I’m a Tesla Model Y owner on a mission to keep my car’s interior pristine, and choosing the right floor mats is a big part of that. In this article, I’ll compare Tesmanian and Tesla’s all-weather mats from a first-person perspective, breaking down their pros, cons, and key features to help you decide which is best for your Tesla.
With a detailed analysis and real-user insights, I’ll guide you through my experience to ensure your car stays protected and stylish.Tesmanian vs. Tesla
Comparison Table: Tesmanian Vs. Tesla
| Feature | Tesmanian Floor Mats | Tesla Floor Mats |
| Material | Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPE) | Thermoplastic Elastomer (TPE) by WeatherTech |
| Fit | Custom-fit, model-specific | Custom-fit, model-specific |
| Coverage | High sidewalls, extensive coverage | Moderate sidewalls, slightly less coverage |
| Price (Full Set) | ~$144–$209 (with discounts) | ~$225–$600 (depending on bundle) |
| Logo | No logo, OEM-like appearance | Tesla logo (subtle) |
| Cleaning | Easy rinse or wipe-down | Easy rinse or wipe-down |
| Durability | High, resistant to wear | High, WeatherTech-backed durability |
| Anti-Slip | Velcro strips, textured surface | Small spikes, textured surface |
| Bundle Options | Frunk, trunk, sub-trunk included in sets | Sold individually or in smaller sets |
| Shipping | Free in contiguous U.S., issues reported in Canada | Direct from Tesla or WeatherTech, reliable |
My Journey With Tesla Floor Mats
When I took delivery of my 2023 Tesla Model Y, I was thrilled but immediately paranoid about keeping the sleek interior spotless. Living in Seattle, where rain and mud are practically a personality trait, I knew all-weather floor mats were non-negotiable. Tesla’s carpet mats, which came standard, were stylish but useless against the Pacific Northwest’s wrath.
So, I began my quest for the perfect all-weather mats, narrowing it down to two heavyweights: Tesmanian and Tesla’s own all-weather liners.
I’ve used both brands over the past two years, swapping them out to test their mettle in real-world conditions—think muddy hiking boots, spilled coffee, and my dog’s enthusiastic post-park slobber. My goal was to evaluate fit, durability, ease of cleaning, and overall value, all while keeping my Tesla’s interior looking showroom-ready. Let’s break it down.
Tesmanian Floor Mats: A Deep Look
Tesmanian has built a cult following among Tesla owners, and I was eager to see if their mats lived up to the hype. Priced at around $144 for a full set (with promo codes like MYEVTRIPS for 10% off), they’re a budget-friendly option compared to Tesla’s pricier offerings. Here’s what I found.
Pros Of Tesmanian Floor Mats
- Perfect Fit and Coverage: The first thing I noticed was how snugly Tesmanian’s mats hugged my Model Y’s floor. Crafted from high-density TPE, they’re laser-measured for a glove-like fit, covering every nook and cranny. The high sidewalls—some of the tallest I’ve seen—trapped mud and water like a fortress, especially around the driver’s dead pedal, where Tesla’s mats fall short. After a rainy hike, I shook off the mats, and my carpet stayed bone-dry.
- No Logo, OEM Aesthetic: I’m not a fan of flashy branding, so Tesmanian’s logo-free design was a win. They blend seamlessly with my Tesla’s minimalist interior, looking like they rolled off the factory line. This subtle elegance is a big plus for anyone who wants protection without screaming “aftermarket.”
- Easy to Clean: Cleaning Tesmanian mats is a breeze. A quick hose-down or wipe with a damp cloth, and they’re good as new. I once spilled an entire latte on the passenger mat, and after a rinse, there wasn’t a hint of a stain. The TPE material resists grime buildup, unlike rubber mats that can turn whitish over time.
- Comprehensive Bundles: Tesmanian offers sets that include frunk, trunk, and sub-trunk liners, making them a one-stop shop. My six-piece set covered every cargo area, saving me from buying extras. The trunk mat’s tight fit impressed me—it didn’t slide around, even with groceries tumbling during sharp turns.
- Anti-Slip Features: Velcro strips and a textured surface keep Tesmanian mats locked in place. I never felt them shift under my feet, even during aggressive driving. The newer “SLP” (Version 2) models add extra grip, addressing early complaints about fitment issues.
Cons Of Tesmanian Floor Mats
- Initial Fitment Quirks: My first set (Version 1) had minor gaps along the sidewalls, requiring a heat gun and some patience to mold them perfectly.The updated Version 2 (SLP) fixed this with Velcro strips, but it’s worth noting if you’re buying older stock. The passenger-side mat was slightly wide, needing a tuck under the center console.
- Plastic-Like Feel: My wife remarked that Tesmanian mats feel “plastic-y” compared to rubber. While I didn’t mind, the TPE material is thinner than Tesla’s, which can feel less premium. Kids’ toys slid around more than I’d like during sharp turns, creating annoying rattles.
- Shipping Woes for Canadians: While shipping is free in the contiguous U.S., Canadian buyers beware. I read horror stories on Reddit about unexpected FedEx fees ($47 in one case) and delayed deliveries. Tesmanian’s customer service was hit-or-miss, with some users reporting unresponsive support for damaged or misfit mats.
- Durability Concerns: After 18 months, my driver’s mat showed a small tear near the heel rest, likely from constant foot pressure. While Tesmanian claims heavy-duty TPE, a few owners reported slits after a few months, suggesting the material isn’t as tough as WeatherTech’s.
Tesla Floor Mats: The Oem Experience
Tesla’s all-weather mats, made by WeatherTech, are the premium choice, retailing at $225 for a basic set and up to $600 for a full bundle. As an OEM product, they promise seamless integration, but do they justify the cost? Here’s my take.
Pros Of Tesla Floor Mats
- WeatherTech Durability: WeatherTech’s reputation precedes it, and Tesla’s mats inherit that legacy. Made from a robust TPE with a rigid core, they feel heavier and more substantial than Tesmanian’s. After two winters, my Tesla mats showed zero signs of wear, even with daily abuse from muddy boots and dog claws.
- Precise Fit: Like Tesmanian, Tesla’s mats are custom-fit, but the WeatherTech pedigree shines. The driver’s mat snaps into place with no gaps, and the small spikes on the underside ensure zero slippage. The trunk mat, though flatter than Tesmanian’s, fits like it was born in the car.
- Easy Maintenance: Cleaning Tesla’s mats is as simple as Tesmanian’s—hose them off or wipe them down. The textured channels trap debris effectively, making vacuuming a cinch. Salt stains from winter roads disappeared with a mild soap scrub.
- Subtle Tesla Branding: The faint Tesla logo adds a touch of authenticity without being obnoxious. For brand loyalists, it’s a nice nod to the car’s identity, unlike the generic look of some aftermarket options.
- Reliable Shipping: Ordering from Tesla’s site or WeatherTech directly was smooth, with no surprise fees. My mats arrived in five days, well-packaged, and ready to install. No horror stories here, unlike some Tesmanian experiences.
Cons Of Tesla Floor Mats
- Limited Coverage: Tesla’s mats have shorter sidewalls than Tesmanian’s, leaving gaps around the dead pedal and center console. During a heavy rain, water seeped under the driver’s mat, dampening the carpet—a cardinal sin for all-weather mats. The trunk mat also lacks a fold line for sub-trunk access, which annoyed me.
- Sky-High Price: At $225 for a three-piece set, Tesla’s mats are nearly double Tesmanian’s cost. A full set with frunk and trunk liners can hit $600, which feels like highway robbery. I could buy two Tesmanian sets and still have cash for a car wash.
- No Comprehensive Bundles: Tesla sells mats individually or in small sets, forcing you to piece together a full package. Unlike Tesmanian’s all-in-one deals, this fragmented approach is inconvenient and pricey.
- Trunk Mat Issues: The trunk mat slid around more than I expected, especially with heavy cargo. It scratched easily when I loaded my bike, looking worn after a single season. Tesmanian’s trunk mat, with its tighter fit, outperformed it here.
Head-To-Head: Key Features Breakdown
To make your decision easier, let’s compare the standout features that matter most: fit, material, coverage, price, and extras.
- Fit and Installation
Both brands offer custom-fit mats, but Tesmanian edges out slightly with its high-wall design and Velcro strips. Tesla’s mats fit flawlessly but lack the same edge-to-edge coverage. Installation for both is a 5-minute job—just lay them down and adjust. Tesmanian’s early models needed heat to flatten, but Version 2 resolved this.
- Material Quality
Tesmanian and Tesla use TPE, but Tesla’s feels denser, thanks to WeatherTech’s engineering. Tesmanian’s thinner material is durable but less premium. Both resist UV, water, and extreme temperatures, making them ideal for all seasons.
- Coverage and Protection
Tesmanian wins for coverage. Its towering sidewalls and dead pedal protection outshine Tesla’s shorter lips. If you live in a wet or snowy climate, Tesmanian’s bucket-style design is a lifesaver. Tesla’s mats are solid but leave vulnerable gaps.
- Price and Value
Tesmanian is the clear budget champ. At $144–$209 for a full set, it’s a steal compared to Tesla’s $225–$600. Frequent discounts (check Tesmanian’s site or Reddit for codes) sweeten the deal. Tesla’s premium price only makes sense if you’re a WeatherTech diehard.
- Extra Features
Tesmanian’s bundles include frunk, trunk, and sub-trunk liners, while Tesla’s piecemeal approach frustrates. Tesmanian’s logo-free look appeals to minimalists, but Tesla’s subtle branding has its fans. Both offer anti-slip features, but Tesmanian’s Velcro feels more secure.
Real-World Testing: My Experience
To give you a clear picture, I put both mats through identical tests: a rainy camping trip, a week of city commuting, and a dog-friendly beach day.
- Camping Trip
Seattle’s spring rains are relentless, and Tesmanian’s mats shone. Muddy boots left no trace on my carpet, thanks to the high sidewalls. Tesla’s mats held up but let some water sneak under the driver’s side, requiring a towel cleanup.
- City Commuting
Daily coffee runs and urban grit tested cleaning ease. Both mats wiped clean in seconds, but Tesmanian’s lack of logos made them look fresher longer. Tesla’s trunk mat slid during grocery hauls, while Tesmanian’s stayed put.
- Beach Day with My Dog
My Lab, Max, is a sand-and-slobber machine. Tesmanian’s deep channels trapped his mess, rinsing off effortlessly. Tesla’s mats did well but scratched under his claws, showing faint scuffs. Tesmanian’s trunk liner also outperformed Tesla’s for pet protection.
Aslo Read: My Thought On Yosuda Vs. Sunny Rowing Machine
Who Should Choose Tesmanian?
Tesmanian is your go-to if you want:
- Budget-friendly mats with premium coverage
- A logo-free, OEM-like aesthetic
- Comprehensive bundles for full protection
- High sidewalls for extreme weather
It’s ideal for families, pet owners, or anyone in a messy climate. Just be cautious if you’re in Canada or buying older stock.
Who Should Choose Tesla?
Tesla’s mats are for you if you:
- Trust WeatherTech’s proven durability
- Want subtle Tesla branding
- Don’t mind paying a premium for OEM quality
- Live in a milder climate with less need for tall sidewalls
They’re perfect for brand loyalists or those prioritizing longevity over cost.
Making Your Decision
Your choice boils down to priorities. If value and coverage are king, Tesmanian’s your pick. If you’re after WeatherTech’s bulletproof build and don’t mind the price, Tesla’s mats deliver. For me, Tesmanian’s balance of affordability and protection wins, especially in Seattle’s slop. But if I lived in a drier climate, Tesla’s durability might sway me.
Consider your climate, budget, and aesthetic preferences. Check Reddit or Tesla forums for user reviews, and watch YouTube comparisons (like HandyDadTV’s showdown) for visual insights. Whichever you choose, quality mats will keep your Tesla pristine for years.
Frequently Asked Questions (Faq)
No, Tesla includes carpet mats with new vehicles, but all-weather mats are sold separately.
Tesla’s all-weather mats are made of thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) by WeatherTech, designed for durability and easy cleaning.
No, Model 3 and Model Y mats are model-specific due to different floor designs, especially in the rear seat area.
TPE is the best for all-weather mats, offering durability, waterproofing, and easy maintenance. Carpet mats suit dry climates but are less practical.
No, Teslas don’t require foam tires. Some models use them for noise reduction, but standard tires work fine for most ow
Read More: My Thought on Vitrazza Vs. Lorell Glass Chair Mats
Conclusion
You’ve got a Tesla, and you want to keep it looking as sharp as the day you drove it home.
I’ve been there, testing Tesmanian and Tesla floor mats to find the best fit for my Model Y.
Tesmanian’s affordability, coverage, and sleek design make it a standout, while Tesla’s WeatherTech-backed durability and OEM vibe appeal to premium buyers. Use my insights to pick the mats that match your lifestyle—you’ll thank yourself when mud, snow, or coffee spills don’t ruin your ride.