Richardson 111 Vs. 112 : Which One Is Better

I’ve worn a lot of hats over the years, from basic ball caps to premium truckers, but few have stuck with me like the Richardson 111 and Richardson 112. These two models stand out as go-to choices for anyone who wants that classic trucker style with solid comfort and breathability. In this article, I share my hands-on take on which one edges out the other, breaking down their key features, pros and cons, how they feel on the head, and more to help you decide the better pick for your needs.

A Brief Comparison Table

Right from the start, the Richardson 112 feels like the more polished, everyday reliable option in my experience. It has that mid-profile crown that sits balanced on my head without feeling too tall or too low. The structured front panels give it a clean shape that doesn’t flop around, even after months of wear. The mesh back keeps things airy during hot days, and the snapback adjusts easily for a secure fit. I appreciate how it holds up to embroidery or patches if you’re customizing it.

The Richardson 111, on the other hand, leans into a softer, more laid-back vibe. The garment-washed fabric gives it an instant vintage feel, like it’s already broken in from day one. It’s unstructured, so it molds to your head more naturally and feels less rigid. That low-pro profile makes it sit closer to the head, which some people love for a subtler look. Both have excellent breathability thanks to the mesh, but the 111’s wash adds extra softness right out of the box.

My Experience With Richardson 111

I picked up my first Richardson 111 a couple of summers ago when I wanted something that felt effortless for weekend errands or casual outings.

The garment wash really stands out—it softens the cotton-poly blend immediately, so there’s no stiff feeling when you first put it on.

I wore it hiking, running errands, and even lounging at home, and it never felt heavy or uncomfortable.

The unstructured design means it relaxes over time and conforms nicely without losing its shape entirely. On my head, it sits lower and feels more relaxed than structured hats.

The precurved bill has a gentle curve that frames my face well without looking too aggressive. Breathability is top-notch; the soft mesh back lets air flow freely, which was a lifesaver in humid weather.

I found the snapback closure straightforward, though it sometimes needed an extra notch for a perfect fit. Colors hold up well after washing, and the vintage look pairs great with jeans or shorts.

Overall, this hat became my go-to for low-key days when I didn’t want anything too “put together.”

One thing I noticed is that because it’s unstructured, it can wrinkle a bit if stuffed in a bag, but that adds to the casual charm.

I’ve had mine for over a year, and it still looks good—no major fading or stretching issues. If you prefer hats that feel broken-in from the start and offer a softer silhouette, the 111 delivers that consistently.

Also read: Comparison of OtterBox Defender And Symmetry

Pros Of Richardson 111

• Instant vintage appeal from garment wash : The pre-washed fabric gives a soft, lived-in look right away, skipping the break-in period many hats require.
• Super relaxed and comfortable fit : Unstructured crown molds to your head shape naturally, reducing pressure points during long wear.
• Excellent breathability with soft mesh : The polyester mesh back promotes airflow, keeping your head cool in warm conditions.
• Low-profile design for subtle style : Sits closer to the head, offering a less prominent look that suits casual outfits perfectly.
• Soft hand feel from cotton-poly blend : The 50/50 mix combined with washing makes it gentle against the skin, no irritation even on sensitive scalps.
• Versatile for everyday casual use : Works well for relaxed activities like errands, outdoor hangs, or light sports without feeling overdone.
• Good color retention after washes : The garment wash process helps maintain vibrancy and prevents quick fading.
• Adjustable snapback for easy sizing : Fits a wide range of head sizes comfortably without digging in.
• Lightweight construction overall : Doesn’t weigh you down, making it ideal for all-day wear in various settings.
• Popular among those seeking a dad-hat vibe : Blends trucker elements with a softer, more approachable aesthetic.

Cons Of Richardson 111

• Less structure means shape can soften over time : Without firm panels, it may lose some crispness after extended wear or improper storage.
• Can wrinkle easily if packed : Folding or stuffing it leads to creases that take time to smooth out.
• Bill curve more pronounced : The traditional curve might not appeal if you prefer a flatter, modern look on truckers.
• Limited structured embroidery hold : Patches or heavy logos can pull on the unstructured front more noticeably.
• Slightly less durable in rough use : The softer materials wear faster under heavy abuse compared to structured options.
• Fit feels looser on some head shapes : May require more snap adjustments for a snug secure feel.
• Fewer size options in some colors : Availability can vary, limiting choices for certain preferences.
• Vintage wash can vary slightly batch to batch : Minor differences in fading or tone between hats.
• Not as versatile for formal casual : The super-relaxed vibe doesn’t transition as seamlessly to semi-dressy outfits.
• Mesh can snag on rough surfaces : The soft back material picks up more lint or small pulls over time.

Maintenance Tips For Richardson 111

• Spot clean stains promptly with mild soap : Dab gently on affected areas to avoid spreading dirt deeper into the fabric.
• Hand wash in cold water when needed : Use a gentle cycle or soak briefly, then air dry to preserve the garment wash effect.
• Avoid machine drying on high heat : Heat can shrink the blend or fade the vintage look faster than expected.
• Store flat or hung to maintain shape : Prevent creases by not folding or crushing it in tight spaces.
• Brush off dust regularly with a soft brush : Keeps the mesh clean and prevents buildup on the front panels.
• Use hat shaper if bill needs reforming : Gently reshape the precurved bill after washing for consistent curve.
• Limit bleach or harsh chemicals : These can damage the dye and mesh integrity over repeated use.
• Air out after sweaty wear : Hang it in a ventilated spot to dry naturally and reduce odor buildup.
• Rotate with other hats : Gives it rest time, extending overall lifespan significantly.
• Check snapback for wear periodically : Tighten or replace if plastic starts to loosen from frequent use.

My Experience With Richardson 112

Switching to the Richardson 112 felt like upgrading to a more dependable daily driver.

I grabbed one in a neutral color for outdoor activities and work errands, and it quickly became my favorite.

The mid-pro profile gives it a balanced, classic baseball-inspired look that sits just right—not too high like some high-crown hats, not too low either.

The structured six-panel front holds its shape impressively, even after being caught in rain or packed for travel.

The cotton-poly twill feels premium and sturdy, while the trucker mesh back ensures it never gets stuffy. I love how the flatter bill gives a modern edge, and the snapback locks in place securely without slipping.

I’ve worn it fishing, to games, and on casual Fridays at the office. It handles embroidery well if customized, and the fit stays consistent wash after wash.

No major sagging or stretching issues here. It’s versatile enough for almost any casual scenario, and the quality shows in the stitching and materials.

Pros Of Richardson 112

• Structured mid-profile for consistent shape : Holds form well, looking sharp even after heavy use.
• Premium feel from cotton-poly twill : Durable front panels resist wear and feel high-quality.
• Excellent ventilation with trucker mesh : Keeps head cool during active or hot days.
• Flatter bill for contemporary style : Modern look that pairs with streetwear or athletic outfits.
• Reliable snapback closure : Adjusts easily and stays secure across various head sizes.
• Versatile for customization : Structured front ideal for clean embroidery, patches, or logos.
• Balanced fit that’s not too tight or loose : Comfortable for extended wear without adjustments.
• Wide color and size variety : More options make finding the perfect match straightforward.
• Strong durability overall : Withstands daily abuse better than softer unstructured hats.
• Timeless classic trucker aesthetic : Appeals to a broad range of users from casual to branded needs.

Cons Of Richardson 112

• Slightly stiffer initially : Needs a short break-in compared to pre-washed options.
• Can feel warmer in extreme heat : Structured front traps a bit more heat than fully relaxed designs.
• Less vintage softness out of box : Doesn’t have that immediate worn-in feel some prefer.
• Bill less curved traditionally : Flatter style might not suit everyone who likes pronounced curves.
• Heavier feel than low-pro hats : Mid-profile adds minor weight noticeable in long sessions.
• Mesh can collect lint faster : Requires occasional brushing to stay pristine.
• Higher price point in some markets : Premium build sometimes costs more than alternatives.
• Snapback plastic can wear : Frequent adjustments may loosen over years.
• Less forgiving on odd head shapes : Structure might not mold as flexibly as unstructured.
• Colors can show sweat stains easier : Lighter shades require more careful maintenance.

Maintenance Tips For Richardson 112

• Spot clean with damp cloth and mild detergent : Targets stains without full immersion.
• Hand wash cold and air dry : Preserves shape and prevents shrinkage in the blend.
• Avoid direct sunlight for long drying : Reduces fading risk on vibrant colors.
• Store on hat rack or form : Maintains crown structure when not in use.
• Gently reshape bill if needed : Use hands or form after washing for crisp curve.
• Brush mesh to remove debris : Keeps airflow optimal and appearance clean.
• Limit harsh scrubbing : Protects stitching and fabric integrity.
• Rotate usage : Prevents overuse wear on favorite colors.
• Check for loose threads early : Trim to avoid unraveling.
• Use hat box for travel : Protects from crushing in luggage.

Comparison With Other Brands

• Decky 6021 offers similar mid-profile trucker at lower cost : Good budget alternative but stitching quality lags behind Richardson.
• Yupoong 6606 provides premium feel with flat bill options : Matches durability closely, often at competitive pricing.
• Outdoor Cap OC771 mimics 112 shape affordably : Slightly rounder crown but comparable materials and comfort.
• Pacific Headwear 104C delivers structured mesh back reliably : Strong contender for custom work with solid build.
• Flexfit styles add stretch but lose snapback adjustability : Better for fitted preference, less versatile than Richardson snap.
• New Era truckers bring brand prestige : Higher cost with similar profiles but sometimes less breathable mesh.
• Otto caps offer variety in profiles : Reliable but front panel rigidity falls short of Richardson’s.
• Richardson alternatives like BK Caps match look factory-direct : Budget-friendly with close aesthetics.
• Richardson edges out most in mesh quality and fit consistency : Stands apart for long-term comfort.
• Other brands catch up in price but not always in premium touch : Richardson maintains edge in craftsmanship.

Read more: Comparison of Osprey Daylite And Daylite Plus

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion: For Richardson 111 And 112

I’ve gone back and forth between these two, and honestly, the Richardson 112 wins for me most days. Its structured design, balanced profile, and reliable shape make it the more versatile pick whether I’m out running errands or styling something casual. That said, if you crave that soft, instant vintage comfort and a lower sit on your head, the Richardson 111 might feel better right away.

You really can’t go wrong with either—they’re both solid truckers from a brand that knows hats inside out. Think about your head shape, preferred fit, and daily use. Grab the one that matches your vibe, and you’ll have a hat that lasts. Which one are you leaning toward now?