When it’s time for an oil change, most drivers have two options – head to a quick oil change shop like Jiffy Lube or go to an automotive service chain like Midas. Both promise fast, convenient oil changes, but there are some key differences between the two.
This guide examines the pros and cons of Midas and Jiffy Lube to help you decide which is the better option for your next oil change.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Midas | Jiffy Lube | |
| Pricing | Slightly lower for synthetic blends | Slightly higher for synthetics |
| Services | Full auto repair & maintenance | Specialize in oil changes |
| Technicians | ASE-certified mechanics | Oil change specialists |
| Inspections | Free with all oil changes | Only with higher tiers |
| Oil Brands | National brands like Valvoline, Pennzoil | National brands like Valvoline, Quaker State |
| Convenience | 2,000+ locations but not as widespread as Jiffy Lube | 2,000+ locations, focus on convenience |
| Speed | 15-20 minutes average | 15 minute oil changes advertised |
| Reputation | Known for expertise and thorough service | Known for fast, reliable service |
| Best For | Those wanting repairs beyond oil change | Quick, periodic oil change convenience |
Overview Of Midas And Jiffy Lube
Midas is an automotive service chain with over 2,000 locations across North America. In addition to oil changes, they also provide brake repairs, muffler replacement, tire services and more. Midas technicians are ASE-certified mechanics who can perform basic to complex auto repairs.
Jiffy Lube is one of the largest quick oil change chains with over 2,000 locations in North America. As the name implies, Jiffy Lube specializes in fast oil changes, with most visits taking about 15 minutes. They also provide other routine maintenance like air conditioning service, windshield wiper replacement and fluid top-offs. Jiffy Lube technicians focus specifically on oil changes, not full-scale auto repair.
Midas Oil Change Overview
Midas offers conventional, high-mileage and synthetic blend oil changes. Most locations also carry full synthetic oil options. Here’s an overview of Midas’ oil change services:
- Conventional oil change – Starts at $39.99 for up to 5 quarts of standard motor oil and a new oil filter. Does not include full inspection.
- High-mileage oil change – Starts at $59.99 for up to 5 quarts of high-mileage motor oil, new filter and full inspection. Recommended for vehicles over 75,000 miles.
- Synthetic blend oil change – Starts at $69.99 for up to 5 quarts of synthetic blend oil and includes full inspection.
- Full synthetic oil change – Starts at $89.99 for up to 5 quarts of full synthetic motor oil, new filter and full inspection.
Midas oil change prices vary by location. Bundled coupon promotions are common, reducing the total cost by $10-20.
Jiffy Lube Oil Change Overview
Jiffy Lube also provides standard, high-mileage and synthetic oil options. Their basic oil change services include:
- Conventional oil change – Starts at $39.99 for up to 5 quarts of regular oil and new filter. Does not include vehicle inspection.
- Signature oil change – Starts at $69.99 for up to 5 quarts of synthetic blend oil, new filter and top-off of vital fluids. Also includes basic inspection.
- Full synthetic oil change – Starts at $109.99 for up to 5 quarts of full synthetic oil, filter and complete inspection.
Similar to Midas, Jiffy Lube runs regular coupon specials taking $10-30 off oil changes. Club members can also save $5-10 per visit.
Also Read: Comparison Between Valvoline and Instant Oil Change
Comparing Midas And Jiffy Lube Oil Change Prices
Midas and Jiffy Lube have similar base pricing on conventional and synthetic oil changes. Both offer coupons to help lower your total bill. Here’s a pricing comparison:
| Service | Midas | Jiffy Lube |
| Conventional Oil Change | $39.99+ | $39.99+ |
| High-Mileage/Signature Blend | $59.99+ | $69.99+ |
| Full Synthetic Oil Change | $89.99+ | $109.99+ |
Jiffy Lube has slightly higher regular pricing for synthetic blend and full synthetic oil options. With coupons at either business, you’ll end up paying around the same price.
One cost advantage at Midas is that basic conventional changes include a 19-point inspection, a $20+ value. At Jiffy Lube, you have to upgrade to the Signature or full synthetic service to get a basic inspection.
Oil Change Experience And Convenience
Both Midas and Jiffy Lube aim to provide fast, convenient oil changes. Speed of service is very similar at around 15-20 minutes for a basic change. You’ll experience nearly identical oil change processes:
- Drive up, no appointment needed
- Service technician takes your information and vehicle details
- Vehicle is driven into the service bay
- Oil is drained and replaced with new filter
- Fluids are topped off and lights/tire pressure checked
- Vehicle is returned and payment is taken
Jiffy Lube has made convenience part of their brand identity. But Midas locations also offer quick drive-thru oil change service. Wait times are comparable between the two.
Jiffy Lube does have more locations, giving them a convenience advantage in some areas. Their focus on fast oil changes also helps speed up the process. Midas provides more complete maintenance, which can extend service times.
Oil Change Quality And Reliability
When it comes to oil change quality, Midas holds a slight edge over quick oil change chains. As a full-service garage, their technicians have deeper training in car maintenance. They are more likely to spot issues during inspection and make you aware of problems.
However, Jiffy Lube technicians perform 10-15 oil changes per day on average. This repetitive experience leads to proficiency in the oil change process. And chances are low of major issues arising from a basic oil/filter change.
Both businesses source national brand name oils like Valvoline, Pennzoil and Quaker State. The oil itself will be similar quality. It comes down to technician diligence in changing it thoroughly and checking for problems.
Overall, Midas offers added peace of mind thanks to their comprehensive maintenance expertise. But a quick oil change at Jiffy Lube will sufficiently top up your oil and get you back on the road.
Also Read: Comparison Between Oil Can Henry’s And Jiffy Lube
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Full synthetic oil changes are typically recommended, especially for newer engines. Full synthetic lasts longer, protects better and improves fuel economy compared to conventional or synthetic blend oils. The higher initial cost saves money over time with fewer changes needed. Both Midas and Jiffy Lube offer full synthetic oil options.
A basic oil change using regular oil costs $40-50 at most national chains. Synthetic blend changes around $60-70. Full synthetic changes go up to $90-120. Shop around for coupons and specials to save $10-30 per oil change. Also search for new customer offers.
Full synthetic oil provides maximum engine protection and can last up to 10,000 miles between changes. It’s worth the extra cost for newer cars, performance vehicles and engines with over 75,000 miles that require extra protection. Using full synthetic also allows you to go longer between oil changes.
Conventional oil is the most affordable option. However, it may not offer the best engine protection compared to synthetic oils. Quality conventional oils like Valvoline, Quaker State and Pennzoil cost as little as $20-25 per 5-quart jug at auto parts stores. Avoid no-name brands selling oil for under $20 that may be diluted or unreliable.
Also Read: Differences Between Dextero And Cooper Tires.
The Verdict
Midas and Jiffy Lube both offer quick, convenient oil change options. Which you choose often comes down to what else you need beyond a basic oil change.
People who get regular maintenance at Midas will benefit from their expert technicians and thorough inspections. If you just need a quick oil refresh between full-service visits, Jiffy Lube is a reliable choice.
Drivers seeking the best protection may want to get synthetic or high-mileage changes at Midas. Those looking for the fastest, most affordable oil change can’t go wrong with Jiffy Lube.
No matter which you choose, performing regular oil changes is vital to engine health. Both Midas and Jiffy Lube offer hassle-free oil change experiences to help you maintain your vehicle. Proactively changing your oil on schedule lets you avoid major repairs down the road.