Ultimate Sack Vs Lovesac: The Battle Of The Giant Foam Chairs

I remember staring at my empty living room corner, imagining a cozy spot where I could collapse after a long week, and realizing that a stiff armchair just wasn’t going to cut it. If you are torn between the premium branding of Lovesac and the budget-friendly allure of Ultimate Sack, you are currently stuck in the same dilemma I faced when hunting for the perfect oversized bean bag. My goal with this article is to walk you through the comfort, durability, and sticker shock of both brands so you can decide if the massive price difference is actually justified. By the end of this comparison, you will know exactly which giant sack of foam belongs in your home.

A Brief Comparison Table

My Experience With Ultimate Sack And Lovesac

I started my journey with the Lovesac, primarily because their marketing is absolutely everywhere.

I walked into one of their showroom kiosks at the local mall, and the first thing that hit me was the sheer size of “The BigOne.”

It looked less like a bean bag and more like a cloud that had been tethered to the floor.

Sitting in it was an experience in itself; it didn’t just squish down like the styrofoam bead chairs of the 90s. It held me.

The “Durafoam” felt dense and supportive, almost like an orthopedic mattress that had been put through a woodchipper. However, when the sales associate told me the price—well over a thousand dollars for the size I wanted—I politely backed out of the store.

That led me straight to the Ultimate Sack. I ordered the Ultimate Sack 6000, which is roughly comparable to the Lovesac SuperSac, for a fraction of the cost. The unboxing experience was a workout. These things arrive vacuum-compressed in a brick, and you have to wrestle the foam apart to get it to expand.

Once the Ultimate Sack fully inflated (which took about two days of aggressive fluffing), the difference was noticeable but not necessarily a dealbreaker. The Ultimate Sack felt a little softer, perhaps a little less dense. I sank deeper into it, closer to the floor. It felt more like a “lounge” experience where you get swallowed up, whereas the Lovesac felt slightly more like furniture that supports you. Over time, I noticed I had to fluff the Ultimate Sack more often to keep it looking round, while the Lovesac at my friend’s house seemed to magically retain its shape. But every time I sat in my Ultimate Sack, I reminded myself that I still had an extra $800 in my bank account, and that made the foam feel just a little bit softer.

Read More: Comparison Of Chill Sack And Comfy Sack

Pros Of Ultimate Sack

• Incredible Value for Money: The most significant advantage of the Ultimate Sack is undeniably the price tag. When you look at the raw materials—shredded foam, a canvas liner, and a removable cover—it is hard to justify the quadruple-digit pricing of competitors. Ultimate Sack delivers about 90% of the comfort for about 25% of the price. For a college student, a young family, or anyone furnishing a basement rec room, this affordability allows you to buy two or even three sacks for the price of a single premium competitor. You aren’t paying for a massive marketing budget or mall real estate; you are paying for the product itself. I found that I could outfit an entire home theater room with Ultimate Sacks for less than the cost of one sectional sofa. This financial flexibility means you don’t have to be as precious with it. If the kids jump on it or the dog claims it as a bed, you aren’t panicking about ruining an investment piece.
• Made in the USA Quality: There is a certain peace of mind that comes with knowing where your furniture is manufactured. Ultimate Sack produces their bean bags in Hudson, Ohio. In an era where supply chains are fragile and quality control from overseas can be hit-or-miss, having a domestic product is a massive pro. I found the stitching to be robust and the zippers to be heavy-duty. They use double-stitched seams, which is critical when you have a 60-pound bag of foam that people are flopping onto. I have never had a seam burst or a zipper derail, which speaks to the manufacturing standards kept in their US facility. This also generally means faster shipping times within the States, as you aren’t waiting for a container ship to cross the ocean.
• Comfortable Shredded Foam Fill: Unlike the cheap bean bags of our childhood that were filled with polystyrene beads that crushed flat after a month, Ultimate Sack uses 100% virgin shredded memory foam. This makes a world of difference in longevity and comfort. When I sit in it, the foam contours to my body rather than just displacing away from me. It provides genuine pressure relief. I have fallen asleep in my Ultimate Sack more times than I can count because it eliminates pressure points. The foam is sourced locally in the USA, and it arrives clean and odorless (after the initial airing out). It mimics the feel of a high-end mattress, just in a chaotic, amorphous form. Because it is shredded, you can also manipulate the shape slightly, pushing foam into the back to create a makeshift headrest.
• Machine Washable Covers: Life happens, especially if you are eating snacks or drinking soda while gaming in your sack. The Ultimate Sack comes with removable covers that are fully machine washable. I have washed my microsuede cover multiple times, and it comes out looking brand new. The fabric doesn’t pill or fade easily. Removing the cover is a bit of a wrestle because of the size of the sack, but once it is off, you just toss it in the wash on cold and hang it to dry (or tumble dry low). This feature is essential for hygiene. The inner liner is durable enough to hold the foam safely while the cover is in the wash, so you don’t have a foam explosion in your living room. The variety of cover fabrics—from fur to suede—means you can also change the look of the room without buying a whole new chair.
• Ten-Year Warranty: While it isn’t a lifetime warranty, a ten-year warranty on a piece of furniture that costs a few hundred dollars is exceptional. This covers manufacturer defects, seams ripping, or zippers breaking. It shows that the company stands behind the build quality. In my experience, if a piece of furniture survives ten years of daily abuse, it has done its job. Most sofas don’t even last that long without sagging. Knowing that Ultimate Sack will replace a defective cover or liner within a decade gives me confidence that this isn’t a “fast furniture” item destined for the landfill in six months. It bridges the gap between disposable decor and heirloom furniture.

Cons Of Ultimate Sack

• Inconsistent Foam Density: One issue I have noticed, and that other users frequently mention, is that the foam can sometimes be inconsistent. Because it is shredded foam, you might find some larger chunks mixed with smaller bits. Occasionally, I have felt a hard “crust” on a piece of foam through the cover, which usually just needs to be broken up by hand. Unlike the highly engineered proprietary blends of more expensive brands, this feels more like raw industrial foam. It requires a bit more manual labor to keep it feeling uniform. You have to aggressively fluff it. If you sit in the exact same spot every day for a month without fluffing it, you will compress the foam into a pancake. It doesn’t have the same “memory” or bounce-back speed as the premium competitors, meaning you have to work a little harder for your comfort.
• Return Policy Friction: This is a major logistical con. Ultimate Sack offers a return policy, but the buyer is typically responsible for return shipping costs. Here is the catch: once you open that vacuum-sealed brick, the foam expands to ten times its original size. You will never, ever get it back into the original box. This means if you decide you don’t like it, you have to find a box the size of a refrigerator and pay freight shipping to send it back. The cost of shipping it back can sometimes be half the cost of the item itself. Effectively, this makes the sale final for most people. You really need to be sure you want it before you open it, because returning it is a logistical nightmare that just isn’t worth the hassle or expense.
• Cover Fit and Finish: While the covers are durable, the fit isn’t always as tailored as the luxury brands. I noticed that after a few weeks of use, the fabric can look a little baggy or wrinkly as the foam settles. It lacks that tight, upholstered look that Lovesac achieves. It looks like a bean bag. In a casual basement or dorm, this is fine, but if you are trying to put this in a formal living room, it might look a bit sloppy. The zipper flap sometimes doesn’t lay perfectly flat, or the seams might twist around the bag if you don’t orient it correctly. It is a functional cover, not necessarily a designer one.
• Limited High-End Fabric Options: Ultimate Sack offers great basic options like microsuede and fur, but they lack the ultra-premium designer textiles found elsewhere. You won’t find intricate weaves, cross-hatched linens, or specific “pet-friendly” branded fabrics that repel claws. The color palette is solid but standard—lots of browns, greys, and navies. If you are an interior designer looking for a specific shade of “greige” or a textured bouclé to match a high-end rug, you might find the Ultimate Sack selection a bit utilitarian. It prioritizes durability and softness over high-fashion aesthetics.
• Heaviness and Imobility: This is true for all foam sacks, but it feels pronounced here. The Ultimate Sack 6000 weighs around 50-60 pounds. Because it is a dead weight with no handles (unlike some competitors that might have straps), moving it is a two-person job or a very awkward solo drag. Once you place it, it lives there. Cleaning behind it is a chore. If you live in a walk-up apartment, getting the box upstairs is hard, but moving the expanded bag out when you move is even harder. It is a semi-permanent fixture in your room, simply due to the physics of moving a giant, shifting blob of heavy foam.

Pros Of Lovesac

• Superior Durafoam Technology: The heart of the Lovesac is the Durafoam. This isn’t just scrap foam swept up from a factory floor; it is a proprietary blend designed specifically for cushioning. In my experience, the difference is tangible. The Durafoam is denser and more resilient. When you stand up, the Lovesac regains its shape much faster than the Ultimate Sack. It doesn’t bottom out. Even when I throw my full weight onto it, I never feel the floor beneath me. It supports your posture better, allowing you to sit on it rather than just sinking in it. This structural integrity means you spend less time fluffing it and more time enjoying it. It feels like a piece of engineered furniture rather than just a bag of stuffing.
• Lifetime Warranty on Inserts: Lovesac offers a lifetime warranty on the foam insert. This is a massive statement of quality. They are essentially betting that the foam will never go flat and the liner will never burst. If you are spending this kind of money, that warranty is your insurance policy. I know people who have had their Lovesacs for fifteen years, and the company still honors the warranty. If the zipper on the inner liner fails, they replace it. This transforms the purchase from a short-term expense into a lifetime investment. You buy it once, and you theoretically have a giant chair for the rest of your life.
• The “Sactionals” Ecosystem Compatibility: While the “Sacs” are standalone products, buying into the Lovesac brand opens you up to their aesthetic ecosystem. The fabrics used on the Sacs often match or complement their famous “Sactional” couches. This allows for a cohesive interior design look. If you have a Sactional in “Charcoal Padded Velvet,” you can get a Sac in the exact same fabric. This coordination is something budget brands cannot offer. It elevates the bean bag from a dorm accessory to a matching component of a well-designed living room. The brand prestige also carries weight; guests recognize the Lovesac name and associate it with quality and luxury.
• Aesthetic and Cover Variety: The range of covers available for Lovesac is staggering. They offer “Custom” covers with hundreds of fabric choices, ranging from Phur to Polylinen to Velvet to leather. You can order swatches to see exactly how the light hits the fabric in your room before you buy. The “Phur” covers are particularly famous for being ridiculously soft and thick, hiding the texture of the foam underneath perfectly. The fit of the covers is also impeccable. They are tailored to fit the insert tightly, minimizing wrinkles and sag. It looks crisp and expensive, which, to be fair, it is.
• Risk-Free Trial Period: Lovesac offers a 60-day home trial with free returns. This removes the anxiety of the “return shipping nightmare” I mentioned with other brands. If you buy it and decide it is too big for your apartment, Lovesac will facilitate the return, and they cover the shipping. This shows immense confidence in their product. They know that once you get it in your house, you probably won’t want to let it go. This policy allowed me to test out the product mentally without feeling like I was gambling a thousand dollars on a hunch. It is a customer-centric approach that justifies the premium service.

Cons Of Lovesac

• Exorbitant Price Tag: There is no dancing around it: Lovesac is expensive. We are talking about the price of a used car for a bean bag. For many people, spending $1,000+ on a casual seating option is simply not feasible or responsible. You are paying for the brand name, the marketing, the mall rent, and the warranty. While the quality is high, is it four times higher than the Ultimate Sack? Mathematically, probably not. The law of diminishing returns kicks in hard here. You are paying a huge premium for that last 10% of performance and finish. If you are on a budget, that money could furnish an entire room at IKEA.
• Massive Footprint: The “BigOne” and “SuperSac” are misleadingly named—they are even bigger than you think. In a showroom with high ceilings, they look manageable. In a standard 10×12 bedroom, they are monsters. I have seen people buy a Lovesac and realize it literally takes up the entire walking space of their den. You need a large home to accommodate these properly. They dominate the visual space of a room. Unlike a sofa that sits against a wall, a round Sac floats in the room, eating up floor space in all directions. You need to measure your space three times before ordering.
• Heavy and Unwieldy: A large Lovesac can weigh between 70 to 95 pounds. Because of the density of the Durafoam, it is significantly heavier than cheaper alternatives. Moving this thing to vacuum under it is a CrossFit workout. If you move apartments frequently, the Lovesac is the item you will dread moving the most. It doesn’t compress back down easily, so you are stuck maneuvering a giant, heavy, soft boulder through doorframes and down stairwells. It is not a portable seating solution in any practical sense.
• Heat Retention: The thick “Phur” covers and the dense foam retain body heat exceptionally well. In the winter, this is a pro. In the summer, it can be a con. After sitting in a Lovesac for an hour, I often find myself getting a bit sweaty. The foam doesn’t breathe very well, and the plush covers trap that heat against your body. If you live in a hot climate or don’t have aggressive air conditioning, the Lovesac can become uncomfortably warm for long movie marathons.
• Slow Break-In Period: When you first get a Lovesac, it can actually feel a bit too firm. The Durafoam needs time and use to break in and soften up. Some users are disappointed initially because they expect to sink into a cloud, but instead, they sit “on top” of a firm mound. It takes a few weeks of jumping on it, rolling it, and sitting in it to get it to that perfect level of pliability. It requires patience, which can be frustrating after spending so much money expecting instant perfection.

Also Read: Comparison Of Chill Sack And Comfy Sack

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion

If you are looking for the absolute best lounging experience money can buy and you have a generous budget, the Lovesac is the winner. The Durafoam consistency, the lifetime warranty, and the premium aesthetic make it a legitimate piece of luxury furniture that will last for decades. It is the “buy it for life” option. However, for 95% of people, the Ultimate Sack is the smarter financial choice. It is incredibly comfortable, durable enough to survive kids and pets, and costs a fraction of the price. Unless you need the specific designer fabric options or the brand prestige of Lovesac, I recommend saving your money and going with the Ultimate Sack. You will get the same cozy, sinking feeling, and your wallet will thank you.