Curie Vs. Native Deodorant: Which Natural Deodorant Is Better?

Deodorant is a daily essential for most people. But with growing concerns around potentially harmful ingredients like aluminum in conventional antiperspirants and deodorants, natural deodorants have surged in popularity.

Two of the most popular natural deodorant brands right now are Curie and Native. But how do these two natural deodorants compare? Which one is better?

A Brief Comparison Table

Comparison	Curie	Native
Scents Offered	6 scents	16 scents
Key Ingredients	Magnesium, arrowroot powder, coconut oil	Baking soda, tapioca starch, shea butter
Sensitive Skin Option	Yes	No
Packaging	Plastic tubes	Cardboard sticks
Average Price	$12 per stick	$7 per stick
Odor Protection	Very good for daily use	Excellent, even for heavy sweating
Skin Care	More moisturizing butters, unscented for sensitive skin	Baking soda can be irritating for some
Reviews	4.3 out of 5 stars	4.4 out of 5 stars

Overview Of Curie And Native

Curie was founded in 2017 by two female entrepreneurs who wanted to create a safe, effective natural deodorant after one of them was diagnosed with breast cancer at age 26. Curie deodorants are aluminum-free, paraben-free, and free of other harsh chemicals.

They contain ingredients like magnesium, arrowroot powder, coconut oil, and essential oils. Curie deodorants come in both scented and unscented versions, in a variety of scents like coconut lime, lavender sage, and more.

Native launched in 2015 and was one of the first natural deodorant brands to really gain mainstream popularity. Native deodorants are also aluminum-free, paraben-free, and free of other potentially harmful ingredients.

Instead, they rely on ingredients like baking soda, shea butter, and tapioca starch to neutralize odor. Native deodorants come in plastic-free cardboard packaging and a wide selection of fun scents like coconut & vanilla, lavender & rose, and cucumber & mint.

So in summary, both Curie and Native are aluminum-free natural deodorants made with safe, clean ingredients. But there are some differences between the brands too.

Also Read: Comparison Between Duradry and Drysol

Key Differences Between Curie And Native

While Curie and Native are both natural deodorants with similar ingredients, there are a few key differences between the two brands:

Scent options: Native currently offers 16 different scents, while Curie has 6 scent options. So Native offers a much wider range of scents.

Ingredient differences: While there is some overlap, Native and Curie do use some different main ingredients. Curie relies more on ingredients like magnesium and arrowroot powder, while Native uses more baking soda and tapioca starch.

Sensitive skin formulas: Curie offers an unscented sensitive skin formula, while Native currently does not have a separate sensitive skin option.

Packaging: Native comes in plastic-free, recyclable cardboard stick packaging. Curie uses traditional plastic tube packaging (although they state they are working on more sustainable packaging).

Price: Native is priced a bit lower than Curie on average. A 2-pack of Native deodorant is $14 while one stick of Curie is $12.

So in summary, the main differences are in the scent range, ingredients, packaging, price, and sensitive skin offerings. But overall, the two brands take a similar natural approach to deodorant.

Curie Deodorant Ingredients & How It Works

Curie relies on a handful of main ingredients to help neutralize odor and soak up wetness:

• Magnesium helps neutralize odor by creating an unfavorable environment for bacteria growth.
• Arrowroot powder absorbs moisture.
• Coconut oil soothes skin and provides a smooth application.
• Shea butter also helps moisturize skin.
• Essential oils like lavender, eucalyptus, and lemon provide scent.

Curie avoids aluminum, parabens, phthalates, and other potentially harmful ingredients commonly found in conventional antiperspirants and deodorants.

According to Curie, their deodorant works by using ingredients like magnesium and arrowroot powder to stop odor at the source. The magnesium makes it harder for odor-causing bacteria to thrive, while the arrowroot powder absorbs sweat. Plus, the coconut oil and shea butter provide moisture to help soothe skin.

Native Deodorant Ingredients & How It Works

Here are the main ingredients Native uses in their deodorant formula:

• Baking soda helps neutralize odor.
• Tapioca starch absorbs moisture.
• Shea butter & coconut oil condition and soothe skin.
• Vitamin E is an antioxidant that protects skin.
• Essential oils provide scents.

Like Curie, Native avoids aluminum, parabens, phthalates, and other questionable ingredients.

Native says their deodorant works through a combination of the baking soda neutralizing odor, the tapioca starch absorbing moisture, and the shea butter and coconut oil providing soothing moisture.

The baking soda creates an alkaline environment that makes it harder for odor-causing bacteria to thrive.

So while the specific ingredients differ, both Curie and Native work in a similar way to combat odor and wetness through absorption and by making the underarm an unfavorable environment for odor-causing bacteria.

In-Depth Comparison Of Key Features Between Curie And Native

Curie Vs. Native: Scent Options Comparison

One of the biggest differences between Curie and Native is the variety of scents offered.

Curie currently offers deodorant in 6 different scents:

• Unscented Sensitive Skin
• Coconut Lime
• Lavender Sage
• Grapefruit Bergamot
• Vanilla Almond
• Matcha Tea

Native offers a much wider selection of 16 scents like:

• Coconut & Vanilla
• Cucumber & Mint
• Lavender & Rose
• Citrus & Herbal Musk
• Mango & Pear

So if having a wide range of scents to choose from is important to you, Native offers far more options. Curie keeps it simple with 6 scented formulas focused on natural scents like citrus, lavender, and vanilla.

Curie Vs. Native: Application & Texture Comparison

In terms of application and texture, Curie and Native deodorants are quite similar.

Both go on smoothly, feel lightweight, and absorb quickly without leaving behind sticky residue or stains on clothes. The shea butter and coconut oil in the formulas help both glide on easily.

Curie’s texture is described as smooth, velvety, and lightweight. Native is also lightweight with a creamy, smooth consistency.

For both Curie and Native, a little deodorant goes a long way, and the sticks last about 2-3 months with daily use.

One small difference is that Native’s cardboard applicator feels slightly smoother gliding on than Curie’s plastic applicator. But overall, both offer easy, mess-free application.

Curie Vs. Native: Effectiveness at Odor & Wetness Protection

So how do Curie and Native compare when it comes to actually preventing odor and wetness?

Overall, most reviews indicate good effectiveness from both Curie and Native deodorants. However, some key points:

• Both brands recommend applying at night and in the morning for best odor protection.
• With natural deodorant, odor protection is more variable than conventional options, so effectiveness can depend on body chemistry.
• Native seems to be slightly more effective for heavy sweating and extreme odor according to some reviews. Its baking soda formula may help it edge out Curie in very high sweat situations.
• For daily light-moderate sweating, both seem to work well for odor and wetness protection.
• Those with sensitive skin seem to have better luck with Curie’s unscented sensitive skin formula over Native.

So while both are effective natural deodorants overall, Native may handle heavy sweating and extreme body odor a bit better, while Curie’s sensitive skin formula is ideal for irritation-prone underarms.

Also Read: Choose Between Hello And Native Deodorant.

Curie Vs. Native: Skin Care & Sensitivity Comparison

Since they don’t contain pore-clogging aluminum, parabens, and other iffy ingredients, both Curie and Native are good natural deodorant options for skin health.

However, Native contains baking soda, which can be irritating for some skin types. Curie leaves out baking soda and instead relies on more soothing ingredients like magnesium, arrowroot powder, and shea butter.

Curie also offers an unscented formula specifically designed for sensitive skin. It contains just five ingredients and leaves out any essential oils that could cause irritation.

So for those with sensitivity or who find baking soda irritating, Curie seems to be the better choice over Native when it comes to skin care.

Watch this video to know more about Curie!

Curie Vs. Native: Pricing & Value Comparison

When it comes to pricing, Native deodorants are a little more affordable than Curie on average:

• Curie deodorants: $12 per stick
• Native deodorants: $14 for a 2-pack, so $7 per stick

Both brands offer subscription ordering options to save on the cost per stick. Overall, Native offers a very competitive price point in the natural deodorant space. Curie is priced on the higher end for natural deodorants but does use high quality ingredients.

Considering the comparable quality and performance between the two brands, Native offers better value for the price. But Curie deodorants may be worth the splurge for some who prefer the sensitive skin formula or more minimal ingredient list.

Curie Vs. Native: Reviews & Ratings Comparison

Both Curie and Native score well in customer reviews and ratings across online stores and review sites:

Curie

• 4/5 stars on Curie’s website based on 130+ reviews
• 4.1/5 on Influenster based on 175+ reviews
• 4.3 stars on Google reviews

Native

• 4.3/5 stars on Native’s website based on 1500+ reviews
• 4.5/5 on Influenster based on 2900+ reviews
• 4.4 stars on Google reviews

So both brands have very satisfied customers that love their deodorants. Common feedback is that they glide on smooth, provide good odor protection, and are gentler on skin than conventional antiperspirants.

Negative reviews tend to focus on odor protection not being as strong as some would like. But the majority seem very pleased with both Curie and Native.

Also Read: Comparison Between OSEA And Biossance.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Final Thought

When choosing between Curie and Native natural deodorants, here are some key factors to help decide which is better for your needs:

Sensitive skin: Curie’s unscented sensitive skin formula wins.

Budget buy: Native is more affordable.

Wide scent options: Native offers far more scents.

Minimal ingredient list: Curie focuses on fewer key ingredients.

Heavy sweating/odor: Native may control this better.

Skin-soothing moisturization: Curie’s butters may be more moisturizing.

Sustainable packaging: Native’s cardboard over Curie’s plastic tubes.

Both Curie and Native make excellent natural deodorants free of concerning ingredients like aluminum and parabens. Choosing between the two brands comes down to personal factors like scent preferences, skin type, budget, and sustainability values.

The good news is that you can feel confident that either Curie or Native will provide safe, effective odor and wetness protection.