Systane Nighttime Gel Vs. Ointment: Which Is Better For Dry Eyes?

Dry, irritated eyes are a common problem, especially at night when eyes tend to feel more parched. Systane Nighttime Gel and Ointment are two popular lubricating eye treatments meant to provide relief for nighttime dry eye. But what are the key differences between the gel and ointment forms, and which one is ultimately better?

A Brief Comparison Table

Feature	Systane Nighttime Gel	Systane Nighttime Ointment
Formulation	Clear gel	White, petrolatum-based ointment
Application	Easy to apply	Thicker consistency can be messy
Feel	Light, non-greasy	Heavier, ointment-like feel
Long-lasting	Moderate duration	Provides longer relief
Vision clarity	Less blurry	Can cause more blurriness
Versatility	Can be used day & night	Best for nighttime use
Active ingredients	Propylene glycol, hydroxypropyl guar	Mineral oil, propylene glycol
Preservatives	Polyquad, Purite	Polyquad, Purite
Osmolarity	Moderate	Higher osmolarity
Lubricity	Lubricates moderately	More lubricating
Dry eye types	Mild to moderate	Severe

Overview of Systane Nighttime Gel

The Systane Nighttime Gel is a clear, preservative-free lubricating gel designed to relieve dry, irritated eyes during sleep. Key features and benefits include:

• Gel-like consistency glides on easily without dripping or running
• Non-blurring formula improves nighttime vision clarity
• Containers hydroxypropyl guar and propylene glycol as lubricants
• Compatible for use with contact lenses
• Can be used during the day or at night
• Free of preservatives that can irritate sensitive eyes
• Provides a moderate level of lubrication and hydration
• Best for mild to moderate dry eye relief
• Portable single-use containers are convenient for travel

The gel formula means it goes on smoothly and feels lighter on the eyes compared to thicker ointments. The drawback is that the gel may not provide as long-lasting relief as a heavier ointment. But for those who dislike the blurriness and heaviness of ointments, the Systane Nighttime Gel can be an excellent option.

Overview of Systane Nighttime Ointment

The Systane Nighttime Ointment has a thicker, petrolatum-based formula designed for extended nighttime dry eye relief. Key features and benefits include:

• Thicker ointment consistency provides longer-lasting lubrication
• Contains mineral oil for added lubricity and moisture
• Highest osmolarity of all Systane products to draw more moisture
• Preservative-free, non-blurring formula
• Provides relief for severe dry eye
• Stays in place overnight without running or dripping
• May cause more blurred vision compared to gel
• Comes in convenient single-use tubes with flip-top caps
• Can feel heavy on the eyelids
• Best for overnight dry eye relief

With its thicker ointment-like consistency, the Systane Nighttime Ointment adheres better to the eye and smooths over rough areas on the conjunctiva. It provides superior lubrication and hydration for severe dry eye, although the thickness can cause more vision blurriness at night.

Also Read: Comparison Between Refresh Relieva and Refresh Contacts

Key Differences Between the Gel and Ointment

When choosing between Systane’s nighttime gel and ointment products, there are several key differences to consider:

1. Consistency and Feel on the Eye

The first big difference between these two products is their consistency. The gel has a lighter feel, kind of like a slightly thick liquid. Imagine the texture of a hair gel or a light lotion.

This means when you put it on your eye, it doesn’t feel as heavy. On the other hand, the ointment has a much thicker consistency. Think of how petroleum jelly or Vaseline feels. This denser texture helps it stick to the eye better.

This sticking property of the ointment means it can stay on your eye for a longer time. This is great if you want longer-lasting relief. But the gel, being lighter, might need to be reapplied more often if you feel your eyes drying out again.

2. Application Process

Now, when you’re trying to put something in your eye, you don’t want a mess. The gel, with its smoother consistency, is easier to apply. It glides right onto your eye without dripping everywhere. It’s like pouring a bit of syrup on pancakes – it spreads easily but doesn’t run all over the plate.

The ointment, because of its thickness, can be a little more challenging. It’s kind of like trying to spread a thick cream on bread; you need to be careful and might need to use a bit more effort.

So, if you’re someone who’s always in a hurry or just doesn’t like dealing with messy products, the gel might be your go-to.

3. Vision Clarity

One thing many people don’t think about until after they’ve applied an eye product is how it might affect their vision. The gel, being lighter, tends to cause less blurry vision.

This means if you wake up in the middle of the night and need to read something or just look around, the gel won’t get in your way as much.

The ointment, with its thicker formula, can cause some blurriness. This is a bit like looking through a foggy window. The benefit of the ointment, however, is its long-lasting moisturizing effect, which may be worth the temporary blur for many.

4. Main Ingredients

What’s inside these products? Well, the gel has two primary ingredients that help keep your eyes moist: hydroxypropyl guar and propylene glycol. These agents work to lubricate your eyes and keep them feeling refreshed.

The ointment, while it also has propylene glycol, uses mineral oil as a primary ingredient. Mineral oil acts like a barrier that locks in moisture. It’s kind of like wearing a light raincoat for your eyes, preventing dryness from setting in.

5. Preservatives and Osmolarity

Both these products are pretty gentle. They don’t have preservatives that can sting or irritate sensitive eyes. But there’s a unique thing about the ointment – it has higher osmolarity.

Without getting too scientific, this just means it draws more water or moisture to the surface of your eyes. It’s like having a small magnet that attracts water, ensuring your eyes remain well-hydrated.

Also Watch This Review Video:

6. When to Use Them

The gel, because of its lighter nature, can be used at any time of the day or night. This makes it versatile. So, if you’re out and about during the day and feel your eyes getting dry, you can easily apply the gel.

The ointment, due to its thickness, is generally best used overnight. Think of it as a deep moisturizing mask for your eyes, letting it work its magic while you sleep.

7. Severity of Dry Eye

Finally, not all dry eyes are created equal. Some folks have just a bit of dryness, while others have severe dryness. For those with mild to moderate dry eyes, the gel works pretty well. It offers enough moisture without being too heavy.

But for those with severe dry eye, where the eyes feel super dry and maybe even painful, the ointment is like a superhero. Its dense texture and moisturizing properties offer much-needed relief.

Overall, the gel may be preferred by those who dislike ointments and want clearer night vision. But the ointment provides superior lubrication and longer relief, making it better for severe cases of dry eye disease.

Also Read: Comparison Between FDgard and IBgard

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Also Read: Is Blink Gel Tears Better Than Blink Tears?

Final Thoughts

For those suffering from dry, irritated eyes at night, both Systane Nighttime Gel and Ointment can provide much-needed relief and lubrication while sleeping.

The thinner gel formula causes less blurred vision at the cost of shorter duration. Meanwhile, the thicker ointment adheres better overnight but can feel messier to apply.

In the end, mild to moderate dry eye sufferers may prefer the lighter gel for clearer night vision. But those with more severe dryness may benefit more from the thicker ointment’s superior lubrication and longer lasting relief.

Knowing the differences allows patients to choose the best Systane nighttime product for their individual needs and preferences.