True Botanicals and Vintner’s Daughter are two of the most highly regarded clean luxury skincare brands. Both feature high quality ingredients and effective natural formulas targeting skin aging concerns.
But how exactly do these plant-based skincare lines compare? In this in-depth guide, we’ll break down the key differences between True Botanicals and Vintner’s Daughter.
Analyze the ingredients, benefits, feel, scent and value to help determine which premium clean beauty brand is best for you!
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | True Botanicals | Vintner’s Daughter |
| Key Ingredients | Vitamin C, vitamin A, botanical oils | Botanical extracts and nutrient oils |
| Texture | Lightweight gels and serums | Rich, nourishing face oils |
| Focus | Anti-aging, sensitivities | Hydration and nourishment |
| Range | Variety of cleansers, treatments, moisturizers | Concentrated serums and masks |
| Price | $70-$110 for serums, cleansers $35-$40 | $185 for signature serum, other $60-$75 |
| Best For | Customizable regimen, anti-aging actives | Luxe botanical oils, simplified routine |
Overview Of True Botanicals And Vintner’s Daughter
True Botanicals
- Founded in 2015 by Hillary Peterson and Christine Luby
- Based in San Francisco, CA
- 100% plant-derived ingredients, certified organic
- Focus on anti-aging, sensitive skin and problem skin
- Sold DTC online, some spas and Credo stores
- Price range $$-$$$
Vintner’s Daughter
- Founded in 2012 by April Gargiulo
- Based in Napa Valley, CA
- Handcrafted nutrient-dense formulas, 22 botanical extracts
- Hero product is Active Botanical Serum
- Sold online and select luxury spas/retailers
- Price range $$-$$$
While both brands craft non-toxic skincare without any synthetic ingredients, their specific formulations differ. Let’s do a deeper dive into their key ingredients and skin benefits.
Hero Ingredients and How They Work
True Botanicals
Some of True Botanicals’ signature ingredients include:
- Vitamin C – brightens, evens tone, builds collagen
- Vitamin A – boosts cell turnover for smoother skin texture
- Hyaluronic acid – provides hydration to plump skin
- Astaxanthin – protects against environmental stressors
- Resveratrol – strong antioxidant that rejuvenates skin
They also harness the power of nourishing botanical oils like marula, jojoba and algae. These provide essential fatty acids to nourish skin.
Vintner’s Daughter
The star ingredients in Vintner’s Daughter products:
- Grape seed oil – moisturizes and protects with antioxidants
- Echium oil – reduces redness and calms inflammation
- Rosehip oil – delivers regenerative omegas 3, 6 & 9
- Alfalfa extract – minimizes pores and provides phytoestrogens
- Resveratrol – stimulates collagen and elastin
Their proprietary Phyto Radiance Infusion process optimizes the potency of 22 active botanicals for visible radiance.
While both lines utilize antioxidant and collagen-boosting botanical actives, True Botanicals’ formulas tend to contain more traditional cosmeceutical ingredients like vitamin C and hyaluronic acid. Vintner’s Daughter focuses more exclusively on botanical oils.
Also Read: Comparison Between BareMinerals And Beautycounter.
Comparison Between True Botanicals and Vintner’s Daughter
Anti-Aging Capabilities
Let’s see how True Botanicals and Vintner’s Daughter stack up when it comes to targeting major signs of skin aging and UV damage:
Lines and Wrinkles
- True Botanicals’ vitamin A and vitamin C serums help stimulate collagen production to reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles.
- Vintner’s Daughter Active Serum nourishes with fatty acids and plant stem cells to soften lines, but doesn’t contain as many peptides and collagen builders.
Dull Uneven Tone
- True Botanicals Chebula serum combines vitamin C with brightening turmeric for luminosity.
- Vintner’s Daughter relies on soothing botanicals like chamomile and calendula to reduce inflammation and brighten.
Hyperpigmentation
- True Botanicals uses vitamin C along with liquorice root extract to inhibit melanin production and fade dark spots.
- Antioxidant rich oils in Vintner’s Daughter protect against oxidation to maintain an even tone.
Loss of Firmness
- True Botanicals’ vitamin A, vitamin C and nutrifying oils restore bounce and resilience.
- Vintner’s Daughter targets firmness with antioxidant protection from grapeseed and rosehip oils, but lacks more intensive actives.
True Botanicals takes a slight edge for harnessing advanced anti-aging actives like vitamins A and C along with botanical oils.
Vintner’s Daughter offers lovely nourishment, but doesn’t directly stimulate collagen and cell turnover as aggressively.
Range of Products
True Botanicals keeps their collection focused with just over 20 multi-tasking products including:
- Cleansers
- Serum treatments
- Face oils
- Eye creams
- Moisturizers
- Masks
- Lip treatments
Vintner’s Daughter features a very minimalist lineup of just 5 core products:
- Active Botanical Serum
- Active Botanical Mask
- Active Treatment Essence
- Eye Cream
- Restorative Skin Cream
The serums and masks make up most of their collection. Vintner’s Daughter takes a simplified, streamlined approach focusing on their signature Serum as the star anti-ager.
True Botanicals offers more variety for layering and customizing a regimen. Those seeking a robust skincare routine with clean active ingredients get more options with True Botanicals.
Also Read: Diffrences Between DermWarehouse And Dermstore.
Texture, Absorption and Feel
The texture and feel of these natural luxury skincare brands also differ:
True Botanicals: Thanks to lightweight botanical gels and nutrient-packed oils, True Botanicals products absorb quickly without any greasy or tacky residue. They leave skin feeling comfortably hydrated and renewed.
Vintner’s Daughter: The Vintner’s Daughter serums have rich, nutrient-dense textures starring pressed plant oils. They take a few minutes to fully absorb, leaving behind a dewy glow. Those with oilier skin may find the formulas too heavy.
True Botanicals gets the edge for lighter, faster absorbing textures suitable for all skin types. The rich face oils of Vintner’s Daughter nourish extremely well, but lean heavy for those prone to breakouts or oiliness.
Scent Profiles
Those sensitive to fragrance should be aware these lines take different approaches:
True Botanicals: Fragrance-free and labeled for sensitive skin. All formulas use only naturally derived essential oils for light, clean scents.
Vintner’s Daughter: No artificial fragrances, but essential oils are blended for signature aromatherapeutic scents like citrus, flowers and herbs. Potent for those sensitive to essential oils.
True Botanicals works better for those with allergies or sensitivities. Vintner’s Daughter offers a sensorial spa-like experience from their complex essential oil blends.
Cost Comparison
Given their high-grade organic botanicals, neither brand is inexpensive. But how do prices stack up?
True Botanicals
- Serums $90-$110 for 30ml
- Moisturizers $70-$85 for 50ml
- Cleansers $35-$40 for 100ml
With a full routine expect to pay $300+ monthly. However the pure, organic quality justifies the price. Sales help offset costs.
Vintner’s Daughter
- Active Serum $185 for 30ml
- Eye Cream $65 for 5ml
- Other serums $60-$75 for 15ml
A minimal 3-step routine easily exceeds $300 per month. However the serum lasts nearly 6 months with daily use.
True Botanicals works out slightly more affordable for a full regimen thanks to more product variety at lower individual prices. Vintner’s Daughter costs more upfront but their hero Serum lasts ages.
Reputation and Reviews
Both brands enjoy glowing reputations as clean luxury leaders. Let’s compare feedback:
True Botanicals
- Rave reviews for clear visible anti-aging results
- Praised as effective alternatives to conventional skincare
- Users say the antioxidant protection makes skin “glow”
- Products are called out for feeling refreshing and non-greasy
Vintner’s Daughter
- Mega-popular among beauty editors and influencers
- Active Serum dubbed a “holy grail” face oil
- Reviews describe skin as balanced, firm and hydrated
- Some sensitive skin types experience breakouts from the oils
The brands are adored for their non-toxic ingredients and healthy skin benefits. Vintner’s Daughter gets more buzz, but some report issues with pore-clogging.
Also Read: Comparison Between Vintner’s Daughter And SkinCeuticals.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Some brands similar to Vintner’s Daughter for active botanical formulas include:
Tata Harper Skincare, OSEA Malibu, Marie Veronique, May Lindstrom, One Love Organics.
These offer high-end clean luxury skincare using patented botanical blends like Vintner’s Daughter.
Yes, reviews overwhelmingly confirm Vintner’s Daughter products deliver real visible results. Their Active Treatment Serum in particular has earned rave reviews for its anti-aging benefits. After consistent use, most customers report brighter, firmer, smoother and more hydrated skin.
Independent studies have also validated the antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects of signature ingredients like resveratrol and echium oil. While it doesn’t contain some stronger cosmeceutical actives, users say Vintner’s Daughter makes skin look revitalized and renewed.
Some celebrities and models reported to use Vintner’s Daughter skincare include:
Emma Stone, Karlie Kloss, Chrissy Teigen, Rosie Huntington-Whitley, Shay Mitchell, Nina Dobrev, Sara Sampaio.
The brand has developed a big following among Hollywood celebrities and supermodels who praise the glowing results from Vintner’s Daughter serum.
True Botanicals and La Mer offer very different formulations, so “better” depends on your preferences. True Botanicals features 100% organic plant-based ingredients at a lower price point. Their vitamin and antioxidant serums deliver noticeable anti-aging results.
La Mer relies on a sea kelp infusion for intense hydration and anti-inflammatory benefits. While the creamy texture feels luxurious, La Mer doesn’t contain advanced actives for firming, brightening, etc.
Overall True Botanicals provides more targeted anti-aging action thanks to its active ingredients. But some still prefer La Mer for the immediate softness and glow.
Watch the video to know more about True Botanicals!
The Bottom Line
There’s no universal winner between these luxury clean beauty brands. Choose based on your preferences:
- Anti-aging power – True Botanicals has more actives targeting fine lines, firmness and pigmentation. Vintner’s Daughter nourishes.
- Formula feel – True Botanicals has lighter gels and serums that sink in fast. Vintner’s Daughter is richer.
- Ingredient purity – Vintner’s Daughter focuses solely on botanical oils. True Botanicals blends some cosmeceuticals.
- Routine customization – True Botanicals offers more products for layering and targeting concerns. Vintner’s Daughter is simplified around their Serum.
- Sensitivities – True Botanicals is better if you have allergies or tend to react. Vintner’s Daughter has more fragrance.
Both deliver gorgeous, glowing skin with clean ingredients. Choose True Botanicals for a complete routine or Vintner’s Daughter for signature botanical luxury!