My Pet Peed Vs Pooph: A Pet Owner’s Battle Against Odors

As a pet owner, I’ve faced the smelly chaos of pet messes more times than I’d like to admit. When my dog decides the carpet is his personal bathroom, I need a solution that works fast and keeps my home fresh. This article compares two popular pet odor eliminators.

My Pet Peed and Pooph, from my real-world experience. I’ll break down their pros, cons, and performance, offering a detailed look at which product might save your nose (and your sanity). With a comparison table, personal insights, and practical tips, you’ll find the best fit for tackling pet odors.

Comparison Table: My Pet Peed Vs Pooph

My Experience With My Pet Peed

When my golden retriever, Max, left a surprise on my living room carpet, I reached for My Pet Peed, a product I’d heard about through a friend. The spray bottle was easy to handle, and I appreciated the clear instructions: spray generously, let it sit, and blot. The first thing I noticed was the mild scent—slightly chemical but not overwhelming. It didn’t make my eyes water, which is a win compared to some cleaners I’ve tried.

I sprayed the affected area, focusing on a fresh urine stain. After letting it sit for about 15 minutes, I blotted with a clean towel. The stain lifted impressively, leaving only a faint outline that disappeared after a second application. The odor was gone too, which was a relief since Max has a knack for revisiting his “accident spots” if any scent lingers.

I tested it on an older stain on my couch, and while it took some scrubbing with a soft brush, the results were solid. The enzymatic formula seemed to break down the urine effectively, though it struggled a bit with a dried feces mark from an earlier incident.

What stood out was how versatile My Pet Peed is. I used it on hardwood floors and even a pet bed, following the same process. It didn’t damage any surfaces, but I noticed it works best when you act fast. The downside? It’s not as effective on non-urine odors, and the price feels a bit steep for a 32-ounce bottle. Still, it’s become a go-to in my cleaning arsenal, especially for Max’s frequent indoor mishaps.

Read more: My Thoughts on Fiestaware Vs. Corelle

Pros Of My Pet Peed

• Effective on fresh stains: The enzymatic formula tackles urine stains quickly, often removing them in one application if you catch them early.
• Versatile surface use: Works on carpets, upholstery, hardwood, and even pet beds without causing damage.
• Pet-safe after drying: Once the product dries, it’s safe for pets to be around, which is great for households with curious animals.
• Minimal scent: The mild, slightly chemical smell doesn’t linger, making it suitable for sensitive noses.
• Prevents re-marking: By breaking down urine molecules, it reduces the chance of pets returning to the same spot.

My Pet Peed’s strength lies in its enzymatic action, which targets the ammonia crystals in urine. I found it particularly effective on fresh accidents, where a quick spray and blot could make the stain vanish. The fact that it’s safe for multiple surfaces gave me confidence to use it around the house, from my area rug to my hardwood floors. The lack of a strong fragrance was a plus, as I’m not a fan of overpowering cleaners. It’s also reassuring that it discourages Max from re-marking, which has been a persistent issue during his house-training phase.

Cons Of My Pet Peed

• Pricey for the size: At $29.95 for 32 ounces, it’s more expensive than some competitors, which can add up with frequent use.
• Weaker on non-urine odors: It struggles with feces or vomit smells, requiring multiple applications or additional cleaning.
• Requires scrubbing for old stains: Set-in stains need extra elbow grease, which can be a hassle.
• Online-only availability: You can’t grab it at a local store, which is inconvenient for urgent needs.
• Slight chemical scent: While mild, the smell might bother those who prefer completely odorless products.

The cost of My Pet Peed is a sticking point for me. With Max’s occasional accidents, I go through a bottle faster than I’d like, and the price stings compared to other options. Its performance on non-urine messes was underwhelming—feces odors lingered even after two applications. The need to scrub older stains felt like extra work, especially when I just wanted a quick fix. The online-only purchase option also meant I had to plan ahead, which isn’t ideal when Max decides to “redecorate” my carpet at 2 a.m.

Maintenance Tips For My Pet Peed

• Act quickly on stains: Spray immediately after an accident to maximize stain and odor removal.
• Test on delicate surfaces: Always do a spot test on fabrics like silk or leather to avoid damage.
• Use enough product: Don’t skimp—saturate the area to ensure the enzymes reach deep into the fibers.
• Blot, don’t rub: Use a clean towel to blot the area to avoid spreading the stain or damaging the surface.
• Store properly: Keep the bottle in a cool, dry place to maintain the enzymatic formula’s effectiveness.

Using My Pet Peed effectively requires some strategy. I learned the hard way that waiting too long makes stains tougher to remove, so I keep a bottle handy in my cleaning closet. Spot testing saved my favorite throw blanket from potential ruin, as the formula can be strong on delicate materials. Saturating the area is key—half-hearted sprays won’t cut it for deep-set odors. Blotting gently with a towel worked better than rubbing, which sometimes pushed the stain deeper. Storing it away from heat ensures the enzymes stay active, which is critical for its performance.

My Experience With Pooph

When I first heard about Pooph, I was skeptical. A fragrance-free, non-enzymatic spray that claims to “dismantle odors on a molecular level”? It sounded too good to be true. But after Max left a particularly pungent mess on my patio potty pad, I gave it a try. The spray bottle is straightforward, and the lack of scent was immediately noticeable—it’s like spraying water, which I found refreshing compared to chemical-heavy cleaners.

I sprayed Pooph directly on the potty pad and let it dry, as instructed. The odor vanished almost instantly, which was shocking. No lingering dog pee smell, no fake floral cover-up—just clean air. I tested it on an area rug where Max had an accident, and while the odor disappeared, the stain remained faintly visible. Unlike My Pet Peed, Pooph didn’t require scrubbing, which was a time-saver. I also used it on Max’s bed and even his collar, and it worked without leaving residue or irritating his skin.

However, Pooph isn’t perfect. It’s less effective on older stains, and I noticed it doesn’t tackle non-pet odors as well (like a spilled milk incident). Still, its ease of use and instant odor elimination made it a game-changer for quick cleanups, especially in high-traffic pet areas.

Pros Of Pooph

• Instant odor elimination: Neutralizes pet odors on contact, leaving no trace of smell.
• Fragrance-free formula: Ideal for sensitive noses or households that dislike scented cleaners.
• Safe for pets and surfaces: Can be used on pet toys, beds, and even near food prep areas.
• No scrubbing required: Simply spray and let dry, making it incredibly user-friendly.
• Affordable price: At $24.99 for 32 ounces, it’s a budget-friendly option for frequent use.

Pooph’s standout feature is its speed. The moment I sprayed it on Max’s potty pad, the smell was gone—no waiting, no lingering odor. The fragrance-free aspect is a huge plus for me, as I can’t stand cleaners that leave my house smelling like a perfume factory. Its safety profile impressed me; I felt comfortable using it on Max’s bed without worrying about residue. The no-scrub application was a lifesaver on busy days, and the price makes it easier to stock up for Max’s inevitable accidents.

Cons Of Pooph

• Limited stain removal: While great for odors, it’s less effective at lifting visible stains.
• Not for non-pet odors: Struggles with food or other household smells, limiting its versatility.
• May need reapplication: Tough odors might require multiple sprays for complete elimination.
• Mixed reviews on old stains: Some users report it doesn’t work well on set-in messes.
• Availability issues: Not as widely available as other brands, though easier to find than My Pet Peed.

Pooph’s biggest drawback is its stain removal. It left a faint urine mark on my rug, which was disappointing when I wanted a one-and-done solution.

It also flopped on a milk spill, making it less versatile than I’d hoped.

I occasionally needed a second spray for stubborn odors, which wasn’t a dealbreaker but felt less efficient. Some online reviews echoed my experience with old stains, suggesting it’s not the best for long-neglected messes. Finding Pooph in stores can be hit-or-miss, though online ordering is reliable.

Maintenance Tips For Pooph

• Spray generously: Apply enough to fully cover the odor source for best results.
• Let it dry naturally: Don’t wipe or blot; allow the formula to work as it dries.
• Use on fresh messes: Apply as soon as possible to prevent odors from setting in.
• Store in a cool place: Keep the bottle away from heat to preserve its effectiveness.
• Check surface compatibility: Test on a small area to ensure it doesn’t affect delicate fabrics.

Pooph’s simplicity makes maintenance straightforward. I found that spraying generously worked better than light spritzes, especially on potent odors. Letting it dry without interference was key—wiping too soon disrupted its magic. Using it right after Max’s accidents yielded the best results, as older odors sometimes needed extra sprays. Storing it in my pantry kept it effective, and I always tested it on new surfaces like curtains to avoid surprises. These steps ensured Pooph performed consistently across my home.

Comparison With Other Brands

• Rocco & Roxie Stain and Odor Eliminator: Enzymatic, like My Pet Peed, but slightly cheaper and stronger on feces odors. However, it has a stronger scent that lingers.
• Angry Orange Pet Odor Eliminator: Citrus-based and effective on multiple surfaces, but the strong orange smell can be overpowering for some.
• Nature’s Miracle Stain and Odor Remover: Comparable to My Pet Peed in enzymatic action but more widely available and slightly less effective on old stains.
• Simple Green Pet Stain and Odor Remover: Mild scent and good for set-in stains, but not as fast-acting as Pooph for odors.
• Bubba’s Rowdy Friends Pet Stain Terminator: Strong enzymatic cleaner with a pleasant eucalyptus scent, but pricier than both My Pet Peed and Pooph.

Rocco & Roxie is a close competitor to My Pet Peed, especially for tough stains, but its scent can linger longer than I’d like. Angry Orange’s citrus punch is effective but too intense for my taste, especially in small spaces. Nature’s Miracle is a solid alternative, though it didn’t outperform My Pet Peed on old stains in my tests. Simple Green’s mild formula is great for versatility but lacks Pooph’s instant odor-zapping power. Bubba’s Rowdy Friends impressed with its scent but felt overpriced compared to Pooph’s affordability and simplicity.

Also read: My Thoughts on Rachio 3 Vs Orbit B-Hyve

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion: For My Pet Peed And Pooph

You’re probably wondering which product I’d crown the winner in this pet odor showdown. Honestly, it depends on your needs. If stains are your main issue, My Pet Peed’s enzymatic power is your best bet—it tackles fresh messes like a champ. If odors are driving you up the wall, Pooph’s instant, fragrance-free elimination is hard to beat. Both have their place in my home, and I’d recommend keeping them both on hand for different situations. Max’s accidents don’t stand a chance with these two in my cleaning lineup.