When it comes to keeping drinks cold, Yeti and Simple Modern are two of the most popular insulated water bottle brands on the market.
Both offer durable, double-walled stainless steel bottles designed to keep contents cold for hours. But which one is really the best option?
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Yeti | Simple Modern |
| Insulation Ability | Keeps drinks cold up to 24 hours | Keeps drinks cold up to 24 hours |
| Materials | 18/8 stainless steel + plastic cap | 18/8 stainless steel + plastic cap |
| Size Options | Four sizes from 12oz to 36oz | Three sizes from 15oz to 40oz |
| Designs | Solid colors and limited editions | Vibrant colors and patterns |
| Lids | Different lid options sold separately | Only one lid option included |
| Durability | Very durable, built to last | Durable but more prone to dents |
| Warranty | 5 year warranty | No warranty |
| Price | $25-$50 per bottle | $15-$40 per bottle |
| Weight | Heavier than Simple Modern | Lighter than Yeti |
Overview of Yeti Water Bottles
Yeti is one of the leading brands when it comes to heavy-duty insulated drinkware. Their water bottles are known for:
- Superior insulation. Yeti’s double-walled, vacuum-insulated design keeps drinks cold for 24+ hours. The 18/8 stainless steel construction prevents temperature transfer.
- Durable build. Made from kitchen-grade stainless steel, Yeti bottles are nearly indestructible. They can withstand falls and beatings without damage.
- Rotating cap. The unique cap twists off and has an attached ring, making drinking easy from any angle.
- Variety of sizes. Choose from 12oz, 18oz, 26oz, or 36oz capacities to meet different hydration needs.
- Interchangeable lids. You can purchase different lid styles like chug caps, straw lids, or splash-proof lids separately.
- Solid color designs. Yeti sticks to basic solid color options like black, white, navy, graphite, and more. Some limited editions have extra patterns.
- 5-year warranty. All Yeti bottles come with a comprehensive 5-year warranty against defects.
Overview of Simple Modern Water Bottles
Simple Modern offers brightly colored insulated water bottles known for:
- Equivalent insulation. Simple Modern bottles also have an insulated double-walled design to keep contents cold for 24+ hours.
- Variety of styles. Choose from an extensive range of colors and patterns including florals, marbles, and more. Unique styles for every preference.
- Lighter weight. Weighing less than Yeti bottles, Simple Modern’s are easier for prolonged carrying. But may dent more easily.
- Handle option. Some sizes come with the option of a detachable handle for easy carrying.
- Lower price point. Simple Modern bottles cost significantly less than the Yeti equivalent. Great for buyers on a budget.
- 3 sizes available. Ranging from 15oz to 40oz capacities. The 40oz is one of the largest insulated bottles available.
- Simple screw top. A basic screw top is functional and easy to use. But only one lid style is included.
- No warranty. The lower prices mean Simple Modern doesn’t include any warranty with defects.
Also Read: Comparison Between Iron Flask and Yeti
Key Differences Between Yeti and Simple Modern
Now let’s dive deeper into how Yeti and Simple Modern insulated water bottles compare across some key factors:
· Insulation Ability
When it comes to insulation performance, Yeti and Simple Modern are neck-and-neck. Both utilize an 18/8 stainless steel construction with double-wall vacuum insulation. This traps air inside to prevent temperature transfer and keep contents cold.
In independent tests, both Yeti and Simple Modern kept ice solid for a full 24 hours without any melting or condensation. You can trust drinks to stay chilled all day long with either brand.
Yeti may have a very slight edge for true all-day insulation. But overall, both perform excellently — you won’t notice much of a difference in real-world use.
· Durability
Yeti is renowned for its rugged durability, living up to the brand name’s promise. The thick 18/8 stainless steel can withstand accidental drops and dings without damage. Even the paint stays immaculately in place.
Simple Modern bottles use comparable 18/8 steel but with slightly thinner walls, making them prone to small dents with rough treatment. Their lightweight design sacrifices some sturdiness.
For people who tend to drop things, Yeti is the safer bet for long-lasting durability. But Simple Modern will withstand normal wear-and-tear just fine. The plastic caps on both brands may be more vulnerable to breaking from an impact.
· Design and Color Options
When it comes to aesthetics, Simple Modern far outshines Yeti with its huge variety of colors, patterns, and overall stylishness.
Simple Modern bottles come in every color under the rainbow, with unique patterns like solid, ombre, marble, and floral. Their use of color-blocking and stylish design details give the bottles a fun, modern vibe.
By contrast, Yeti sticks to muted solid color options like gray, navy, black, and white. Occasional special editions add extra color or graphics. But overall Yeti offers a minimalist, outdoorsy look.
For shoppers who want a bottle to stand out, Simple Modern has far more options to reflect your personal style. Yeti blends in more as an everyday essential item.
· Lid Styles
Yeti and Simple Modern take differing approaches when it comes to lids.
Yeti bottles include just the standard screw top with an attached key ring. But you can purchase various additional lid accessories like a chug cap, straw lid, or a splash-proof option. This lets you customize features to your needs.
Simple Modern just includes their standard screw top lid, which is quite basic in functionality. There are no other first-party lid options to upgrade or swap out.
So while Simple Modern keeps things simple, Yeti provides more versatility and customization via lid options you can mix and match.
· Size Range
When it comes to sizing, both brands offer a range to meet different hydration needs:
- Yeti: 12oz, 18oz, 26oz, 36oz
- Simple Modern: 15oz, 20oz, 24oz, 40oz
Yeti’s smaller 12oz size is nice for short trips, while their 36oz is great for all-day use. Simple Modern’s huge 40oz bottle can hold over a liter, one of the largest insulated sizes available.
Both have great size options in that mid-range, right around 20-25oz. This is likely the sweet spot for most people. Overall there are great carrying capacity choices with either brand.
One advantage to Simple Modern is that certain sizes, like the 24oz, come with the option of a detachable carrying handle. This makes it easier to tote larger bottles around.
· Weight
Due to the slightly thinner stainless steel in Simple Modern bottles, they are noticeably lighter than the equivalent Yeti. Exact weights vary by size, but Simple Modern shaves off several ounces across the board.
This makes their bottles easier to carry around all day without fatiguing your arm. It’s not a huge difference, but noticeable — especially for smaller folks.
However, the heavier Yeti construction contributes to its enhanced durability. You have to balance priorities here in choosing between lighter weight vs. sturdiness.
Also Watch This Review Video:
· Price
When it comes to price, Simple Modern bottles retail for around 30-50% less than comparable Yeti bottles.
For example, a 26oz Simple Modern might cost around $22, while a 26oz Yeti costs $35. The differences vary a bit by size, but you’ll always pay more for a Yeti.
Yeti does frequently run sales and promotions to help offset the higher cost. But dollar-for-dollar, Simple Modern is the wallet friendlier choice.
You get nearly equivalent performance but with big cost savings going with Simple Modern. The main tradeoffs are a lack of warranty, fewer lid options, and potentially less long-term durability.
· Warranty
One significant advantage of Yeti is that all their bottles come standard with a comprehensive 5-year warranty. This covers any manufacturer defects or leaks.
Simple Modern offers no warranty for defects in materials or workmanship. You are responsible for any issues after purchase.
For anyone wanting that peace of mind, Yeti’s industry-leading warranty is a nice perk providing years of coverage. But Simple Modern’s quality is solid too, if you handle the bottles with proper care.
Also Read: Differences Between Owala And Hydro Flask.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Yes, Simple Modern bottles offer nearly equivalent performance to Yeti when it comes to insulation and keeping drinks cold. Both utilize vacuum-insulated stainless steel to maintain temperatures for 24+ hours. Simple Modern actually weighs slightly less for easier portability. The main differences are Yeti offers enhanced durability, more lid options, and a 5-year warranty. But if you don’t need the highest ruggedness, Simple Modern works very well at a lower cost.
Yeti is considered one of the best insulated cooler and drinkware brands. Their products are renowned for superior insulation, extreme durability, and 5-year warranties. Yeti bottles in particular will keep drinks cold all day and can take plenty of wear-and-tear thanks to the thick stainless steel build. They are an excellent choice if you want heavy-duty performance. The main downside is the higher cost.
For most people, Yeti bottles are worth the investment if you can afford them. Their insulation ability is second-to-none, keeping ice solid for 24 hours straight. The durable build and 5-year warranty also ensure years of reliable use. If you want the absolute best-performing insulated bottle, Yeti is a top choice. The Simple Modern brand offers nearly as good insulation at a lower price point, but Yeti remains the premium option.
There is no single best water bottle brand, as the “best” depends on your priorities. Yeti and Simple Modern are two of the top choices for insulated stainless steel bottles that keep drinks cold. If you want just a reusable plastic bottle, Nalgene and CamelBak are very popular. For glass, Ello makes nice sustainably designed bottles. And brands like Hydro Flask and Klean Kanteen offer high-quality insulated bottles similar to Yeti. Look for BPA-free materials and double-walled insulation for the best reusable water bottles.
Also Read: Is Iron Flask Better Than Simple Modern?
Final Thoughts
In comparing Yeti vs Simple Modern water bottles, you’ll get excellent insulation and cold-keeping abilities from either brand. Yeti offers enhanced durability and lid options, but for a higher price.
Simple Modern gives you big savings and fun colors, at the expense of slightly less ruggedness.
Consider where you plan to use the bottle and your budget to choose between these two top insulated bottle brands. Both Yeti and Simple Modern will serve you well for keeping drinks nicely chilled wherever your adventures take you.