Toilet paper is an essential household purchase that most of us give little thought to. As long as it gets the job done, we’re happy. But with premium brands like Cottonelle offering toilet papers designed for different needs, it’s worth taking a closer look to find the best option for you.
In this article, we’ll compare two popular Cottonelle variants – Ultra Clean and Ultra Comfort – to help you decide which suits your needs. We’ll break down the key differences, pros and cons, features and frequently asked questions about these two toilet paper types.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Ultra Clean | Ultra Comfort |
| Cleaning Ability | Excellent, textured ripples scrub thoroughly | Good, gently cleans with soft ripples |
| Strength | Very durable, withstands vigorous wiping | Less durable but still decent strength |
| Softness | Rough, papery texture | Extremely soft, cushiony, lotion-infused |
| Price | Cheaper per package | More expensive per package |
| Rolls Per Package | 12 double rolls | 9 mega rolls |
| Septic/Plumber Safety | Yes, septic safe | Yes, septic safe |
An Overview Of Cottonelle Ultra Clean And Ultra Comfort
Cottonelle is one of the leading toilet paper brands in the US. They offer several different lines, with Ultra Clean and Ultra Comfort being two of their most popular.
Ultra Clean is designed for superior cleaning ability. It has ripples to provide extra scrubbing power to remove residue thoroughly. The paper itself also has a more textured feel compared to regular toilet paper.
Ultra Comfort, on the other hand, prioritizes softness and gentleness. It has cushiony ripples and a silky texture for a plush, luxurious feel. The layers are also infused with lotion to prevent irritation.
While both aim to provide a premium toilet paper experience, Ultra Clean focuses on cleaning strength whereas Ultra Comfort is all about pampering your skin. Below, we’ll explore the key differences in more detail.
Key Feature Differences
Here are some of the main features that set Cottonelle Ultra Clean and Ultra Comfort apart:
- Cleaning Ability
Ultra Clean is the clear winner when it comes to cleaning power. Its textured ripples allow it to scrub and remove residue without excessive wiping. By comparison, Ultra Comfort has less pronounced ripples that lightly clean but prioritize softness.
- Strength
Ultra Clean is also noticeably tougher and more durable than Ultra Comfort. Its paper can withstand vigorous wiping without tearing or shredding. Ultra Comfort sacrifices some strength for its cushy feel.
- Softness
For a silky-smooth, pillowy feel, Ultra Comfort is far softer against the skin. Its lotion-infused layers practically melt in your hand. Ultra Clean has more of a papery texture better suited for scrubbing.
- Sewer and Septic Safety
Both varieties are septic safe and clear plumbing with no issues. Ultra Comfort may take a bit longer to break down due to its sturdier ripples. But neither should clog drains or cause build-up when flushed.
- Rolls Per Package
Ultra Clean packs have 12 double rolls while Ultra Comfort has just 9 mega rolls. However, the longer length of the mega rolls makes the total square footage roughly equal between the two.
- Price
Ultra Clean tends to retail for $1-3 less than Ultra Comfort per package. But the price per square foot is very similar between them. Ultra Comfort adds value through enhanced softness.
As you can see, Ultra Clean excels at cleaning while Ultra Comfort excels at softness and comfort. But there are some other nuanced pros and cons to weigh up too.
Also watch the review video of Cottonelle!
Pros And Cons Of Ultra Clean
Pros
- Exceptional cleaning ability to remove residue
- Textured ripples scrub without excessive wiping
- Durable paper withstands vigorous wiping
- 12 double rolls (308 2-ply sheets per roll)
- Septic and plumbing safe
- Usually cheaper per package than Ultra Comfort
Cons
- Not as soft or cushy as Ultra Comfort
- Can feel papery or rough against skin
- Less soothing if you have sensitive skin
- May pill if used dry or cause minor irritation
Pros And Cons Of Ultra Comfort
Pros
- Luxuriously soft, cushy feel
- Lotion-infused for a silky texture
- Extra gentle on skin, even if sensitive
- 9 mega rolls (352 2-ply sheets per roll)
- Just as septic and plumber safe as Ultra Clean
- Leaves you feeling pampered and indulgent
Cons
- Not as effective at scrubbing and cleaning
- Weaker, less durable paper
- More expensive than Ultra Clean
- Takes slightly longer to break down in sewer
- Riffling can pill if too delicate
Which Is Best For You?
Choosing between Cottonelle Ultra Clean and Ultra Comfort comes down to your priorities.
If you want superior cleaning power that leaves you feeling refreshed, Ultra Clean is the best choice. The textured paper will remove residue without repeated wiping or plumber issues.
But if pampering your skin is most important, Ultra Comfort can’t be beat. The soft, cushiony feel provides a little luxury every time you use the toilet. It may not scrub quite as vigorously but still gets the job done in a gentle, soothing way.
Either toilet paper is a step up from basic options in terms of quality. And they both provide great value given their reasonable prices.
Ultra Clean suits households who use a lot of toilet paper and need an effective cleaning experience. Big families or those with messy bowel movements benefit most from its scrubbing ripples and durability.
Meanwhile, Ultra Comfort is ideal if you have sensitive skin or hemorrhoids. Its softness prevents redness or irritation from aggressive wiping. It also nicely indulges solo users who want to feel pampered.
With either toilet paper choice, you can’t go wrong with Cottonelle Ultra. And the difference in price between them is minor. Pick the one catering best to your household’s needs and bathroom priorities.
Also Read: Comparison Between Bounty Family Roll And Double Roll.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
The main difference is that Ultra Clean has a textured, rippled surface for scrubbing away residue. Ultra Comfort has a smoother, more delicately rippled surface that prioritizes softness over cleaning power. Ultra Clean is also a bit tougher and cheaper than Ultra Comfort.
With regular Cottonelle toilet paper, the focus is on a balance of basic softness and cleaning ability. The Ultra Clean variant skews towards improved cleaning while Ultra Comfort skews towards enhanced softness and comfort.
Of all Cottonelle varieties, Ultra Comfort takes the prize for the softest feel against your skin. Its lotion-infused paper with lightly rippled texture has an amazingly silky, plush feel. It pampers your skin while still gently cleaning.
Yes, Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care toilet paper is fully septic safe. Its thicker paper and cushiony ripples take a bit longer to dissolve but won’t clog or damage plumbing systems. As long as you use normal amounts, it shouldn’t cause issues or blockages.
Also Read: Is Pampers Sensitive Wipes Better Than Aqua Pure?
The Bottom Line
When it comes down to Cottonelle Ultra Clean VS. Ultra Comfort, you really can’t go wrong. These premium toilet papers represent the best Cottonelle has to offer.
Choose Ultra Clean if heavy duty cleaning is your top priority. Opt for the indulgent softness of Ultra Comfort to pamper your skin. Either provides great value, effectiveness, and septic/plumber safety.
Focus on your household’s needs and bathroom priorities. Both toilet papers will leave you feeling clean and comfortable – just in slightly different ways. With Cottonelle Ultra, you get a little luxury with every wipe!