EveryDrop Water Filters: How Do Filter 1 and Filter 2 Compare?

If you own a Whirlpool or Maytag refrigerator with a built-in water filtration system, you’re probably familiar with EveryDrop water filters. But with their filter 1, filter 2, filter 3 and more, it can get confusing trying to figure out which one you need.

In this article, we’ll focus on EveryDrop filter 1 Vs. filter 2 – examining the key differences, pros and cons, and what each one is best suited for.

A Brief Comparison Table

Feature	Filter 1	Filter 2
Part Number	EDR1RXD1 or EDR1RXD1B	EDR2RXD1
Compatibility	Most Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, JennAir models with EveryDrop system	Same compatible models as Filter 1
Contaminant Reduction	Chlorine, particulates, heavy metals, cysts, asbestos, turbidity, etc.	Enhanced reduction of pharmaceuticals and microscopic parasites
Cost	More affordable	Costs more than Filter 1
Lifespan	6 months or 300 gallons	6 months or 300 gallons
Flow Rate	0.5 gallons per minute	0.5 gallons per minute
Certifications	Certified by NSF International	Certified by NSF International. Meets more standards than Filter 1.
Design	Standard cylindrical filter, twist-in installation	Same design. Has darker band for identification.

EveryDrop Filter 1 Overview

EveryDrop filter 1 is designed to deliver cleaner, fresher-tasting water and ice by reducing contaminants from your water supply.

Here are some key features and specifications:

• Part Number: EDR1RXD1 or EDR1RXD1B (alternate version)
• Compatible Refrigerator Models: Designed for most Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, JennAir models with EveryDrop ice and water dispenser systems. Not compatible with EveryDrop filter 3 or 4 refrigerators.
• Removes: Chlorine taste and odor, particulate matter, benzene, asbestos, cadmium, lead, cysts, lindane, toxaphene, turbidity and zinc.
• Water Filter Capacity: 6 months or 300 gallons.
• Flow Rate: 0.5 gallons per minute.

The EveryDrop 1 filter uses a carbon block filtration media to reduce contaminants through a combination of mechanical filtration, ion exchange and adsorption. It is certified by NSF International to reduce substances like lead, mercury, benzene, asbestos and more.

EveryDrop Filter 2 Overview

EveryDrop filter 2 builds upon filter 1 by offering enhanced contaminant reduction.

Here’s an overview:

• Part Number: EDR2RXD1
• Compatible Refrigerator Models: Designed for most Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, JennAir models with EveryDrop ice and water dispenser systems. Not compatible with filter 3 or 4 models.
• Removes: All contaminants reduced by Filter 1, plus additional pharmaceuticals and waterborne parasites.
• Water Filter Capacity: 6 months or 300 gallons.
• Flow Rate: 0.5 gallons per minute.

The filter 2 uses carbon block filtration like filter 1, but adds an extra layer of coconut shell carbon for even more adsorptive sites to trap contaminants. This allows it to further reduce pharmaceuticals and microscopic waterborne parasites like Cryptosporidium and Giardia.

Comparing EveryDrop Filter 1 And Filter 2

Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s compare some of the key differences between these two models:

Contaminant Reduction

• Both reduce chlorine, particulates, heavy metals like lead and mercury, and other common contaminants.
• Filter 2 offers enhanced reduction of pharmaceuticals and microscopic parasites.

Cost

• Filter 1 is the more affordable option.
• Filter 2 costs more for its additional contaminant reduction capabilities.

Lifespan

• Both filters have a 6 month or 300 gallon capacity.

Flow Rate

• Both filters have a flow rate of 0.5 gallons per minute.

Compatibility

• Both filters are designed for most Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, JennAir refrigerators originally equipped with EveryDrop systems.
• Neither are compatible with EveryDrop filter 3 or 4 refrigerator models.

Certifications

• Both are certified by NSF International. Filter 2 meets more NSF standards for its extra contaminant reductions.

Design

• The filters have the same physical design and twist-in installation.
• Filter 2 has a darker band at the bottom for visual identification.

Which Should You Choose: Filter 1 Or 2?

So which EveryDrop model is right for you?

Here are some things to consider:

If your main goal is improving taste and odor: Filter 1 will provide solid performance at a lower price point. Its activated carbon is highly effective at adsorbing the chlorine used in most public water systems.

If you want enhanced contaminant reduction: Filter 2 is the way to go. The extra layer of coconut shell carbon gives it more adsorptive sites to trap additional pharmaceuticals and microscopic parasites. This makes it ideal if you’re concerned about these specific contaminants.

If you have a filter 3/4 compatible refrigerator: Neither of these filters will fit your model. You’ll need to choose from EveryDrop filter 3 or 4 instead.

If you’re replacing an existing filter: Check your owner’s manual or existing filter part number to determine whether you need filter 1 or 2.

If you’re unsure which you need: EveryDrop has an online filter finder tool on their website to help match you with the right one based on your refrigerator model.

Also watch the video!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Also Read: Choose Between Aquasana And LifeSource.

The Bottom Line

While EveryDrop filter 2 performs better when it comes to pharmaceutical and parasite reduction, filter 1 still delivers solid overall performance, especially for improving water taste and odor.

Make sure to use EveryDrop’s filter finder to choose the right model number for your refrigerator. And no matter which you choose, be sure to replace it every 6 months or 300 gallons as indicated to keep your water at its best quality and flavor.