When it comes to supplements, two of the biggest names on the market today are Ancient Nutrition and Garden of Life.
Both brands offer a wide range of products including protein powders, probiotics, vitamins, and collagen supplements. But how do you know which one is better for your needs?
This comprehensive guide provides an in-depth comparison of Ancient Nutrition and Garden of Life, examining the key features, ingredients, and pros and cons of each brand.
We’ll look at product quality, taste, price, and more to help you determine which supplements are right for you.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Category | Ancient Nutrition | Garden of Life |
| Product Range | Bone broth protein, multi-collagen protein, probiotics, vitamins, skin care | Protein powders, probiotics, vitamins, greens powders, skin care |
| Key Ingredients | Bone broth, collagen, turmeric, ashwagandha, probiotics | Probiotics, protein blends, organic fruits/veggies |
| Taste | Natural flavors, not always tasty | Good taste for most products |
| Price | $$$, mid to high range | $-$$$, budget to mid-range |
| Quality | Very high quality ingredients | High quality with organic options |
| 3rd Party Testing | Yes | Yes |
| Certifications | USDA Organic, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free | USDA Organic, Non-GMO, Kosher |
Overview of Ancient Nutrition
Ancient Nutrition was founded in 2016 and quickly became popular for bone broth protein powders and collagen supplements. Some key facts about the brand:
- Specializes in bone broth, collagen, and superfood supplements
- Emphasizes using real food ingredients
- Products feature protein blends from bone broth, eggs, and seeds
- Offer a wide range of collagen types and products
- Uses organic and non-GMO ingredients
- Products are gluten-free, dairy-free, soy-free
- Manufacturing follows cGMP standards
- Conducts 3rd party testing for purity and potency
Some of their most popular supplements include:
- Bone Broth Protein Pure
- Multi-Collagen Protein Powder
- Collagen Peptides Powder
- Turmeric with Collagen Gut Health
- Daily Probiotic
- Vitamin C Plus
- Ashwagandha Capsules
Overview of Garden of Life
Garden of Life was founded in 2000 and is now owned by Nestle. Some key facts:
- Specializes in supplements made from real, organic foods
- Emphasizes probiotics and protein powders
- Uses unique protein blends from organic plants
- Features probiotics, enzymes, and greens in products
- Offers protein powders for fitness, weight loss, and recovery
- Products are USDA Organic, non-GMO, gluten-free
- Manufacturing meets NSF standards
- Conducts extensive 3rd party testing
Some of their top-selling supplements include:
- Raw Organic Protein
- Dr. Formulated Probiotics
- Once Daily Women’s Multivitamin
- Raw Organic Perfect Food Greens Powder
- Vitamin Code Family Multivitamin
- Plant Protein Shake & Meal Replacement
- Vitamin D3 + K2 + A
Also Read: You Should Choose Huel Or Garden of Life
Key Differences Between Ancient Nutrition and Garden of Life
Now, let’s take a detailed look at how Ancient Nutrition and Garden of Life stack up against each other in key categories:
· Ingredients
Ancient Nutrition uses premium ingredients like bone broth, collagen, and superfoods. Their bone broth protein comes from real chicken and beef bone broth. Their collagen peptides are sourced from grass-fed, pasture-raised cows. Most products use organic fruits, veggies, and herbs.
Garden of Life focuses on using raw, organic, and non-GMO ingredients. Their protein powders use plant-based proteins like organic pea, sprouted brown rice and seeds. Many products feature probiotics, enzymes, and organic fruits and vegetables.
Both brands emphasize real food ingredients. Ancient Nutrition has a unique edge with bone broth and collagen, while Garden of Life offers more plant-based and vegan options.
· Taste
Ancient Nutrition bone broth protein has a natural broth-like taste. Their collagen peptides are relatively tasteless when mixed into foods or drinks.
Some supplements have added flavors like vanilla or chocolate to improve taste. But not all flavors are great, and some products have an earthy taste.
Garden of Life generally gets positive reviews for taste due to added flavors and sweeteners. Their protein powders come in decadent options like chocolate, vanilla, and banana cream.
The greens powders also have good flavors like apple cranberry. The vitamins have a neutral taste.
For best taste, Garden of Life products tend to be a safer bet over Ancient Nutrition. But Ancient Nutrition isn’t bad if you don’t mind an earthy flavor.
· Quality
Ancient Nutrition has rigorous quality standards. Their collagen comes from grass-fed, pasture-raised bovine. The bone broth is made by simmering bones for 24-48 hours. They use organic produce and natural ingredients. Manufacturing follows Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP).
Garden of Life also uses very high quality ingredients. Their produce is certified USDA organic and non-GMO. Unique proteins like pea and sprouted brown rice ensure quality. Their facilities meet NSF standards for manufacturing, quality control, and testing.
Both brands produce high-quality supplements from ethical sources. Ancient Nutrition has the benefit of complete control over bone broth and collagen sources.
· Price
Ancient Nutrition products fall into the medium to high end of supplement pricing. A tub of bone broth protein runs from $40-$60. Collagen supplements range from $30-$50. Some products like the probiotics and turmeric are priced lower.
Garden of Life offers more budget-friendly prices overall. Their protein powders cost $30-$50 per tub. Probiotics run from $20-$40. Vitamins and greens powders are very affordable at $20 or under. The pricing is budget to mid-range.
Garden of Life generally wins for affordability. But Ancient Nutrition offers good value for the unique ingredients.
· Product Range
Ancient Nutrition specializes in bone broth, collagen, and digestive health. They offer around 10 collagen supplement options. For bone broth protein, there are whey protein blend, dairy-free, keto, and paleo options. The range is smaller than some competitors but highly targeted.
Garden of Life has an extensive product catalog with diverse supplement types. They offer around 20 unique protein powders. There are at least 10 options for greens powders, probiotics, vitamins, and protein bars each. The range accommodates many diets and needs.
Garden of Life clearly offers a much wider range of supplements. But Ancient Nutrition still provides variety within their niche.
Also Watch This Review Video:
· Certifications
Ancient Nutrition products are USDA Organic, non-GMO, gluten-free, and dairy-free. Their facilities follow cGMP standards. They perform 3rd party testing for purity and potency.
Garden of Life also follows very stringent quality protocols. Their products are USDA Organic, non-GMO project verified, certified vegan, NSF certified, and kosher. Extensive 3rd party testing is conducted.
Both brands carry trusted certifications and maintain high standards. Their facilities meet quality manufacturing guidelines and undergo stringent testing by independent labs.
· Customer Reviews
Ancient Nutrition earns overwhelmingly positive feedback from customers. Their bone broth protein line has around 15,000 reviews on Amazon with 83% giving 5 stars. Customers praise the quality, taste, and digestive benefits. Some don’t like the earthy flavor though.
Garden of Life also has very satisfied customers. Their protein powders average 4.5 out of 5 stars from anywhere from 3,000 to 20,000 reviews each. Their vitamins and greens powders also have high satisfaction. Negative reviews are rare and minor.
Both brands have earned the trust and loyalty of customers by delivering high-quality, effective supplements. Reviews indicate most are very pleased with their purchases.
Also Read: Comparison Between HLTH Code And Huel.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Yes, Ancient Nutrition is considered one of the top brands for bone broth protein and collagen supplements. They use high quality ingredients and stringent manufacturing standards. Customers consistently give positive feedback on their products for digestibility, results, and quality.
Vital Proteins is considered the top selling collagen brand in the world right now. Their grass-fed collagen peptides dominate the market. But Ancient Nutrition and Garden of Life also offer high quality collagen supplements using clean ingredients.
Collagen peptides (also called hydrolyzed collagen) are the most effective and absorbable form. Ancient Nutrition and Garden of Life both use collagen peptides in their supplements for optimum benefits.
Some of the best collagen peptide supplements today include: Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides, Ancient Nutrition Multi-Collagen Protein, Garden of Life Collagen Beauty Strawberry Lemonade, Sports Research Collagen Peptides, Bulletproof Collagen Protein.
Final Thoughts
While both Ancient Nutrition and Garden of Life deliver high-quality supplements, they have some key differences. Ancient Nutrition specializes in bone broth and collagen while Garden of Life offers wider variety.
Garden of Life tends to be more affordable and have better taste. But Ancient Nutrition is a leader in specific ingredients like bone broth.
Look at your own nutritional needs and preferences to decide which brand aligns better. Ancient Nutrition wins for collagen and gut health. Garden of Life takes the lead for plant-based proteins and probiotics. Both are excellent companies producing supplements with integrity.