When it comes to choosing a gym, two popular options on the East and West Coasts are City Sports Club and 24 Hour Fitness. With different offerings, pricing, and atmospheres, it can be tough deciding which gym best suits your fitness needs and preferences.
This comprehensive guide will compare and contrast City Sports Club and 24 Hour Fitness on key factors like classes, amenities, membership options, and culture to help you determine the better fit.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Category | City Sports Club | 24 Hour Fitness |
| Price | Higher membership fees | More affordable membership |
| Amenities | Luxury amenities like pools, squash courts, juice bars | Standard gym equipment only |
| Atmosphere | Upscale, community-focused | Basic, self-directed |
| Locations | 20+ gyms, primarily Northeast US | 300+ gyms, strong West Coast presence |
| Classes | Premium coaching, specialty classes | Basic group exercise options |
| Training | Personal training, golf/tennis programming | Personal training available for added fee |
| Beginner-friendly? | Yes, but premium pricing | Yes, flexible hours, affordable pricing |
| Open gym hours | Varies, not open 24/7 | Open 24/7 |
| Nationwide access | CityPremier membership only | All-Club Sport or PF Black Card membership |
Overview of City Sports Club
Founded in 1977 and headquartered in Boston, City Sports Club started as a small tennis club before expanding into a full-service gym chain concentrated in the Northeastern United States. City Sports Club aims to foster community and personalized service in a comfortable, upscale environment.
With just over 20 locations, primarily in major cities like New York, Philadelphia, and Boston, City Sports Club gyms offer studio classes, personal training, specialty equipment like squat racks and platforms, and premium amenities.
The vibe is luxurious yet laidback, with a focus on expert coaching and community.
Classes and Training
City Sports Club prides itself on top-notch classes and personal training. Group fitness classes span modalities like boxing, barre, pilates, indoor cycling, yoga, and high intensity interval training.
Classes aim to be challenging yet welcoming to all fitness levels. For more personalized attention, City Sports Club employs knowledgeable trainers to lead private and small group sessions.
You’ll also find specialty programming like learn-to swim classes, pre- and post-natal fitness, golf conditioning, and more.
Amenities
Given its upscale positioning, City Sports Club does not skimp on premium amenities. Locations feature comprehensive strength training zones, dedicated cardio decks, basketball courts, saltwater and regular pools, hot tubs, steam rooms, and saunas.
Some even include indoor tennis courts, squash courts, rock climbing walls, juice bars, and cycling studios. Amenities aim to rival upmarket hotel gyms.
Membership Options
City Sports Club offers flexible membership options month-to-month or annually:
- CityPremier: Full access to any City Sports Club location nationwide, includes group fitness classes. Ranges $99-$199/month.
- CityFit: Access to your “home” City Sports Club location only, includes group fitness classes. Ranges $79-$109/month.
- CityFit Lite: Access to your “home” location only, excludes group fitness classes. $69/month.
Discounted student, family, and corporate rates are also available. Membership includes use of all amenities, ability to enroll in specialty programs for added fees, towel service, and guest passes.
Also Read: Comparison Between Equinox And OrangeTheory
Overview of 24 Hour Fitness
Founded in 1983 and headquartered in San Ramon, California, 24 Hour Fitness operates over 300 gyms in 14 states, primarily concentrated on the West Coast. As the name implies, 24 Hour Fitness locations are open 24/7 for convenience.
The extensive chain aims to provide a wide range of fitness offerings at an affordable price point. 24 Hour Fitness caters to the everyday gym-goer looking for cardio, strength training, and basic classes without fancy frills.
Classes and Training
24 Hour Fitness offers a variety of standard group fitness classes free with membership, including Zumba, yoga, indoor cycling, kickboxing, and step aerobics. Class variety and scheduling depends on your location.
Personal training packages are available for added fees, however 24 Hour Fitness does not emphasize premium personal training services like City Sports Club. Overall, you’ll find basic group classes and training options helpful for starting an exercise routine.
Amenities
With the focus on affordable prices, 24 Hour Fitness foregoes expensive amenities and premium services. However, you’ll still find all the standard gym equipment needed for a solid workout.
Locations feature treadmills, ellipticals, stationary bikes, weights, resistance machines, and functional training zones.
Some clubs also provide extras like pools, hot tubs, basketball courts, steam rooms, and spin rooms based on location. Don’t expect towel service, squash courts, or juice bars.
Also Read: Comparison Between StretchLab And Stretch Zone
Membership Options
24 Hour Fitness provides flexible, low-price membership options:
- Standard: Access to your “home” club, includes group fitness classes. Ranges $24.99-$34.99/month, discounted annual rates available.
- All-Club Sport: Access to any 24 Hour Fitness club nationwide, includes classes. Ranges $29.99-$74.99/month, annual discounts available.
- PF Black Card: Access to any Planet Fitness location nationwide, includes classes. $22.99/month.
Discounts for students, teachers, military, and corporate employees may apply. Membership includes amenities usage, ability to enroll in fee-based services, towel rentals, guest passes, and nationwide access depending on your plan.
Watch this review video:
Key Differences and Factors to Consider
When comparing City Sports Club and 24 Hour Fitness, the most substantial differences come down to price, amenities, atmosphere, and geographic coverage. Keep the following factors in mind when choosing the right gym for your preferences and budget:
- Price
City Sports Club is the pricier option. Entry-level monthly rates are $79 for limited access Vs.. $24.99 at 24 Hour Fitness. City Sports Club positions itself as a premium gym with services to match, reflected in higher membership fees. 24 Hour Fitness offers exceptional value prices for budget-focused gym-goers.
- Amenities and Services
City Sports Club locations offer luxury amenities like squash courts, pools, and juice bars that 24 Hour Fitness does not. Given the higher membership costs, City Sports Club delivers premium locker rooms, specialty equipment, and classes you won’t find at 24 Hour Fitness. However, 24 Hour Fitness still provides sufficient standard gym equipment for a good workout.
- Atmosphere
City Sports Club cultivates an upscale, community-driven vibe while 24 Hour Fitness offers a basic yet affordable gym experience. If you want social, expertise-focused training in a comfortable setting, City Sports Club is likely the better cultural fit. 24 Hour Fitness offers a practical, utilitarian environment focused on self-directed fitness.
- Geographic Coverage
24 Hour Fitness wins when it comes to number of locations, especially on the West Coast. With over 300 clubs nationally, 24 Hour Fitness easily out-spaces City Sports Club. City Sports Club only has locations in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic. So convenience of club access depends on your geographic location.
- Classes and Training
City Sports Club provides premium coaching and specialty classes while 24 Hour Fitness offers standard group exercise. If customized personal training and diverse, expert-led classes are important to you, City Sports Club is the better option. 24 Hour Fitness has basic classes helpful for starting a workout routine.
Also Read: Comparison Between Planet Fitness And Fitness 19.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are answers to some common questions about City Sports Club and 24 Hour Fitness:
No, City Sports Club and LA Fitness are completely different gym chains. City Sports Club operates primarily on the East Coast while LA Fitness has locations nationwide. They have different offerings, pricing, and membership options.
No, a City Sports Club membership does not grant you access to LA Fitness gyms. Memberships are valid only at the gym brand they are purchased from. You would need to buy separate memberships to use both gym brands.
Both City Sports Club and 24 Hour Fitness are great for beginners, with supportive staff and a wide variety of equipment and classes for all fitness levels. 24 Hour Fitness may be slightly better for beginners given the affordable prices and flexible open gym hours. But it depends on your preferences.
It depends on your membership level. Premier memberships allow access to all 24 Hour Fitness gyms nationwide. More basic memberships only grant access to your designated “home” location. Check membership terms when you join.
Final Thought
In the battle of City Sports Club Vs. 24 Hour Fitness, there is no single stand-out winner. The right gym for you depends on your budget, preferences for amenities and services, geographic location, and desired atmosphere.
For premium amenities, expert-led workouts, and an upscale vibe, choose City Sports Club. The higher membership fees buys you perks like squash courts, specialty classes, and premium training options in a socially-driven environment. But geographic reach is limited.
For affordability and nationwide access, go with 24 Hour Fitness. You get convenient gym access 24/7 at reasonable prices, though extras like pools, steam rooms, and premium coaching are hit-or-miss. But you can’t beat the nationwide coverage at wallet-friendly rates.
Ultimately, think about your fitness goals, budget, and preferences for things like training, amenities, and vibe as you choose between these two established gym chains. Know that neither option is the “wrong” choice – selecting the gym that best aligns with your needs will set you up for success as you get fit!