My Patriot Supply Vs. 4Patriots: Which One Is Better?

I’ve spent the last few years testing and stocking emergency food kits from both My Patriot Supply and 4Patriots. In this article I share my honest, hands-on experience so you can decide which one truly deserves space in your pantry. I’ll cover everything from taste and variety to price and customer support, then give you a clear recommendation based on what actually matters when the power’s out.

A Brief Comparison Table

My Experience With My Patriot Supply

When I first opened my first My Patriot Supply box, I was honestly impressed by how organized everything was.

The packaging felt sturdy and professional, with clear labels on every pouch.

I started with their 4-Week Emergency Food Supply kit and later added the Survival Seed Vault and Water Filtration items.

The meals themselves surprised me in a good way. I’ve eaten their Granny’s Homemade Potato Soup on a cold night when I didn’t feel like cooking, and it actually tasted like real potato soup with bits of veggies and a creamy texture.

The Creamy Stroganoff is another favorite; the noodles hold up well and the sauce isn’t too salty.

One thing I really appreciate is the variety. They offer breakfast options like Maple Grove Oatmeal and Chocolate Peanut Butter Pancake Mix that make mornings feel normal even during an outage.

I also like that many of their kits include drinks—apple cinnamon electrolyte powder and creamy hot cocoa are small touches that matter when you’re stuck indoors for days.

I’ve had their food in rotation for over two years now, and nothing has gone bad or tasted rancid. The pouches seal tightly and the oxygen absorbers do their job.

When I had a family member with gluten sensitivity, I was relieved to see how many gluten-free options they offer.

Customer service has been a highlight. I once called with a shipping question on a Saturday and got a live person within five minutes. They even upgraded my shipping for free when I explained I needed the order before a planned trip.

The only minor downside I’ve noticed is that some of the dessert pouches (like the brownie bites) can feel a bit dry if you don’t add enough water. But overall, My Patriot Supply has become the brand I recommend to friends who are just starting their preparedness journey.

Also read: Comparison of LiftMaster 98022 And 8500W A Day

Pros Of My Patriot Supply

• Long shelf life you can actually trust : Every pouch is stamped with a clear 25-year guarantee, and I’ve eaten food from kits that were already 4–5 years old with no quality drop.
• Huge variety keeps meals interesting : Over 50 different meal options across kits, including breakfasts, entrees, snacks, drinks, and even gluten-free and low-sodium choices.
• Generous calorie counts : Most kits provide 2,000+ calories per person per day, which is more than enough for active adults during stressful situations.
• Excellent taste for emergency food : Real ingredients like actual chicken, beef, and vegetables instead of just textured soy protein.
• Very strong customer support : U.S.-based team that answers calls quickly and resolves issues without hassle.
• Generous return policy : Full 365-day money-back guarantee, even if you’ve opened the buckets.
• Frequent discounts and free shipping : Almost every order I’ve placed qualified for free shipping, and promo codes are common.
• Eco-friendly packaging : Lightweight mylar pouches inside heavy-duty buckets that are easy to stack and store.
• Wide range of kit sizes : From 72-hour kits all the way to 1-year supplies, so you can scale up gradually.

Cons Of My Patriot Supply

• Higher initial cost for smaller kits : The 72-hour kit feels expensive compared to buying individual pouches from other brands.
• Some meals require cooking : A few items (like pancake mix) need boiling water and a stove, which isn’t ideal if you’re in a true no-cook scenario.
• Desserts can be hit-or-miss : The brownies and cookies sometimes come out a bit dry unless you add extra water.
• Limited spicy options : If you love hot food, the selection is fairly mild overall.
• Bucket handles can feel flimsy : On the larger buckets, the plastic handles sometimes flex too much when fully loaded.
• Not all meals are low-sodium : Some entrees are saltier than I prefer, though they do offer a low-sodium line.

Maintenance Tips For My Patriot Supply

• Store buckets in a cool, dry place : Ideal temperature is 55–70°F; avoid garages or attics where temperatures swing wildly.
• Keep buckets off the floor : Use wooden pallets or shelving to prevent moisture wicking up from concrete.
• Rotate stock every 2–3 years : Even though the label says 25 years, I taste-test and rotate older kits to keep everything fresh.
• Check seals periodically : Look for any bulging pouches or loose lids; if you see damage, use that kit first.
• Label your buckets clearly : Mark the purchase date and contents so you know exactly what’s inside without opening them.
• Avoid direct sunlight : UV light can degrade the mylar pouches over time.
• Use silica gel packs for extra protection : If you live in a humid area, adding food-grade silica gel inside the bucket adds another layer of moisture control.
• Keep an inventory list : I maintain a simple spreadsheet so I know exactly what I have and when it’s time to reorder.
• Inspect after any major move : Buckets can get jostled during transport; check for dents or punctures.

My Experience With 4Patriots

I bought my first 4Patriots kit about three years ago because of their heavy advertising on podcasts and YouTube.

The packaging looked patriotic and professional, and I liked that they offered free bonuses like water filters and seed vaults with larger orders.

The food itself is decent but noticeably different from My Patriot Supply.

The Grilled Chicken and Rice is one of the better entrees, but many meals lean heavily on pasta and rice, which can feel repetitive after a few days.

I found the Cheesy Chicken and Rice a bit bland compared to similar dishes from My Patriot Supply.

One thing I did appreciate was the portion size. Meals are filling and most kits hit around 1,800–2,000 calories per day. The Pancake Mix and Apple Cinnamon Granola Crunch are solid breakfast choices, but there are fewer drink options than I’d like.

Customer service was okay, but not as fast as My Patriot Supply. I once waited two days for an email response about a missing bonus item. The return policy is only 30 days, which feels short when you’re buying emergency food that you hope you never have to use.

Overall, 4Patriots is a solid brand and I’ve kept their kits in my basement as backup. But after trying both, I tend to reach for My Patriot Supply first when I want something that feels more like a real meal.

Pros Of 4Patriots

• Strong marketing and bonuses : Many kits come with extras like water filters, seed vaults, and power generators.
• Decent portion sizes : Meals are filling and provide 1,800–2,000 calories per day.
• Attractive packaging : Buckets and pouches look sharp and patriotic.
• Free shipping on most orders : Similar to My Patriot Supply.
• Some unique items : They offer things like freeze-dried fruit and occasional limited-edition flavors.
• Good for beginners : Easy-to-understand website and clear kit descriptions.
• Reasonable shelf life : 25-year guarantee matches industry standards.
• Frequent bundle deals : You can often get multiple kits at a slight discount.

Cons Of 4Patriots

• Higher price point : Most kits cost more than comparable My Patriot Supply options.
• Less variety : Fewer meal types and fewer breakfast/drink options.
• Taste is average : Many meals feel bland or overly salty.
• Shorter return window : Only 30 days, which is tight for emergency food.
• Slower customer service : Response times can lag compared to competitors.
• Limited gluten-free selection : Not as accommodating for dietary restrictions.
• Heavy reliance on pasta and rice : Meals can feel repetitive after a few days.
• Fewer low-sodium choices : Salt content is noticeably higher in many entrees.

Read more: Comparison of Cyberpower And Skytech

Maintenance Tips For 4Patriots

• Store in a stable, cool environment : Keep buckets between 55–70°F to maximize shelf life.
• Elevate off concrete floors : Use shelves or pallets to avoid moisture issues.
• Rotate every 2–3 years : Taste-test older kits to ensure quality.
• Check pouches for damage : Look for punctures or loose seals after moving.
• Label contents and dates : Mark each bucket so you know what you have.
• Avoid extreme temperature swings : Garages and attics are risky.
• Add extra oxygen absorbers if needed : If you’re storing long-term in humid areas.
• Inspect after shipping : Check for dents or broken handles.
• Keep an inventory : Track what you own to avoid overbuying.

Comparison With Other Brands

• Compared to ReadyWise : My Patriot Supply beats ReadyWise on taste and variety, while 4Patriots is closer in price but lower in flavor quality.
• Compared to Augason Farms : Augason is cheaper but the taste and texture are noticeably inferior; My Patriot Supply feels more premium.
• Compared to Mountain House : Mountain House wins on taste, but costs significantly more per serving and has a shorter shelf life (30 years vs 25).
• Compared to Legacy Food Storage : Legacy offers excellent gluten-free options, but My Patriot Supply has more overall variety and better pricing.
• Compared to Nutrient Survival : Nutrient Survival focuses on nutrition over taste; My Patriot Supply strikes a better balance for daily use.
• Compared to Wise Company : Wise is budget-friendly but has more complaints about taste and quality control.
• Compared to Thrive Life : Thrive is great for freeze-dried ingredients you cook yourself, but My Patriot Supply is more ready-to-eat.
• Compared to Valley Food Storage : Valley offers clean ingredients and good taste, but their kits are usually more expensive than My Patriot Supply.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion: For Both Products

After using both brands for years, I personally keep My Patriot Supply as my primary emergency food source. It offers better taste, more variety, stronger customer service, and a longer return policy at a lower price point. That said, 4Patriots is still a reliable option if you like their bonuses or find a good deal.

If you’re just starting out, I recommend beginning with My Patriot Supply’s 4-Week Emergency Food Supply kit. It gives you a solid foundation without breaking the bank, and you can always add more later. Whatever you choose, the most important thing is taking that first step toward being prepared. You’ve got this.