Ointment on my son for two weeks each. Here’s how they performed across key factors.

Ingredient Safety

EllaOla takes the lead with its EWG verification and certifications from the National Eczema Association and USDA. These credentials reassured me that every ingredient was vetted for safety. Tubby Todd, while free of parabens, gluten, and synthetic fragrances, doesn’t have the same level of third-party validation. Their use of essential oils in some products also raised a flag for me, as my son’s skin is prone to reactions. If safety is your top priority, EllaOla feels like the safer bet.

Effectiveness

Both brands delivered results, but in different ways. EllaOla’s face cream soothed my son’s eczema flare-ups within days, and the hydration lasted impressively long. I could skip a day of application, and his skin still felt soft. Tubby Todd’s AOO was a lifesaver for dry patches and diaper rash, creating a thick barrier that protected against irritation. However, I had to reapply it daily, and it didn’t calm eczema as quickly as EllaOla. For severe eczema, EllaOla wins; for versatility, Tubby Todd shines.

Texture and Application

EllaOla’s cream is rich but absorbs quickly, leaving no residue. I loved how easy it was to apply during a squirmy diaper change. Tubby Todd’s AOO, while effective, is thicker and stickier, requiring more effort to rub in. It’s great for targeted areas like elbows or knees but less practical for full-body use. If you value ease of application, EllaOla is the better choice.

Scent

EllaOla’s fragrance-free formula was a relief for my son’s sensitive skin. I didn’t have to worry about irritation from scents. Tubby Todd offers both scented and fragrance-free options, but the lavender-scented AOO was too strong for my liking. While the natural essential oils are appealing to some, they’re a risk for babies with allergies. EllaOla’s scent-free approach feels safer.

Price and Value

EllaOla’s Baby Face Cream (~$28 for 8 oz) is more budget-friendly than Tubby Todd’s Dream Cream (~$36 for 8 oz). Given EllaOla’s longer-lasting hydration, I felt I got more bang for my buck. Tubby Todd’s higher price is justified by its broader product range and thicker formulas, but it’s a tougher sell if you’re only buying one item. For value-conscious parents, EllaOla edges out.

Packaging and Accessibility

Both brands have sleek, user-friendly packaging, but Tubby Todd’s colorful designs are more eye-catching. EllaOla’s minimalist bottles look chic but are harder to find in stores. Tubby Todd is available at Target and Amazon, making it more convenient for last-minute purchases. If you prefer shopping in-store, Tubby Todd wins; for online shoppers, both are equally accessible.

Real-World Scenarios

To make this comparison practical, let’s look at how these products fit into common parenting situations.

Scenario 1: Eczema Flare-Ups

If your baby has eczema, EllaOla’s Baby Face Cream is my top pick. Its ceramides and vitamin B5 strengthened my son’s skin barrier, reducing redness in less than a week. The National Eczema Association seal gave me confidence, and the fragrance-free formula didn’t aggravate his condition. Tubby Todd’s AOO helped with itching but didn’t clear flare-ups as fast.

Scenario 2: Diaper Rash

For diaper rash, Tubby Todd’s AOO is unbeatable. Its thick, beeswax-based formula creates a protective shield that healed my son’s rash overnight. EllaOla’s cream is too light for this purpose, better suited for face or body moisturizing. If diaper rash is your main concern, go with Tubby Todd.

Scenario 3: Everyday Moisturizing

For daily use, EllaOla’s long-lasting hydration makes it a no-brainer. I applied it after baths, and my son’s skin stayed soft for days. Tubby Todd’s Everyday Lotion is great but requires more frequent application. If you want a low-maintenance routine, EllaOla is the way to go.

Scenario 4: Sensitive Eyes

My son loves splashing during bath time, and I worried about products getting in his eyes. EllaOla’s fragrance-free cream didn’t cause irritation, even when he rubbed his eyes. Tubby Todd’s scented products stung slightly when accidentally splashed, so I stuck with their fragrance-free options. EllaOla feels safer for eye-sensitive babies.

Which Brand Suits Your Needs?

Choosing between EllaOla and Tubby Todd depends on your baby’s skin needs and your preferences as a parent. If you’re dealing with eczema or want a science-backed, fragrance-free product, EllaOla is your best bet. Its certifications, long-lasting moisture, and affordable price make it a standout. If you need a versatile product for diaper rash, dry patches, or even mama skincare, Tubby Todd’s broad range and thick formulas are hard to beat.

I lean toward EllaOla for its safety credentials and effectiveness on my son’s eczema, but I keep Tubby Todd’s AOO in my diaper bag for emergencies. Both brands are excellent, but EllaOla’s focus on baby-specific needs gives it a slight edge for newborns and sensitive skin.

Also read: My Thoughts on Primally Pure Vs. Beautycounter.

Frequently Asked Questions (Faq)

Conclusion

After testing EllaOla and Tubby Todd, I’ve learned that both brands offer quality solutions for your baby’s skin, but they cater to slightly different needs. EllaOla’s science-backed, fragrance-free formulas are perfect for eczema and sensitive skin, while Tubby Todd’s versatile, plant-based products shine for diaper rash and family-wide use. I hope my insights help you choose the right product for your little one. You’ve got this, and with the right skincare, your baby’s skin will thank you!