If you’re in the market for a monitor arm, you’ve likely come across two major players: Humanscale and Ergotron. Both companies make high-quality, adjustable monitor arms to improve ergonomics and free up desk space. But which one is right for your needs?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Humanscale and Ergotron on key factors like price, quality, range of motion, ease of use, and more. By the end, you’ll have a clear sense of the pros and cons of each brand and which is the best fit for your workspace.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Humanscale | Ergotron |
| Price Range | $250 – $600+ | $100 – $400 |
| Quality | Consistently high-end | Varies widely by price |
| Adjustability | Very fluid and smooth | Wider range of motion |
| Extension | Up to 25″ | Up to 34″ |
| Rotation | ~180° swivel | Full 360° swivel |
| Tilt | Up to 40° tilt | Up to 30° tilt |
| Weight Capacity | Up to 35 lbs | Up to 40 lbs |
| Cable Management | Internal routing | External routing |
| Aesthetics | Sleek, refined | Industrial, utilitarian |
| Best For | Premium quality and looks | Affordability and customization |
Overview Of Humanscale And Ergotron
Humanscale and Ergotron dominate the monitor arm market, and for good reason. Both companies have been around for decades (Humanscale since 1983 and Ergotron since 1982) and have built reputations for durable, functional products.
Humanscale is known for sleek, aesthetic designs using high-end materials like aluminum and carbon fiber. They promote effortless functionality and longevity. Humanscale arms offer extensive customization and sit at the higher end of the price spectrum.
Ergotron focuses more on ergonomics and smooth adjustability. They use high-grade steel and hard plastic construction to enable a broad range of motion. Ergotron covers the spectrum from value arms to premium professional models. Their products also integrate well into complete ergonomic workstation systems.
Now let’s get into the details comparing these two industry leaders.
Price And Budget
When it comes to price, Ergotron generally wins out over Humanscale.
Humanscale arms range from $250 on the low end up to $600 or more. The materials and manufacturing processes justify the price; the arms feel sturdy and built to last. But it’s a significant investment, especially for a home office setup.
Ergotron arms cover a wider spectrum, from around $100 to $400 in most cases. You can find basic Ergotron arms for under $100, though the quality suffers at the lowest price points. Ergotron uses less expensive materials like plastic and steel to produce more affordable arms without sacrificing adjustability.
If budget is a primary concern, Ergotron beats Humanscale hands down. You can get a high-functioning Ergotron arm for the same price or less than a basic Humanscale model.
That said, Humanscale’s elite craftsmanship shows in the buttery smoothness and effortless function of their arms. If money is no object, many professionals and design enthusiasts prefer the sleek aesthetics and precision engineering of Humanscale.
Range Of Motion And Adjustability
A monitor arm loses its value if it doesn’t provide you with ample adjustment capabilities. You want an arm that makes it easy to raise, lower, tilt, swivel, and position your monitor exactly as needed.
Both Humanscale and Ergotron enable an excellent range of motion, with a few differences:
- Ergotron offers greater extension – Their arms extend further, especially the high-end LX models. You can position the monitor up to 34″ away from the base.
- Humanscale has more fluid adjustability – The arms glide smoothly into any position with minimal effort. The internal springs and gas lifts make adjustments feel almost weightless.
- Ergotron gives you greater display rotation – Most Ergotron arms allow a full 360° swivel rotation for portrait or landscape positioning. Humanscale is limited to around 180° swivel motion.
- Humanscale offers more tilt – With up to 40° tilt motion, Humanscale edges out most Ergotron models for tilting a monitor up or down. This helps customize angle for reduced glare and neck strain.
For most users, either brand provides exceptional maneuverability to customize your setup. Ergotron wins out if you want to extend your display further away from the desk or swivel to portrait orientation.
Quality And Durability
At the premium end of the market, Humanscale and Ergotron are closely matched for quality construction and longevity. But differences emerge at lower price points.
Humanscale uses high-end materials like carbon fiber and aluminum across all their monitor arms. This consistently results in sturdy, stable performance and sleek aesthetics. However, you pay a premium for this quality craftsmanship.
With Ergotron, build quality varies more widely by price. Lower-end Ergotron arms utilize plastic housings and hollow metal arms susceptible to drooping over time. But their high-end professional models compete directly with Humanscale for quality. The Ergotron LX Desk Monitor Arm offers phenomenal stability and precision but costs significantly less than a comparable Humanscale.
For home office or light duty use, Ergotron arms offer decent durability at an affordable price. But for demanding office environments and long-term performance, Humanscale wins out. Their arms simply feel stouter with the ability to uphold heavier computer monitors.
Weight Capacity
How much weight do these arms hold?
The maximum weight capacity gives a sense for which brand handles heavier dispalys. However, keep in mind that the arms often become unwieldy at their upper capacity limits.
- Humanscale supports up to 35 lbs – Enough for most large monitors and small TVs. But you’ll want to stay under 30 lbs for best performance.
- Ergotron supports up to 40 lbs – A slightly higher weight capacity, with several heavy-duty models supporting even greater loads up to 52 lbs. These can easily handle larger widescreen monitors.
Both companies provide arms suitable for the vast majority of computer monitors, even big screens up to 40″ ultra-wides. But Ergotron pulls ahead for giant monitors and TVs. above 40 lbs where their high capacity products excel.
Ease Of Installation
Installing a monitor arm can be frustrating. But both Humanscale and Ergotron aim to make assembly quick and simple.
- Humanscale uses a tool-free snap system – The segments snap together and lock in place without needing tools. This enables fast assembly while maintaining strength.
- Ergotron provides external screws – The arms utilize exposed bolts and screws tightened by hand or Allen wrench. Some complain about the utilitarian look, but installation proves fast and simple.
For home use, Ergotron likely has an edge with instructions easy to follow. But Humanscale’s snap system feels more stable and integrated once assembled. The exposed bolts on Ergotron arms allow for tool-free adjustments down the road.
Both companies include the necessary hardware and components in the box for attaching to your desk. On the whole, ease of setup is comparable between the brands.
Aesthetics
While aesthetic appeal is subjective, Humanscale arms win points for sleek, minimalist designs using premium materials like aluminum. They come in matte silver, black, and white color options to blend seamlessly into professional environments.
Ergotron arms have a more industrial, utilitarian look. The mix of metal and plastic comes across as budget-friendly but not as refined as Humanscale. Of course, you can find high-end polished Ergotron arms, but most have visible screws, joints, and brackets.
This aesthetic debate comes down to personal preference. For a seamless, sophisticated look, Humanscale excels. But Ergotron offers wider customization of colors and finishes if you value expressiveness. Both enable you to declutter your desk and spotlight the tech tools that matter, regardless of styling preferences.
Monitor Compatibility
With VESA mount compatibility, you won’t have issues attaching most any monitor or TV to these arms – from 20” screens to 50” ultra-wides.
Humanscale and Ergotron use the 75mm x 75mm or 100mm x 100mm VESA standards. Just confirm your display adheres to the same mounting measurements.
In some cases, you may need an adapter plate. This allows non-VESA monitors or odd VESA patterns to interface properly with the arm. But compatibility poses few limitations with either brand.
Also Read: Comparison Between Lenovo M15 And L15 Monitors
Desk Attachment Method
Proper mounting is essential for stability. Humanscale and Ergotron provide various options:
Clamp attachment – A clamp secures the base to the back or side of your desk up to 3.5″ thick. Quick to install but limited placement.
Grommet mount – The arm threads through an existing grommet hole in your desk. Requires a compatible grommet hole.
Base stand – For sit/stand desks, a weighted stand preserves stability when raising or lowering the desk.
Wall mounting – Good for limited desk space. Attaches directly to a sturdy wall.
Free-standing – For use without a desk. A floor placement stand provides stability.
Ergotron offers the greatest diversity of mounting options. Models like the LX Desk Arm provide desk clamp, grommet, and base mounting in one box. But you’ll generally find a suitable option with either brand for your workspace.
Integrated Cable Management
Nothing deteriorates the look of a sleek monitor arm faster than cables dangling loosely. Fortunately, both companies integrate cable management into their arms:
- Humanscale runs cables inside the arm – Cables disappear within channels for a seamless look. The elbow joint enables smooth cable routing.
- Ergotron routes cables externally – Zip ties and clips attach cables along the exterior of arms. More visible but still neat.
Internal routing has aesthetic advantages if you want cables to vanish. Externally run cables prove easier to access when swapping monitors or cords. Regardless of approach, cables remain organized and out of the way.
Pros And Cons Compared
Let’s summarize the key pros and cons for Humanscale and Ergotron based on the factors above:
Humanscale Pros
- Premium build quality and materials
- Fluid, smooth adjustability
- Sleek, minimalist aesthetic
- Internal cable routing
Humanscale Cons
- Expensive, especially for home use
- Limited swivel rotation
- Hardware can loosen over time
Ergotron Pros
- Affordable, wide price range
- Greater extension and rotation
- High weight capacities
- External cables stay accessible
Ergotron Cons
- Cheaper models are less durable
- Utilitarian, industrial look
- Stand feels lightweight at upper capacities
Best Uses For Each Brand
Based on the comparing factors, here are the ideal use cases for each brand:
Ergotron works best when you want:
- An affordable monitor arm under $200
- To maximize extension and swivel capabilities
- To mount large 40″+ monitors or small TVs.
- A complete ergonomic workspace system
Humanscale excels when you want:
- Top-tier quality and performance
- The look and feel of a premium product
- Smooth adjustability and solid stability
- To make a design statement with your arm
Both companies make excellent products. Your needs and budget will determine if Ergotron’s customization and value or Humanscale’s refined quality suit you better.
Also watch the video!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Ergotron makes excellent monitor arms, especially in the mid to high price ranges. Models like the LX Desk Arm offer unparalleled adjustability. However, “best” depends on your needs and budget. For quality and performance, Ergotron competes directly with premium brands like Humanscale.
Yes, Ergotron is a leading brand in monitor arms. Their products enable ergonomic positioning of monitors to reduce neck, back, and eye strain. Even budget Ergotron arms provide excellent maneuverability. Their high-end arms match premium brands for build quality and smooth function.
The Ergotron HX Desk Monitor Arm is one of their premium offerings with a higher price tag. The heavy-duty aluminum construction provides phenomenal stability and adjustment capabilities.
While expensive, it justifies the cost for demanding office use with heavy monitors. The HX arm is unmatched for those needing maximum extension and weight capacity.
Many Amazon Basics monitor arms utilize parts and designs produced by Ergotron, then retailed under the Amazon Basics brand. This allows Amazon to sell affordable models with Ergotron’s signature adjustability. However, build quality varies widely on Amazon Basics arms, so purchase with caution.
The Bottom Line
When comparing Humanscale and Ergotron monitor arms, both deliver excellent performance, adjustability, and durability. Ergotron wins out for budget-friendly pricing across a wide selection.
Humanscale justifies a higher cost with premium materials, effortless functionality, and aesthetic appeal.
Think about your budget, the importance of aesthetics, and any needs for extreme adjustability or weight capacity. This will steer you towards the best arm – whether Humanscale, Ergotron, or another brand – for creating your ideal desktop workspace.