As a mom navigating the overwhelming world of baby skincare, I’ve spent countless hours researching products for my little one’s sensitive skin. My mission? To compare Bubbsi and Tubby Todd, two popular brands promising gentle, effective care. In this article, I’ll break down their key features, share my real-world experience, and weigh the pros and cons to help you decide which is best for your baby. From eczema relief to newborn safety, let’s explore what these brands offer in a clear, conversational way.
Comparison Table: Bubbsi Vs. Tubby Todd At A Glance
Feature/Product | Bubbsi | Tubby Todd |
Key Products | Whipped Coconut Oil Cream, Body Lotion | All Over Ointment, Everyday Lotion, Dream Cream |
Target Skin Concerns | Dryness, mild eczema, general hydration | Eczema, sensitive skin, redness |
Main Ingredients | Coconut oil, shea butter, sunflower seed oil | Colloidal oatmeal, aloe vera, plant-based oils |
Scent Options | Fragrance-free, mild coconut scent | Fragrance-free, lavender, citrus |
Price Range | $20–$30 for 4–8 oz | $16–$30 for 2–8 oz |
Packaging | Recyclable plastic jars, eco-friendly | Plastic tubes/jars, some recyclable |
Certifications | EWG Verified, hypoallergenic | National Eczema Association Seal, hypoallergenic |
Best For | Newborns, mild skin issues | Eczema-prone skin, sensitive babies |
Availability | Online, select retailers | Online, Target, Amazon |
My Journey With Baby Skincare
When my daughter, Ellie, was born, her skin was as soft as a petal, but by three months, dry patches appeared on her cheeks and elbows. I panicked, scrolling through parenting forums and ingredient lists, desperate for a solution. That’s when I stumbled across Bubbsi and Tubby Todd, two brands that kept popping up in mom groups. Both promised gentle, non-toxic care, but which one would work for Ellie’s sensitive skin? I decided to try them both, and what follows is my honest take after months of testing, complete with the good, the bad, and the greasy.
Understanding Bubbsi: Whipped And Wonderful

Bubbsi, a newer player in the baby skincare game, caught my eye with its playful branding and eco-conscious vibe. Their star product, the Whipped Coconut Oil Cream, felt like a luxurious treat for Ellie’s skin. It’s thick, buttery, and melts into the skin, leaving a soft, hydrated glow. Their Body Lotion, a lighter option, became my go-to for daily use. Both are formulated with coconut oil, shea butter, and sunflower seed oil—ingredients I trusted for their natural moisturizing properties.
What I loved most was Bubbsi’s simplicity. The ingredient lists are short, and everything is EWG Verified, meaning they meet strict safety standards. The fragrance-free option was perfect for Ellie’s sensitive skin, though the subtle coconut scent in their scented version felt fresh and natural. I also appreciated their eco-friendly packaging—recyclable jars that looked cute on her changing table.
But it wasn’t all perfect. The whipped cream is rich, which is great for dry patches but can feel heavy in humid weather. I noticed it took a bit longer to absorb compared to other products, leaving Ellie’s skin slightly slick. Also, Bubbsi’s price tag—around $25 for a 4-ounce jar—felt steep for daily use, especially when you’re slathering it on a wiggly baby.
Read More: My Thoughts on Cubo Vs. Nanit.
Tubby Todd: The Eczema Warrior
Tubby Todd, a cult favorite among parents, has been around longer and has a loyal following, especially for eczema-prone kids. Their All Over Ointment was my first purchase, recommended by a friend whose son battled severe eczema. It’s a thick, balm-like product with colloidal oatmeal and aloe vera, designed to soothe irritation and lock in moisture. I also tried their Everyday Lotion for lighter hydration and the Dream Cream for flare-ups.
The first time I applied the All Over Ointment, I was impressed. Ellie’s red, irritated cheeks calmed down overnight, and the texture wasn’t as greasy as I’d feared. Tubby Todd’s National Eczema Association Seal gave me confidence, and their fragrance-free options were gentle enough for her newborn skin. The lavender-scented lotion became my personal favorite—it smelled like a baby spa day. Their products are widely available at Target, which was a lifesaver when I ran out mid-week.
On the downside, Tubby Todd’s packaging isn’t as eco-friendly as Bubbsi’s. The plastic tubes are practical but less sustainable. Also, while the ointment worked wonders for eczema, the Everyday Lotion felt less hydrating than I expected for the price ($20 for 8 ounces). I also noticed that some products, like the Dream Cream, were pricier ($30 for 8 ounces) without offering significantly better results than the ointment.
Pros and Cons: Bubbsi
Pros
- Clean Ingredients: EWG Verified, with natural oils like coconut and shea butter that hydrate without irritation.
- Eco-Friendly Packaging: Recyclable jars align with my sustainability goals.
- Gentle for Newborns: Fragrance-free options are safe for the youngest babies.
- Luxurious Texture: The whipped cream feels indulgent and locks in moisture for hours.
- Simple Lineup: Easy to choose between just two main products.
Cons
- Pricey: $25 for 4 ounces feels like a splurge for daily use.
- Heavy Texture: Can feel greasy in warm weather or on less dry skin.
- Limited Availability: Mostly online, with fewer retail options.
- Slower Absorption: Takes a minute to sink in, which can be tricky with a squirmy baby.
Pros and Cons: Tubby Todd
Pros
- Eczema Relief: All Over Ointment and Dream Cream are game-changers for irritated, eczema-prone skin.
- Trusted Certifications: National Eczema Association Seal ensures safety for sensitive skin.
- Variety of Products: From ointments to lotions, there’s something for every need.
- Pleasant Scents: Lavender and citrus options smell amazing without being overpowering.
- Wide Availability: Found at Target, Amazon, and online, making restocks easy.
Cons
- Less Sustainable Packaging: Plastic tubes aren’t as eco-friendly.
- Inconsistent Hydration: Everyday Lotion didn’t impress as much as the ointment.
- Higher Cost for Some Products: Dream Cream’s $30 price tag feels steep.
- Scent Sensitivity: Scented options might not suit every baby’s skin.
Key Features Breakdown
Let’s talk about what makes these brands stand out. Bubbsi’s Whipped Coconut Oil Cream is a multitasker—I used it for Ellie’s dry patches, diaper area, and even my own cracked hands. Its coconut oil base is naturally antimicrobial, which gave me peace of mind for minor scrapes. The Body Lotion, with sunflower seed oil, was lightweight enough for daily use but still deeply nourishing. Both products are hypoallergenic, making them safe for newborns and beyond.
Tubby Todd’s All Over Ointment is the hero for eczema. Colloidal oatmeal soothes inflammation, while aloe vera calms redness. I found it worked faster than Bubbsi for flare-ups, often reducing irritation within hours. The Everyday Lotion, with plant-based oils, was fine for maintenance but didn’t wow me like the ointment. The Dream Cream, formulated for severe eczema, includes ceramides to strengthen the skin barrier, but I didn’t see enough difference from the ointment to justify the cost.
Both brands prioritize non-toxic ingredients, but Bubbsi leans into natural oils, while Tubby Todd incorporates science-backed actives like colloidal oatmeal and ceramides. If your baby has mild dryness, Bubbsi’s simplicity might be enough. For persistent eczema, Tubby Todd’s targeted formulas have the edge.
Real User Perspective: My Experience

Using these products felt like a science experiment at times. With Bubbsi, I’d scoop out the whipped cream, warm it between my hands, and massage it into Ellie’s skin after her bath. Her dry elbows softened within days, but in summer, the texture felt too heavy, leaving her skin shiny. The lotion was better for warmer months, absorbing quickly and keeping her skin smooth without residue.
Tubby Todd’s ointment was my nighttime savior. I’d apply a thin layer to Ellie’s cheeks before bed, and by morning, the redness was gone. The lotion was my daytime choice, but I often mixed it with a drop of the ointment for extra hydration. The lavender scent was calming, but I stuck to fragrance-free for flare-ups to avoid any risk of irritation.
One thing I noticed: Bubbsi felt more “natural” and aligned with my eco-conscious values, but Tubby Todd delivered faster results for Ellie’s eczema. It was a trade-off between long-term hydration and immediate relief.
Analytical Comparison: Which Is Better?
Choosing between Bubbsi and Tubby Todd depends on your baby’s needs. For newborns or mild dryness, Bubbsi’s clean, natural formulas and eco-friendly ethos make it a great choice. Its whipped cream is a luxurious all-purpose moisturizer, but the price and heavier texture might not suit everyone.
Tubby Todd shines for eczema and sensitive skin. The All Over Ointment’s fast-acting relief and National Eczema Association Seal make it a go-to for flare-ups. However, the less sustainable packaging and variable performance across their range (like the Everyday Lotion) are drawbacks.
Price-wise, both brands are premium, but Bubbsi’s smaller sizes make it feel costlier per ounce. Tubby Todd’s wider availability at retailers like Target gives it an edge for convenience. If I had to pick, I’d lean toward Tubby Todd for Ellie’s eczema but keep Bubbsi’s lotion for daily use.
Also read: My Thoughts on Primally Pure Vs. Beautycounter.
Frequently Asked Questions (Faq)
Bubbsi’s Whipped Coconut Oil Cream helps with mild eczema by hydrating dry patches, but it’s not as effective as Tubby Todd for severe cases.
Yes, Tubby Todd’s fragrance-free products, like the All Over Ointment, are hypoallergenic and safe for newborns.
Tubby Todd uses non-toxic, plant-based ingredients and holds the National Eczema Association Seal, ensuring safety for sensitive skin.
Absolutely. The All Over Ointment soothes eczema flare-ups quickly with colloidal oatmeal and aloe vera.
Conclusion: Making The Right Choice For Your Baby
You want the best for your baby’s skin, and I’ve been there, testing Bubbsi and Tubby Todd to find what works. Bubbsi’s natural, eco-friendly formulas are perfect for newborns and mild dryness, while Tubby Todd’s targeted products tackle eczema like a champ. Weigh your priorities—sustainability, cost, or specific skin concerns—and use my insights to choose what fits your family. Whether you go with Bubbsi’s whipped goodness or Tubby Todd’s soothing ointments, you’re giving your little one gentle, loving care.