Lumabone Vs. Benebone: Which Dog Chew Is Better?

Dog chews are a popular toy for keeping your pup busy and entertained. Two of the most well-known brands of durable chews are Lumabone and Benebone. But which one should you choose for your pet?

Here’s an in-depth look at the pros, cons, features, and differences between Lumabone and Benebone to help you decide.

A Brief Comparison Table

Feature	Lumabone	Benebone
Main Materials	Food-grade nylon, chicken flavor	Nylon, real bacon
Made in	USA and China	China from USA-sourced materials
Flavors	Chicken, Peanut Butter	Bacon, Peanut Butter, Chicken, Quack & Milk
Safety	Non-toxic if ingested	Non-toxic if ingested
Claim of Veterinary Approval	No	Yes
Prices	$$	$$$
Shape Options	Sticks, rings, bones	Wishbone, dental, bacon, peanut
Sizes Available	XS – XL	XS – XL

Overview Of Lumabone And Benebone

Lumabone and Benebone are both companies that manufacture tough, long-lasting chew toys made specifically for dogs.

Lumabone chews are made from food-grade materials like nylon and real chicken. They contain no rawhide, are highly durable, and come in a variety of flavors.

Benebone chews are made from nylon and real bacon. They are designed with deep grooves to provide dental stimulation and satisfy dogs’ urge to chew. Benebone chews have an irregular shape that makes them easy to grip.

While both brands aim to provide dogs with enrichment through chewing, there are some key differences between Lumabone and Benebone that may make one better suited for your pup.

Lumabone Dog Chew Pros

Here are some of the advantages of choosing Lumabone dog chews:

• Made from food-grade nylon: Lumabone chews are constructed from food-grade nylon that is non-toxic and safe if ingested.
• Real chicken flavor: Lumabones are infused with real chicken for a tasty flavor dogs love.
• Durable and long-lasting: Lumabones are extremely tough and built to withstand aggressive chewers.
• Variety of shapes and sizes: From sticks to rings, Lumabone offers different shapes and sizes to appeal to any dog.
• Specialized formulas: Lumabone has formulas tailored for puppies and senior dogs.
• Cleans teeth: The nubs and ridges help clean tartar and plaque as dogs chew.
• Made in the USA: Lumabone chews are manufactured in the USA with globally-sourced materials.

Benebone Dog Chew Pros

Here are some of the advantages of opting for Benebone dog chews:

• Real bacon flavor: Benebones contain real bacon for a mouthwatering flavor dogs can’t resist.
• Grooves and nubs: The textured surface helps clean teeth and gums while chewing.
• Irregular shape: The ergonomic shape makes them easy for dogs to grip and bite.
• Durable nylon construction: Benebones are made to be extremely tough and long-lasting.
• Vet recommended: Many veterinarians recommend Benebone chews for dental health.
• USA-sourced materials: While manufactured in China, Benebones use USA-sourced nylon.
• Range of sizes: Benebones come in different sizes optimal for any dog breed.
• No splintering: The durable nylon is designed not to break off into shards if destroyed.

Also Read: Comparison Between Lumabone And Nylabone.

Lumabone Dog Chew Cons

While Lumabones have many benefits, there are a few potential drawbacks to consider:

• Not actually edible: While Lumabones are technically food-grade, they aren’t truly intended to be eaten.
• May get slimy: After a lot of chewing, some users note Lumabones get slimy from dog saliva.
• No approved dental claim: Lumabone does not have veterinary oral health claims like some other chews.
• Single-flavor options: Each Lumabone chew only comes in one flavor, limiting variety.
• Made in China: While designed in the USA, Lumabones are manufactured in China.
• Questionable quality control: Some owners complain Lumabone quality is inconsistent between purchases.

Benebone Dog Chew Cons

There are also a few drawbacks associated with Benebone dog chews:

• Not truly edible: Benebone chews are meant for chewing, not eating, and pass through the digestive system.
• May develop odor: Some pet parents find that Benebones emit a rancid smell after heavy use.
• No actual bones: Despite the name, Benebones contain no real bone material.
• Made in China: Benebones are produced in China which may be a concern for some consumers.
• Higher calorie: The real bacon flavor adds more calories than some other low-calorie chews.
• Cost: Benebone chews generally have a higher price point than many competing products.
• Can fracture into pieces: While rare, Benebones may break into chunks if aggressively chewed.
• Limited formulations: Benebone only uses nylon and bacon flavors, lacking diversity.

Which Is Better For Your Dog?

So when it comes down to Lumabone VS. Benebone, which dog chew comes out on top? Here are some factors to consider when deciding:

Chewing Intensity: For mild chewers, both will work well. But for aggressive heavy-duty chewing, Benebone may be the better choice.

Dental Care: The grooves and nubs of Benebone provide superior teeth cleaning compared to Lumabone’s relatively smooth surface.

Safety: Both brands are non-toxic and safe if swallowed, with Benebone less likely to fracture into pieces.

Price: Lumabones are generally more affordable than the higher-end Benebone chews.

Ingredients: Lumabone uses food-grade nylon while Benebone contains real bacon flavor.

Odor: Benebone tends to develop a smell with extended use unlike the relatively odorless Lumabone.

Country of Origin: Those concerned about China-made products may prefer the USA-sourced Lumabone chews.

Ultimately, it depends on your priorities and your individual dog. Try out different styles from both brands to see which your pup responds to best. Lumabone and Benebone both make high-quality chews, so you can’t go wrong with either option.

Also Read: Differences Between Barkbone And Nylabone.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Also watch the review video!

The Bottom Line

When comparing Lumabone versus Benebone dog chews, both offer distinct advantages. Lumabone tends to be more affordable, made in the USA, odor-free, and with food-grade ingredients. Benebone has grooves for dental health, real bacon flavor, and durable construction, but is pricier.

Try out different chews to see which brand and specific shape keeps your dog happily occupied. Consider chewing habits, dental needs, safety, smell, and your budget. With regular use, whichever durable chew you choose, your pup is sure to enjoy the chewing and bonding experience.

Provide supervision, rotate with other toys, and replace when worn for the safest, longest-lasting results.