Dermablend vs. Dermacolor: A Personal Journey Through High-Coverage Makeup

I’ve spent years chasing the perfect foundation to cover my skin imperfections—scars, redness, and the occasional tattoo I’d rather hide at formal events. As someone who’s tried countless products, I’ve narrowed my focus to two heavyweights in the high-coverage makeup world: Dermablend and Dermacolor. 

My goal in this article is to share my experience comparing these brands, breaking down their pros, cons, and key features from a real user’s perspective. Whether you’re covering blemishes or vitiligo, I’ll help you decide which product suits your needs.

Comparison Table: Dermablend vs. Dermacolor

My Journey with High-Coverage Makeup

I’ve always been fascinated by makeup’s ability to transform—not just how I look but how I feel. A scar on my cheek from a childhood accident and some hyperpigmentation have made me a bit self-conscious, so I’ve leaned on high-coverage foundations to even things out.

Dermablend and Dermacolor caught my attention because they’re both praised for covering everything from acne to tattoos. But which one works better for someone like me, who wants reliable coverage without feeling like I’m wearing a mask? Let’s break it down.

Dermablend: The Everyday Champion

I first tried Dermablend’s Cover Crème at a friend’s wedding, desperate to hide a fresh scar from a minor surgery. The creamy texture felt luxurious, and I was impressed by how easily it melted into my skin. Dermablend Professional, the brand behind it, is a dermatologist favorite for its high-pigment formulas that tackle everything from vitiligo to rosacea.

Their products are designed to be breathable yet powerful, offering full coverage without clogging pores.

Key Features of Dermablend

• Buildable Coverage: I love that I can apply a thin layer for a natural look or layer it up to hide stubborn discoloration. Their Flawless Creator Liquid Foundation Drops are a standout for this versatility.
• SPF Protection: Most Dermablend products, like the Smooth Liquid Camo Foundation, come with SPF 25 or 30. As someone who burns easily, I appreciate the built-in sun protection.
• Hydrating Ingredients: Glycerin and sodium hyaluronate keep my dry skin happy, preventing that tight, cakey feeling I’ve experienced with other brands.
• Shade Range: With around 30 shades across warm, cool, and neutral undertones, finding a match was straightforward. Their partnership with Match My Makeup makes shade selection a breeze.
• Non-Comedogenic: As someone with sensitive skin, I was relieved to find Dermablend’s formulas are fragrance-free, paraben-free, and won’t clog pores.

Pros of Dermablend

• Easy Application: Whether I use a sponge, brush, or my fingers, Dermablend blends seamlessly. It’s forgiving, even for makeup novices like me.
• Long-Lasting: With their Loose Setting Powder, I’ve gone 16 hours without touch-ups, even in humid weather.
• Skin-Friendly: The non-comedogenic, dermatologist-tested formulas never irritated my sensitive skin or triggered breakouts.
• Versatile Products: From the Cover Crème for heavy-duty coverage to the Continuous Correction CC Cream for lighter days, Dermablend offers options for every occasion.
• Affordable: At $30-$40, it’s reasonably priced for the quality and coverage.

Cons of Dermablend

• Limited Extreme Coverage: While it’s great for most imperfections, Dermablend struggles with very dark tattoos or severe vitiligo compared to Dermacolor.
• Shade Matching Challenges: Although the shade range is solid, my skin tone shifts seasonally, and finding an exact match in winter was tricky.
• Can Feel Greasy: On oily skin days, I noticed the Cover Crème felt a bit heavy unless I set it well.
• Not Fully Waterproof: It’s transfer-resistant, but sweat or swimming can cause fading without extra setting spray.

Dermacolor: The Professional’s Choice

Next, I ventured into Kryolan’s Dermacolor Camouflage Creme, a staple in professional makeup kits. I bought a mini palette to test it out, hoping to cover a small tattoo on my wrist for a family event. The thick, pigment-packed formula intimidated me at first—it’s not as intuitive as Dermablend. But once I got the hang of it, the coverage was unmatched.

Key Features of Dermacolor

• Extreme Coverage: Dermacolor is a beast at hiding tattoos, scars, and vitiligo. It’s designed for stage and film, so it’s no surprise it can cover anything.
• Extensive Shade Range: With around 75 shades, I had no trouble finding a match, even for my tricky undertones.
• Waterproof Formula: Once set with Dermacolor’s Fixing Powder or Spray, it’s practically bulletproof—perfect for long days or humid climates.
• Long Wear: I’ve worn it for 24 hours with minimal fading, even after swimming.
• Professional-Grade: It’s a favorite among makeup artists for its reliability in high-stakes settings.

Pros of Dermacolor

• Unparalleled Coverage: No other product I’ve tried comes close to hiding my wrist tattoo as effectively.
• Durable: Waterproof, smudge-proof, and rub-proof, it’s ideal for events where you can’t touch up.
• Customizable Palettes: The mini palettes (6, 12, or 24 shades) let you mix and match for a perfect blend.
• Matte Finish: It gives a polished, professional look that photographs well.
• Versatile Use: Beyond the face, it works on arms, legs, and body for full camouflage.

Cons of Dermacolor

• Learning Curve: The thick texture requires practice to apply smoothly. My first attempt looked patchy until I learned to warm it up on my hand.
• Fragrance Concerns: Unlike Dermablend, Dermacolor contains fragrance, which irritated my sensitive skin slightly.
• Heavy Feel: It can feel like a mask if overapplied, especially in hot weather.
• Less Accessible: You’re more likely to find it at specialty retailers or online, not your local drugstore.
• Pricey Add-Ons: The Fixing Powder and Spray are almost mandatory for best results, bumping up the cost.

Head-to-Head: My Experience Comparing the Two

To really put these products to the test, I wore Dermablend Cover Crème one day and Dermacolor Camouflage Creme the next, both set with their respective powders. My goal was to cover my cheek scar and some redness around my nose, then see how they held up through a busy day.

Application and Blendability

Dermablend was a dream to apply. I used a damp sponge, and the Cover Crème blended effortlessly, leaving a natural, slightly dewy finish. It felt lightweight, and I didn’t need much to cover my scar. Dermacolor, on the other hand, took more effort. The thick cream needed warming up between my fingers to avoid streaks, and I had to work quickly to blend it before it set. Once I got it right, though, the coverage was flawless—my scar vanished completely.

Coverage and Finish

Dermablend’s coverage was impressive for my everyday needs. My scar was barely visible, and the redness was neutralized with a single layer. The finish was natural, almost like my skin but better. Dermacolor took it to another level. My scar, redness, and even a faint birthmark I hadn’t noticed before were completely gone. The matte finish looked polished but slightly less “lived-in” than Dermablend’s. For photos or stage lighting, Dermacolor wins, but for daily wear, Dermablend feels more like me.

Longevity and Durability

Both held up well, but Dermacolor edged out slightly. After a 12-hour day that included a sweaty gym session, Dermablend faded slightly around my nose, requiring a quick touch-up. Dermacolor didn’t budge, even after I accidentally splashed water on my face. The downside? Dermacolor’s matte finish started to feel heavy by evening, while Dermablend stayed comfortable.

Skin Feel and Comfort

As someone with dry, sensitive skin, I appreciated Dermablend’s hydrating ingredients. It felt nourishing, and I didn’t notice any irritation, even after wearing it all day. Dermacolor, while effective, felt denser. The fragrance gave me a slight itch by the end of the day, which was a dealbreaker for long-term use.

Price and Accessibility

Dermablend is easier to find at places like Ulta or Dermstore, and at $30-$40, it’s a solid investment for the quality. Dermacolor’s price varies ($25-$50), but you’ll likely need the Fixing Powder or Spray, which adds to the cost. It’s also harder to source unless you’re near a professional makeup retailer or order online.

When to Choose Dermablend

Dermablend is my go-to for everyday wear. Its ease of use, skin-friendly formula, and natural finish make it perfect for covering mild to moderate imperfections without feeling like I’m wearing stage makeup. If you have sensitive skin, prefer a dewy look, or want something versatile for daily use, Dermablend is your friend. It’s also great if you’re new to high-coverage makeup or want built-in SPF.

When to Choose Dermacolor

Dermacolor shines in situations where you need bulletproof coverage. If you’re covering tattoos, severe vitiligo, or scars for a special event, it’s unmatched. Its waterproof, long-wear formula is ideal for professionals or anyone in extreme conditions (think summer weddings or beach days). Just be prepared to practice your application technique and invest in the fixing products.

My Verdict: Which One Wins?

Choosing between Dermablend and Dermacolor depends on your needs. For me, Dermablend is the winner for daily wear. Its lightweight feel, easy application, and skin-friendly ingredients fit my lifestyle better. I don’t need to hide a tattoo every day, and I value comfort over extreme coverage. But when I need to pull out all the stops—like covering a tattoo for a formal event—Dermacolor is my secret weapon. Its durability and camouflage power are unbeatable, even if it takes more effort.

Tips for Getting the Most Out of Both

• Dermablend: Prep your skin with a hydrating primer like their Insta-Grip Jelly Primer. Apply in thin layers and set with Loose Setting Powder for all-day wear. If your skin is oily, use a mattifying primer to prevent greasiness.
• Dermacolor: Warm the cream between your fingers before applying to avoid patchiness. Use a small amount and build gradually. Always set with Fixing Powder or Spray for waterproof results.
• Color Matching: Both brands offer shade-matching tools online. For Dermablend, try their Match My Makeup quiz. For Dermacolor, mini palettes are a cost-effective way to test shades.
• Removal: Use a gentle, oil-based cleanser for both to avoid scrubbing your skin raw, especially with Dermacolor’s waterproof formula.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Read More: Ogee vs. Seint

Conclusion: Your Skin, Your Choice

You’ve got a choice to make: Dermablend for easy, everyday coverage that feels like a second skin, or Dermacolor for heavy-duty camouflage that laughs in the face of water and sweat. I’ve shared my journey testing both, and I hope my experience helps you find the perfect fit for your skin’s needs. Whether you’re hiding a scar, tattoo, or just want a flawless complexion, both brands have something to offer. Try them out, play with the application, and let your confidence shine through.