Nasal irrigation has become an increasingly popular way to help relieve sinus congestion and allergies. Two of the most popular nasal irrigation devices on the market are the Sinusonic and the Navage.
But which one is better? Here is a comprehensive comparison of the sinusonic Vs. navage to help you decide which nasal irrigation system may work best for your needs.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Sinusonic | Navage |
| Irrigation Method | Ultrasonic pulsating spray | Powered suction |
| Pressure | Low pressure | Pressurized suction |
| Saline Delivery | Reservoir tank with saline solution | Single-use saline pods |
| # of Nose Pieces | 1 multi-angled nozzle | 3 customizable nose pillows |
| Comfort Level | Gentle pulsating spray | Can feel pressurized |
| Effectiveness | Breaks up mucus, flushes sinuses | Flushes sinuses more thoroughly |
| Cost | $99.95 (device only) | $139.99-$159.99 (starter bundle) |
| Cleaning | Easy to clean nozzle | More device parts to disassemble and clean |
Overview Of Sinusonic And Navage
The Sinusonic and the Navage are both nasal irrigation devices designed to flush out mucus, allergens, and irritants from the nasal cavity and sinuses.
Sinusonic uses ultrasonic vibration technology to break up and liquefy mucus. It comes with multi-angled nozzles to target different areas of the nasal cavity. The Sinusonic irrigates by releasing a gentle, pulsating spray of saline solution into the nasal passages.
Navage is a powered nasal irrigation system. It uses gentle suction to pull saline solution through the nasal cavity and out the other nostril. This creates a flushing effect to clear out mucus and debris. The Navage has proprietary “Powered Suction” technology and ergonomic nose pieces for a comfortable fit.
Both the Sinusonic and Navage are quick and easy to use on a daily basis. They are prescription-free and can be used as part of an at-home sinus care regimen.
Pros And Cons Of Sinusonic
Pros:
- Uses ultrasonic vibration to break up mucus and make it easier to flush out
- Multi-angled nozzles allow you to target different areas of the nasal cavity
- Gentle pulsating spray is less jarring than positive pressure systems
- Easy to use and clean
- Cordless and rechargeable
Cons:
- Saline solution drips out of nose rather than being suctioned out
- May not remove mucus as thoroughly as powered suction devices
- Battery life may be limited compared to other rechargeable options
- Only includes one nozzle rather than multiple nose piece sizes
Pros And Cons Of Navage
Pros:
- Powered suction actively flushes out mucus and prevents backflow
- Nose pillows come in 3 sizes for customized fit
- Empties sinuses more thoroughly than irrigation alone
- Uses less saline solution than some other irrigation systems
- Rechargeable and cordless for easy portability
Cons:
- Suction can occasionally feel uncomfortable or jarring
- Nose pillows may not fit everyone’s nasal anatomy
- Saline pods are single-use and non-reusable
- Higher initial upfront investment than some competitors
Ease Of Use
Both the Sinusonic and Navage are designed to be easy and convenient to use.
The Sinusonic involves filling the reservoir tank with premixed saline solution. You then insert the soft silicone nose piece into one nostril and turn the device on. Gently gliding the nozzle in a circular motion irrigates each nasal cavity. It’s recommended to use the lowest comfort setting when first starting out.
The Navage requires inserting a saline pod into the device and fitting one of the nose pillows into the appropriate nostril. When turned on, the device gently flushes the solution through one nostril and suctions it out the other side. The aspirator tab allows you to clear any excess solution at the end.
The Navage uses proprietary saline pods while the Sinusonic allows you to use your own saline mix. Both are portable thanks to rechargeable batteries.
Effectiveness And Results
Independent clinical studies found that both the Sinusonic and Navage are effective at improving sinus symptoms:
- The Sinusonic was clinically shown to improve stuffy noses, sinus pressure, nasal drainage, and nasal breathing.
- In a clinical study, regular use of the Navage was found to significantly improve sinus symptoms and quality of life.
Anecdotally, users of both devices report improved breathing, reduced congestion and post-nasal drip, and better sleep. The Navage seems to have a slight edge in completely emptying and flushing out the nasal cavity thanks to powered suction. But the Sinusonic also received positive feedback on mucus relief.
For mild congestion, the Sinusonic may provide sufficient relief. But those with more severe sinus issues may benefit more from the stronger suction of the Navage.
Cost Comparison
The Sinusonic costs less upfront, with a list price of $99.95 for the device. Ongoing costs include purchasing distilled water and non-iodized salt to make your own saline solution.
The Navage system is pricier, costing $99.99 for the starter bundle. But the most popularbundles go for $139.99 to $159.99. Ongoing costs include buying packages of proprietary Navage saline pods, which can add up over time.
So while the Sinusonic costs less initially, the recurring costs of the Navage’s saline pods start to close the gap somewhat. Still, the Navage involves more significant upfront investment.
Also watch the video of Navage!
Cleaning And Maintenance
Keeping either device clean is important for proper functioning and avoiding bacterial buildup.
The Sinusonic is very easy to clean. The main cleaning step is washing the nozzle with soap and water after each use. You can also periodically sanitize the entire device by filling the tank with vinegar and running a cleaning cycle.
Navage cleaning involves removing and washing the nose pillows, aspirator, and medication tray with soap and water. The main device can be cleaned by wiping with a sanitizing wipe or cleaning solution. However, saline residue can occasionally build up internally over time. Navage recommends a full device refresh after 6 months to a year of use.
So while both devices require regular cleaning, the Sinusonic’s simpler construction may require less frequent deep cleaning sessions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
The Sinupulse and Navage use different approaches to nasal irrigation, so it depends on your preferences. The gentle pulsating spray of the Sinupulse can effectively flush sinuses. But the Navage’s powered suction may empty nasal passages more thoroughly.
Many ear, nose and throat doctors do recommend the Navage system to patients with chronic sinus issues. The Navage has undergone clinical testing for safety and efficacy and is one of the more physician-recommended nasal irrigation devices available.
Yes, the saline solution flushed by the Navage does enter and travel through the nasal cavity, behind the bridge of the nose, and into the sinus cavities to irrigate those areas. The suction effect helps pull the solution through the sinuses to clear them out.
Also Read: Choose Between ResMed HumidX And HumidX Plus.
The Verdict
For reliving congestion, post-nasal drip and sinus pressure, both the Sinusonic and Navage are great options. They are easy to operate, portable, and clinically proven to improve sinus health.
However, the Navage comes out slightly ahead for people with more severe sinus issues. The powered suction system empties the nasal cavities more thoroughly. And clinical evidence shows the Navage improves sinus symptoms and quality of life.
That said, the Sinusonic is still an effective and affordable alternative. It’s a bit simpler to use and clean as well. So it really comes down to your personal preferences and nasal irrigation needs.
At the end of the day, both devices can be extremely helpful additions to your sinus care routine. But for completely flushing out the nasal passageways, the Navage remains the top choice.
You never answered the question “you” posed about whether Navage can cause sinus infections! What’s the deal with that?
Navage is not rechargeable. The necessity of having removable AA cells means there is a door that leaks and corrodes the battery compartment, destroying the unit. The life of a Navage is generally equal to the life of the batteries that came with it.