Flooret Base Vs. Signature: A Comprehensive Comparison

When I set out to choose flooring for my home, I wanted something durable, stylish, and budget-friendly. After researching, I landed on Flooret’s Modin collection, specifically the Base and Signature lines.

This article compares these two luxury vinyl plank (LVP) options, exploring their features, pros, and cons to help you decide which fits your needs. Using a semantic approach, I’ll break down their differences in a conversational, user-focused way, sharing my experiences and insights. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of which Flooret model suits your space.

Comparison Table: Flooret Base Vs. Signature

My Experience With Flooret Base

When I decided to renovate my home office, I chose Flooret’s Modin Base in the Nakan color for its neutral tone and budget-friendly price.

The 6-inch-wide planks were easy to handle, and the click-lock system made installation a breeze, even for a DIYer like me with moderate experience.

I laid about 200 square feet over a weekend, and the micro-bevel edges gave the floor a sleek, modern look without drawing too much attention to the seams.

The Base line’s 20-mil wear layer held up well against my office chair rolling around and occasional coffee spills.

Its 5 mm thickness, including a 1 mm pre-attached underlayment, felt sturdy underfoot, though it’s not as cushioned as thicker options. I appreciated the 100% waterproof feature, especially when a water bottle tipped over and I didn’t panic about damage.

The texture, with its embossed-in-register design, mimicked real wood convincingly, and the low sheen kept glare minimal in my brightly lit space.

However, I noticed the thinner planks were less forgiving on my slightly uneven subfloor, requiring extra prep work to avoid soft spots. The color options, while varied, felt slightly limited compared to premium brands, and the micro-bevels didn’t provide the dramatic plank definition I later saw in the Signature line. Still, for a low-traffic space like my office, the Base delivered excellent value, and I’ve had no major issues after a year of use.

Read More: My Thoughts On Gemcore Flooring

Pros Of Flooret Base

• Affordable Price: At $2.95 per square foot, the Base line is one of the most budget-friendly rigid core LVP options, making it ideal for large projects or tight budgets.
• Easy Installation: The 6-inch-wide, 48-inch-long planks are lightweight and manageable, with a click-lock system that simplifies DIY installation.
• 100% Waterproof: Perfect for kitchens, bathrooms, or homes with pets and kids, the Base line handles spills without warping or damage.
• Durable Wear Layer: The 20-mil wear layer outperforms many competitors in its price range, resisting scratches and scuffs in moderate-traffic areas.
• Sustainably Sourced: Flooret uses FSC-certified materials, appealing to eco-conscious buyers.
• Low Maintenance: A simple sweep or damp mop keeps the floor looking pristine, and no wax or special cleaners are needed.
• Variety of Styles: With 24 colors, there’s enough variety to match most aesthetics, from modern to rustic.

The affordability of the Base line was a game-changer for me. I covered my office without breaking the bank, and the waterproof feature gave me peace of mind. The 20-mil wear layer is impressive for the price, holding up against daily wear better than some pricier brands I’ve tried. Installation was straightforward, and the pre-attached underlayment saved me from buying extra materials. While not as luxurious as higher-end options, the Base line’s balance of cost and quality makes it a solid choice for practical homeowners.

Cons Of Flooret Base

• Thinner Planks: At 5 mm, including a 1 mm underlayment, the Base feels less substantial than thicker options, potentially amplifying subfloor imperfections.
• Micro-Bevel Edges: The subtle bevels don’t provide the same visual depth as enhanced bevels, making the floor look flatter in some lighting.
• Limited Plank Size: The 6-inch width and 48-inch length may feel restrictive for those wanting a bolder, wider-plank aesthetic.
• Less Cushioning: The thinner underlayment offers less sound absorption and comfort compared to thicker models like the Signature.
• Potential Quality Concerns: Some online reviews mention wear layer durability issues over time, though I haven’t experienced this myself.
• Shipping Costs: The $199 flat-rate shipping can be steep for smaller projects, eating into the budget savings.
• Fewer Premium Features: Lacks the enhanced texture and thicker construction of higher-end lines, which may matter in high-traffic areas.

The thinner planks were my biggest gripe with the Base line. I had to spend extra time leveling my subfloor to avoid a spongy feel in spots. The micro-bevels, while clean, didn’t give the dramatic plank definition I later admired in the Signature line. For my small office, the shipping cost felt disproportionate, and I wondered if the wear layer would hold up in a busier household. These drawbacks didn’t ruin my experience, but they’re worth considering for larger or high-traffic spaces.

My Experience With Flooret Signature

For my living room, I went all-in with Flooret’s Modin Signature in Palka, drawn to its wider 9-inch planks and richer aesthetic. The installation process was similar to the Base, but the longer 72-inch planks required a helper to manage their weight and ensure tight joints. The enhanced bevels and embossed-in-register texture made the floor look like real hardwood, earning compliments from guests who couldn’t believe it was vinyl.

The 40-mil wear layer is a standout, shrugging off scratches from my dogs’ nails and heavy furniture. At 7 mm thick, including a 1.5 mm underlayment, it felt more substantial and quieter underfoot than the Base. The 100% waterproof feature was a lifesaver during a spilled wine incident, and the lifetime residential warranty gave me confidence in its longevity. However, the $4.50 per square foot price tag and $199 shipping fee stung, especially for my 400-square-foot space. The wider planks also meant more cutting for my room’s angles, which tested my DIY skills.

Overall, the Signature line felt like a premium upgrade, perfect for high-traffic areas or those wanting a luxurious look. It’s been a year, and the floor still looks flawless, but the cost and installation effort are worth weighing.

Pros Of Flooret Signature

• Industry-Leading Wear Layer: The 40-mil wear layer is unmatched in LVP, offering exceptional durability for high-traffic areas or homes with pets.
• Premium Aesthetic: The 9-inch-wide, 72-inch-long planks with enhanced bevels mimic hardwood’s depth and texture, elevating any room.
• Thicker Construction: At 7 mm, including a 1.5 mm underlayment, it feels solid and reduces noise better than thinner options.
• 100% Waterproof: Ideal for spill-prone areas, the Signature line resists water damage without warping.
• Long Warranty: A lifetime residential and 20-year commercial warranty ensures long-term reliability.
• High-Quality Materials: Made with virgin PVC and aluminum-oxide coating, it resists scratches and maintains its look.
• Designer-Friendly Styles: 24 curated colors offer versatility for modern, traditional, or eclectic designs.

The Signature line’s durability blew me away. My dogs haven’t left a mark, and the enhanced bevels make each plank pop, giving my living room a high-end feel. The thicker planks and underlayment made a noticeable difference in comfort and sound, and the waterproofing saved me during a party mishap. The wide range of styles let me find the perfect match for my decor, and the warranty adds peace of mind. If you want flooring that feels like an investment, Signature delivers.

Cons Of Flooret Signature

• Higher Cost: At $4.50 per square foot, it’s pricier than many LVPs and approaches hardwood pricing.
• Challenging Installation: The larger 9-inch by 72-inch planks are heavier and harder to cut, requiring more skill or help.
• Shipping Costs: The $199 flat-rate shipping can be a burden for smaller projects, reducing cost-effectiveness.
• Overkill for Low-Traffic Areas: The 40-mil wear layer may be excessive for spaces with minimal wear, like offices or guest rooms.
• Fewer Budget Options: The higher price limits accessibility for those on tight budgets.
• Potential Subfloor Sensitivity: Like the Base, it requires a level subfloor to avoid unevenness, though less so due to thickness.
• Limited Color Nuance: Some users note the colors lack the subtle variation of real hardwood, though I found them convincing.

The cost of the Signature line was a tough pill to swallow, especially with shipping. Installing the larger planks was trickier than the Base, and I needed a friend’s help to get clean cuts around corners. For my low-traffic office, this level of durability might’ve been overkill, and I could’ve saved money with the Base. Still, the premium look and feel justified the splurge for my living room, but budget-conscious buyers might hesitate.

Comparison With Other Brands

• Flooret vs. Coretec: Coretec’s thicker planks (up to 15 mm) offer more stability, but Flooret’s 40-mil wear layer in Signature outshines Coretec’s 30-mil maximum. Coretec’s pricing ($4-$6 per square foot) is higher than Base but comparable to Signature.
• Flooret vs. Lifeproof: Lifeproof’s 6.5 mm thickness and 22-mil wear layer sit between Flooret’s Base and Signature, but its $3-$4 per square foot price is closer to Base. Flooret’s embossed texture feels more realistic than Lifeproof’s smoother finish.
• Flooret vs. Shaw: Shaw offers similar 20-mil wear layers in its budget lines, but Flooret’s Base is cheaper at $2.95 versus Shaw’s $3.50-$5. Shaw’s premium lines lack the 40-mil wear layer of Flooret’s Signature.
• Flooret vs. Cali Bamboo: Cali Bamboo’s 8 mm thickness is sturdier than Base but not Signature, and its $3.50-$5 pricing is less competitive than Base. Flooret’s wider style range outpaces Cali’s limited palette.
• Flooret vs. Pergo: Pergo’s 12-20 mil wear layers and $3-$4.50 pricing align with Flooret’s Base, but Signature’s durability and aesthetics are superior. Pergo’s installation is similar but lacks Flooret’s FSC certification.
• Flooret vs. Mohawk: Mohawk’s 6-8 mm thickness matches Signature, but its $4-$6 pricing is steeper. Flooret’s 40-mil wear layer trumps Mohawk’s 20-30 mil, and its direct-to-consumer model cuts costs.

I found Flooret’s Base to be a better value than Lifeproof and Pergo for budget-conscious projects, while Signature competes with premium brands like Coretec and Mohawk at a lower price point. The 40-mil wear layer is a standout, and Flooret’s sustainable sourcing adds an edge over Shaw and Cali Bamboo. However, Coretec’s thicker planks might suit uneven subfloors better, and Mohawk’s brand recognition could sway some buyers. Flooret’s direct model and style variety made it my top pick.

Read More: My Thoughts On Lux Flooring

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion: For Flooret Base Or Signature?

Choosing between Flooret’s Base and Signature depends on your budget and needs. If you’re outfitting a low-traffic space or working with a tight budget, the Base’s $2.95 per square foot price and 20-mil wear layer offer great value without sacrificing quality. For high-traffic areas or a premium look, the Signature’s 40-mil wear layer and 9-inch planks deliver unmatched durability and style, though at $4.50 per square foot, it’s a bigger investment. Both are waterproof and easy to install, so you can’t go wrong. Pick Base for savings, Signature for luxury—you decide what fits your home best.